Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Everyone seems to think Superman wins so I've changed the conditions a little.


Thor gets Mjolnir and Captain Americas sheid, and is in Warrior Madness.



Superman is on complete bloodlust



who wins?

Originally posted by GODSCRIBE
Everyone seems to think Superman wins so I've changed the conditions a little.


Thor gets Mjolnir and Captain Americas sheid, and is in Warrior Madness.



Superman is on complete bloodlust



who wins?
if people are going to says Superman is stronger than thor because of JLA/Avenger.

then they must also agree on lots of bullshit result from that comic.


Like Kyle (Gl) < Wonder Man

supes has better fighting skills. but yes i say thor is more powerful.

better fighting skills? i disagree

if they fought hand to hand without there powers. supes takes that one. but using there powers yes thor is more powerful

Originally posted by diabloman
if they fought hand to hand without there powers. supes takes that one. but using there powers yes thor is more powerful
hand to hand superman whould win.

Because he is stronger, faster.

no skill is required


Skill wise thor is better

Thor is a better Hand to Hand combatant plain and simple, Thor over all is to powerful. Let's be real Thor killed superman with the Godblast with ease, JLA/Avengers crossover was manipulated by DC, so they can have their way.

Originally posted by GODSCRIBE
Everyone seems to think Superman wins so I've changed the conditions a little.


Thor gets Mjolnir and Captain Americas sheid, and is in Warrior Madness.



Superman is on complete bloodlust



who wins?

Look at the other thread. I'd say people lean the other way - towards Thor - overall.

It depends on which of the threads you're refering to

Originally posted by GODSCRIBE
It depends on which of the threads you're refering to

The one with nearly 1,700 replies.

Originally posted by kgkg
hand to hand superman whould win.

Because he is stronger, faster.

no skill is required


Skill wise thor is better

Superman is stronger and faster than Drax the Destroyer with the Power Gem? Thor is.

Originally posted by roughrider
The one with nearly 1,700 replies.

Sorry, Thor, son of Odin. I should have never questioned you.

Originally posted by GODSCRIBE
Sorry, Thor, son of Odin. I should have never questioned you. hahahaha, just call supes, he'll drop him in one punch for ya

Assuming Thor doesn't hold himself back, Thor wins 7-8/10.

thor takes this, plain and simple....

Assuming Thor doesn't hold back? You should be more concerned with Superman holding back.

Why would anyone worry about Superman holding back? We've already seen what he can do in all-out mode versus Wonder Woman.

We've also seen what Thor can do in all-out mode: drive off Galactus, defeat Ego, beat Silver Surfer, Adam Warlock, Beta Ray Bill, Drax...

I thought the Wonder Woman thing was rather silly. He's owned Darkseid and Doomsday after all.

I thought Superman's fight versus Wonder Woman was pretty good. She had to use all of her skill just to hang in there.

Superman's first fight against Doomsday was a good showing for an all-out Superman, but I'm not too impressed with his victories against Darkseid. Sometimes Darkseid seems more powerful than Superman and other times he's having his Omega Effect deflected by Superman's heat vision and being overpowered by Superman.

The problem with Superman vs. Darkseid is consistency. If Darkseid's a peer of Superman, then he's also a peer of Black Adam, Captain Marvel, and Orion, which is top tier, but not beyond top tier.

If Superman's meant to be as powerful as an impressive Darkseid, then Superman should be at least a whole level above BA, CM, and Orion which isn't what's been shown in comics.

i'll go with thor

Originally posted by JohnR
Why would anyone worry about Superman holding back? We've already seen what he can do in all-out mode versus Wonder Woman.

We've also seen what Thor can do in all-out mode: drive off Galactus, defeat Ego, beat Silver Surfer, Adam Warlock, Beta Ray Bill, Drax...

Superman:

Defeat Dominus, absorb Mageddon, defeat cannibal planet, beat the Eradicator, Darkseid, Cyborg Supes, Doomday, whole JLA....

Both characters have their own amazing feats.

Thor wins in KMC.

Problem is, in any comic the battle would be a popularity contest just like all of Superman's fights.

Popularity has nothing to do with it.

Stronger, faster, more durable. It's been proven countless times.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Popularity has nothing to do with it.

Stronger, faster, more durable. It's been proven countless times. Yeah , but Thors a god.

Originally posted by JOE NUNEZ
Yeah , but Thors a god.

Thor himself couldn't even explain what that means to Genis.

Superman has beaten "gods." No biggie.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Thor himself couldn't even explain what that means to Genis.

Superman has beaten "gods." No biggie. Ares manhandled supes.

Originally posted by JOE NUNEZ
Ares manhandled supes.

Juggs has manhandled Thor.

Supes still wins.

Wolverine manhandled Juggernaut.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Juggs has manhandled Thor. Good point, is it fair to say this is the best match-up in comics.

Originally posted by badabing
Wolverine manhandled Juggernaut.

Wolverine and Steve Jobs share a reality distortion field.



Originally posted by JOE NUNEZ
Good point, is it fair to say this is the best match-up in comics.

Personally, I think WW vs Thor is a far better and more interesting battle.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Wolverine and Steve Jobs share a reality distortion field.