Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Kate or Jack? Sanctuary thinks Kate would win because she's a criminal, but Jacks a man with a plan. And he's a doctor so he could fix himself.

How about...who gives a crap?

There are many variables involved in fights which could make the outcome swing either way.

Sure Jack is a doctor, but how could he work on himself in the middle of a fight?

what are they winning and ...huh?

a fight....im guessing...

that's.......that's...that is seriously a ridiculous question. Kate versus Jack in a fight? There's no way Kate could take jack. First off, Kate gets taken out in miniature wrestling matches with Sawyer tons of time, whereas Jack pwn3d Sawyer in "Confidence Man"

aye, what a thread.

Originally posted by Itzak
Kate or Jack? Sanctuary thinks Kate would win because she's a criminal, but Jacks a man with a plan. And he's a doctor so he could fix himself.

your an idiot

Originally posted by QuincE
that's.......that's...that is seriously a ridiculous question. Kate versus Jack in a fight? There's no way Kate could take jack. First off, Kate gets taken out in miniature wrestling matches with Sawyer tons of time, whereas Jack pwn3d Sawyer in "Confidence Man"

aye, what a thread.

Exactly. Now go tell that to Sanctuary.

Originally posted by KillTheLight
your an idiot

Why thank you for pointing that out, but if you would be so knid... go tell Sanctuary Jack wins, and that she owes me $5. Because she didn't think Jack could win. 1234

Kate is sneakier! And she has more experience




I can't believe you actually made this thread

Also, I think it depends on the location, and if they can have weapons or not 1234

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_
Also, I think it depends on the location, and if they can have weapons or not 1234

Location: The hatch.

No weapons. If they did Jack still has a chance though.

Originally posted by Itzak
Location: The hatch.

No weapons. If they did Jack still has a chance though.
What?!
If this is a real life thing, Kate can win easily, she's manipulative and sneaky.
If it's like in a ring or something, then Jack, because he's physically stronger.

The hatch would actually be the most ideal place if you think about it. Seriously, Kate doesn't have a chance in a hand-to-hand fight, how many times has Sawyer beaten her in those fights? A lot of times. And part of the reason I say Jack being doctor is so important is that he would know where all the vital points on the body are so he could do some serious damage.

Originally posted by Itzak
The hatch would actually be the most ideal place if you think about it. Seriously, Kate doesn't have a chance in a hand-to-hand fight, how many times has Sawyer beaten her in those fights? A lot of times. And part of the reason I say Jack being doctor is so important is that he would know where all the vital points on the body are so he could do some serious damage.
Yeah, I didn't mean in a "hand-to-hand" fight. Kate is crafty! And good with a gun

Oh now you tell me. Fine. I would actually like to see this fight, hmm I think it'd be pretty good.

But anyways... Even if they had guns, it would still be in a small place. And Jack with a gun = Kate pwned. It's as simple as that.

Originally posted by Itzak
Oh now you tell me. Fine. I would actually like to see this fight, hmm I think it'd be pretty good.

But anyways... Even if they had guns, it would still be in a small place. And Jack with a gun = Kate pwned. It's as simple as that.
no2 Kate would think of a plan mwahaha

And also, at first you said Jack was better purely because he was a guy so your arguement was faulty to begin with

And you spelt "would" wrong

How is it faulty to begin with?

Only because I wanted to see if you would notice. Which wasn't until just now. So there...

Originally posted by Itzak
How is it faulty to begin with?

Only because I wanted to see if you would notice. Which wasn't until just now. So there...
You had no real arguement to start with

i think Charlie would pwn them all 1v1...end of damn story, all he has to do is drug them and he wins my gawd oh btw sanctuary whos that girl in your sig, shes purdy

It's Ayumi Hamasaki

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_
You had no real arguement to start with

Sure I did, answer the question. And so far nobody has said anything about Kate winning. So you might as well realises Jack wins.

Originally posted by Marth18
i think Charlie would pwn them all 1v1...end of damn story, all he has to do is drug them and he wins my gawd oh btw sanctuary whos that girl in your sig, shes purdy

That's true. Drug them...

Originally posted by Itzak
Sure I did, answer the question. And so far nobody has said anything about Kate winning. So you might as well realises Jack wins.


mhm

Kate would still win
She'd think of a plan, she's more manipulative and experienced.

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_
mhm

Kate would still win
She'd think of a plan, she's more manipulative and experienced.

Running out of reasons my dear? I think I've already heard those.

Jack is smart, where as Kate is clever. He would use the room to his advantage. He would think of ways for her to waste her bullets.

Originally posted by Itzak
Running out of reasons my dear? I think I've already heard those.

Jack is smart, where as Kate is clever. He would use the room to his advantage. He would think of ways for her to waste her bullets.
Kate would see right through it!
And also she would be able to lull him in to a false sense of security

Jack would get owned by Kate.

Just because Kate is a criminal doesn't make her a good fighter. She just (SPOILER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) Blew up a house. She essplodes one house and she's supposed to be Jackie Chan or something?

