Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

reeve or routh

Originally posted by superkronick92
reeve or routh

Can't talk about Routh .....we will have to wait until the movie comes out.

As for the X-men, we have to (as of the 24th of May) use their depictions in X-men and X-men 2, and thus not the X-men 3 coming out this Friday.

However Reeve's Superman depiction was basically Pre-Crisis Superman.
Flying faster than light, turning back time, tossing things into the sun with ease, super-intellect, etc etc etc.

Movie Superman (Reeve) wins 10/10 against Movie X-men (unless in X-men 3 they all get a hold of the Infinity Gauntlet .....which will not happen ....or unless in XM3 Jean, as the Phoenix, is given a power set directly analogous to that of the comic-book Phoenix. Which will most probably not happen ....she will be made far more powerful than her prior form in the first 2 movies, but I doubt her as the Phoenix will be at the same cosmic/universe level as in the comic books).

Anyways .....another way of writing this thread is X-men vs Pre-Crisis Superman.
X-men lose.
Badly.

Originally posted by superkronick92
reeve or routh

Reeve FTW

either Superman would take this...the X-men were not overly powerful in the movies.

Originally posted by charlemagne9746
either Superman would take this...the X-men were not overly powerful in the movies.

If Xavier gets him before Superman punches him, Xavier would take movie Superman out.

Dark Phoenix would take him out either with TK ot TP.
Others don't stand a chance.