Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Harry is teally stupid in this book. I mean if he had never gone down to try capturing the stone before voldemort, voldemort would never have been close getting the stone. Dumbledore had no reason to worry, the stone was perfectly safe. It is a fackt. I'm out..

Originally posted by vanice
Harry is teally stupid in this book. I mean if he had never gone down to try capturing the stone before voldemort, voldemort would never have been close getting the stone. Dumbledore had no reason to worry, the stone was perfectly safe. It is a fackt. I'm out..

Harry is really stupid in this book. I mean, if he had never gone down to try to capture the Stone before Voldemort, Voldemort would never have been so close to getting the stone. Dumbledore had no reason to worry, because the stone was perfectly safe. And that, is a Fact. vanice out...

.... What?

Originally posted by Barker
Harry is really stupid in this book. I mean, if he had never gone down to try to capture the Stone before Voldemort, Voldemort would never have been so close to getting the stone. Dumbledore had no reason to worry, because the stone was perfectly safe. And that, is a Fact. vanice out...


and your point is?

spell properly

maybe this person is drunk when i used to get drunk id write some crazy posts

Originally posted by jedi sarah
maybe this person is drunk when i used to get drunk id write some crazy posts

lol

Originally posted by vanice
Harry is teally stupid in this book. I mean if he had never gone down to try capturing the stone before voldemort, voldemort would never have been close getting the stone. Dumbledore had no reason to worry, the stone was perfectly safe. It is a fackt. I'm out..




ok....

Originally posted by jedi sarah
maybe this person is drunk when i used to get drunk id write some crazy posts

they're not drunk. they actually make a good point because Dumbledoor said that only someon who wanted the stone but didn't want to use it would be able to get it. therefor, Voldy would never have been able to get it. In fact, Harr'y's going down to save it actually put it in jeopardy because he could get it out of the mirror and Voldy almost got it.

Sooo basically your saying its all Harrys fault

nothing is anyone's fault because voldemort didn't get the stone. What I and vanice are saying is that Voldemort would never have had the opportunity to get the stone if Harry didn't try to save it.

Originally posted by Rapscallion
nothing is anyone's fault because voldemort didn't get the stone. What I and vanice are saying is that Voldemort would never have had the opportunity to get the stone if Harry didn't try to save it.

yeah i agree

Originally posted by Rapscallion
they're not drunk. they actually make a good point because Dumbledoor said that only someon who wanted the stone but didn't want to use it would be able to get it. therefor, Voldy would never have been able to get it. In fact, Harr'y's going down to save it actually put it in jeopardy because he could get it out of the mirror and Voldy almost got it.

I suggest you read the text you qouted again...

huh?

Originally posted by vanice
I suggest you read the text you qouted again...

why are they using some alternative definition of the word "drunk" that I don't know abour?

I think a better way to ensure the stone was safe would have been for Dumbledore to have put all the security and things he had up to safeguard the stone then put a fake in it's place and keep the real stone on a shelf in his office.
Hidden in plain sight.

Here's a question that sort of pertains(sp?) to this: If the stone is so dangerous why would they have built in ways of getting past protection. Like why would they have the actuall key to open the door in the same room.(the room with all the flying keys where they have to ride broomsticks to get it.) Or why don't they have a chess board with only white pieces so that you can't possibly win? Or why would there be a potion to get you throuh the flames in Snapes challenge. If they really wanted to protect it, there would be no potion so you couldn't get through at all. This is a little off topic but it is something that has bothered me for a while and this seems like a good thread to post it in since we are arguing over why the climax of the first book doesn't work.

bcuz what would be the point in mentioning it unless there was a way for harry to get to the stone and meet voldemort again.

true

Originally posted by andyb44
I think a better way to ensure the stone was safe would have been for Dumbledore to have put all the security and things he had up to safeguard the stone then put a fake in it's place and keep the real stone on a shelf in his office.
Hidden in plain sight.

its in plain sight, how can it be hidden?

Originally posted by vanice
Harry is teally stupid in this book. I mean if he had never gone down to try capturing the stone before voldemort, voldemort would never have been close getting the stone. Dumbledore had no reason to worry, the stone was perfectly safe. It is a fackt. I'm out..


It's a good point, but Harry didn't know what Dumbledore knew, so therefore, I don't believe it's fair to hold him accountable and call him "stupid."

Originally posted by Rapscallion
they're not drunk. they actually make a good point because Dumbledoor said that only someon who wanted the stone but didn't want to use it would be able to get it. therefor, Voldy would never have been able to get it. In fact, Harr'y's going down to save it actually put it in jeopardy because he could get it out of the mirror and Voldy almost got it.

But Harry didn't know that, he had no way of knowing and so did what seemed best to get the stone from Voldy.

well he must be the world champion in "putting your nose on other peoples buisness" ( I don't know if you can say that ) .

Originally posted by Grand_Moff_Gav
But Harry didn't know that, he had no way of knowing and so did what seemed best to get the stone from Voldy.

I'm not blaming him for it, I'm just saying he put it in jeopardy when it would have been perfectly safe.