Id say, who cares...................Sawyer would own kate...in bed

Originally posted by ~Mitsurugi~
Jack would get owned by Kate.
w00tOriginally posted by QuincE
Just because Kate is a criminal doesn't make her a good fighter. She just (SPOILER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) Blew up a house. She essplodes one house and she's supposed to be Jackie Chan or something?
But it means she's more experienced, and she'd have a good strategy

Kate wouldnt hurt jack, jack wouldnt hurt kate.........i on the other hand

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_
w00t
But it means she's more experienced, and she'd have a good strategy

More experienced in what? Running away? Because that's really all we've seen Kate do in her past. Never has she fought anyone. Jack on the other hand has fought Ethan twice, and traded blows with Sawyer on occasion. Kate's not a strategist, just a girl on the run.

I guess it depends on what type of fight it is

Originally posted by Marth18
Id say, who cares...................Sawyer would own kate...in bed

nope, this is the part where, YOU WRONG!......behind the scenes i killed Kate and i was forced 2 take kates place...Whoops, my bad

Really? cause i killed sawyer and took sawyers place, GOSH DAMNIT I THOUGHT YOU WERE KATE

.....wait a sec shock

HA! made u look!
I'M SOOOO BORED! ENTERTAIN ME!!!! sum1 please cry

Freak and Marth...in LOST? Were doomed... :rolleye:

Kate would screw Jack over easily. Jack is too much of a goody goody 2 screw her over...Kate would give a shit

yea, Freeak is the new pregnant lady

Originally posted by QuincE
More experienced in what? Running away? Because that's really all we've seen Kate do in her past. Never has she fought anyone. Jack on the other hand has fought Ethan twice, and traded blows with Sawyer on occasion. Kate's not a strategist, just a girl on the run.
mhm If they both had guns though... And I think Kate would come up with a good strategy!

Originally posted by Marth18
yea, Freeak is the new pregnant lady

shock fool_fly

i think if they were to get in a fight, they'd have sex instead

Kate n Sawyer? ....gawd shes a lucky biatch if that happens lol...

no hes a lucky biatch

chair UR WRONG! HE'S the lucky biatch

Originally posted by Marth18
i think if they were to get in a fight, they'd have sex instead

i want to watch sawyer and jack 'fight' then droolio

HA! n i have a front row seat

Originally posted by PsychoFreeak
chair UR WRONG! HE'S the lucky biatch

ha, somethings wrong here... shock
i meant... SHE'S!***
*shivers then dies* faintthud

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_

But it means she's more experienced, and she'd have a good strategy

You haven't explained what exactly she's more "experienced" in. She hasn't fought anyone. And she what kind of "strategy" could she make? Beat Jack before he beats her?

good call lol

anyway'z, i was just snoopin round in Lost Media (which i havent done in AGES) and saw this pic...
who rekons that if he lost the shirt but stood int hat same pose, he's be half hot?
yeh ok *leaves*

ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

not expacting u 2 answer that, stress less lol

He has a weird looking face shapeness......... like that

...Thats the point lol....
c'mon! Both sawyer and charlie look hot wen they're angry! so y not Jin too?

because this is the "Who would win thread".........but jin can kick sawyer, charlie, locke, jack, EVERYONS BUTT

Originally posted by QuincE
You haven't explained what exactly she's more "experienced" in. She hasn't fought anyone. And she what kind of "strategy" could she make? Beat Jack before he beats her?
She's a good liar and she'd probably be able to trick him. mwahaha


This thread confuses me.

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_
She's a good liar and she'd probably be able to trick him. mwahaha


This thread confuses me.

Hmm...a good liar? Shall we flashback? From what I recall, the last time Kate lied to Jack (during the opening of the silver case.) Jack saw through her lies about "the man I loved" and caught her during her "trick" of the hands during the keyswap. So no, Kate wouldn't be able to trick Jack. She'd be pwned. I can't believe this is a thread. Jack vs Kate? Jack would murder her.

Originally posted by QuincE
Hmm...a good liar? Shall we flashback? From what I recall, the last time Kate lied to Jack (during the opening of the silver case.) Jack saw through her lies about "the man I loved" and caught her during her "trick" of the hands during the keyswap. So no, Kate wouldn't be able to trick Jack. She'd be pwned. I can't believe this is a thread. Jack vs Kate? Jack would murder her.
Maybe part of her wanted him to know, or she didn't want to lie to him.

If they were really put against each other I think she'd be able to trick him.

Wow, jin is now my favorite character in this show, he kicks ass fking best character ever, i missed episode 11 season 2 did somthing happen to Michael in that episode? cause i havnt seen him anywhere past that but anyways, JIN IS THE COOLEST BASTARD EVER

Originally posted by _Sanctuary_
Maybe part of her wanted him to know, or she didn't want to lie to him.

If they were really put against each other I think she'd be able to trick him.

Provide evidence! I've shot down your theories and backed up my own claims. Kate wouldn't last three seconds. I have no idea why they would fight each other, but Jack would obviously beat her. She doesn't seem athletic or durable in a bout at all. And no, you obviously don't know Kate that well if you think on some level "She wanted Jack to know." This is because Kate protects her secret the best she can. She does that during the entire show. She desperately didn't want ANYONE to know her secret (hence one of the reasons she so dearly wanted the Marshall out of the picture.)

wow Big Post's

Originally posted by Marth18
Wow, jin is now my favorite character in this show, he kicks ass fking best character ever, i missed episode 11 season 2 did somthing happen to Michael in that episode? cause i havnt seen him anywhere past that but anyways, JIN IS THE COOLEST BASTARD EVER

ROCK ON!!!

JIN > KATE!!!!!!!!!

.....