Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins?

Wolverine

PC Superman is still vulnerable to kryptonite. However, if SS doesn't know Superman is vulnerable to kryptonite, he won't use it. and superman would b*tch slap the mofo

Originally posted by General Kon-El
PC Superman is still vulnerable to kryptonite. However, if SS doesn't know Superman is vulnerable to kryptonite, he won't use it. and superman would b*tch slap the mofo
He would know, because of cosmic awarness.

Originally posted by Takion
He would know, because of cosmic awarness.

Originally posted by Takion
He would know, because of cosmic awarness. Cosmic awareness tells SS where the being is. Not telling him Superman's weakness. Therefore, he doesn't know. Tries stupid stunts and Superman takes him out 10/10

No kryptonite in this fight because it defeats the purpose of an actual debate.

Wolverine wins

But still CA doesnt tell SS superman's weakness. But PC Superman still wins since batdude says no k.

Originally posted by Dayscribe
Wolverine wins make relevant posts. ur soo annoying saying wolverine wins.

Originally posted by General Kon-El
PC Superman is still vulnerable to kryptonite. However, if SS doesn't know Superman is vulnerable to kryptonite, he won't use it. and superman would b*tch slap the mofo

1. SS could read his mind.
2. According to forum rules, each side knows everything about their opponent.

Superman wins with his super weaving

Originally posted by Jabba the Hutt
1. SS could read his mind.
2. According to forum rules, each side knows everything about their opponent.
Silver Surfer doesn't have telepathy. And ok fine, SS has basic knowledge of Superman. But Superman can dodge the blasts. He's taken on Metallo with a kryptonite heart. He can use his super speed and dodge the kryptonite blasts.

Originally posted by Jabba the Hutt
1. SS could read his mind.
2. According to forum rules, each side knows everything about their opponent.

Where does it say that other than prep? Anyways, I said no kryptonite because it wouldn't be a debate anymore.

Originally posted by Big Sexy
Superman wins with his super weaving

HA HA, that's so funny.

Originally posted by batdude123
Where does it say that other than prep? Anyways, I said no kryptonite because it wouldn't be a debate anymore. Well tron said

"Basic knowledge

Each side receives basic knowledge of the other. A good measure of this would be what the general population of the character's homeworld knows. For example, that Superman has a weakness to Kryptonite is general knowledge, but that he's Clark Kent is not."

I'll throw the PC Superman fanboys a bone and say he wins this one. Just don't go saying he could beat Galactus as some have.

Originally posted by General Kon-El
Well tron said

"Basic knowledge

Each side receives basic knowledge of the other. A good measure of this would be what the general population of the character's homeworld knows. For example, that Superman has a weakness to Kryptonite is general knowledge, but that he's Clark Kent is not."

Yes, well Silver Surfer's basic knowledge of him is not going to help him considering he's not allowed to use k-nite in this fight.

no kryptonite then SS loses i suppose since he dont have magic :P

surfer absorb all the sunlite radiation in supermans cell, surfer wins.

There is no such thing as a well written Superman. But yeah, I'd say he wins the majority of the time. Say 6/10.

Post Crisis supes, however, is Silvie's little beeyotch.

As I've said before, if you ain't Darkseid, you ain't beating Pre-Crisis Superman.

Originally posted by Tron
As I've said before, if you ain't Darkseid, you ain't beating Pre-Crisis Superman. Agreed

......................................
erg
Supes wins

SS is my main man, but I am having a very hard time convincing myself he could beat pre-crisis Superman.

Superman invents "Anti Cosmic Vision" and annihilates him.

SS takes this

Pre Crisis Superman hits Silver Surfer once at full power & makes him explode.