Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Collective Farming and Equal Distribution of Food, Can it Work?!

No, no one works for free.

it's called a kibutz

Originally posted by Kommunistisch
Collective Farming and Equal Distribution of Food, Can it Work?!


sure, maybe if you want to shift society and the way it progress's to an agricultural based society. Which by the way I think is a bad idea and am against.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
No, no one works for free.

In a socialist society, you aren't working for free. You got to work, do your job, and come home to a house and food. I think it's a good idea, but there are some problems that need to be fixed.

Originally posted by Kommunistisch
In a socialist society, you aren't working for free. You got to work, do your job, and come home to a house and food. I think it's a good idea, but there are some problems that need to be fixed.

Yes, I'am aware of the "The Bread maker prepares bread for Shoe maker and the Shoe maker prepares shoes for the Bread maker" socialist idea.

Is just a idea which put in practice will have it's drawbacks.

Also, Kibutz and the Amish are small societies...try Collective Farming on a larger nation scale....no way it will work.

this is why mutualism is the most ideal economic system, not capitolism or collectivism

Originally posted by Kommunistisch
Collective Farming and Equal Distribution of Food, Can it Work?!

No,

If we were not human, it would work. There will always be those who, because of opportunity, will take advantage and have more then others.

It worked for the "Flower Children" of the 60's.........partytime

Originally posted by debbiejo
It worked for the "Flower Children" of the 60's.........partytime

And now look at them, some of the biggest capitalists around.

Yes it can.

No, because there is no motivation to work.

it works in very small communities. otherwise, mutualism is our only hope.

Originally posted by Kommunistisch
Collective Farming and Equal Distribution of Food, Can it Work?!


posted, ironically by someone called Kommunistisch