This by far is the hardest judgement I have had to come to, for I really liked both sigs.
Thorinn:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v461/Aurora8387/duelsig.jpg
I liked the use of the border that you added, even though it is small and plain, it does add a lot to the overall effect of things.
I liked the usage and placement of the render, specifically the handle of the sword.
I liked the placement and font used for your name, and it is quite fitting for this sig.
I disliked the background that you have chosen, for it doesn't seem to fit entirely into the overall feel of the sig.
Spartant4489
Originally posted by spartant4489
http://img75.imageshack.us/img75/7917/best3py.png
I liked how you added more of a firey background around the Render, surrounding it certainly gives it more of a flow.
I liked the placement of the Render and how you brought it up close so that more of the facial features can be seen.
I like the usage of the border, for it makes it look like a backdrop, and pulls your sig off of it.
I disliked the font that you used, as well as the size of it. You could have chosen a much more powerful font, to allow your name to stand out far more.
Final judgment - Spartant4489 wins ( but it was a hard decision to come to )
Great job to both of you!!!!