How Exactly

My friend and I were having a discussion on Cyclops and he said he wasnt dead hearing this a million times I asked him why he thought that he said because he is in Jean because she sucked out his soul so can someone tell how exactly did he die.

Idk about any soul things but what I got out of the movie is that the people that Jean "killed", actually are in the astral plane now cause look at how they were taken off - it appears as though their molecules were transported and not actually destroyed.

Originally posted by Pressure
My friend and I were having a discussion on Cyclops and he said he wasnt dead hearing this a million times I asked him why he thought that he said because he is in Jean because she sucked out his soul so can someone tell how exactly did he die.

there is no explanation of how he died, so it leaves the option of cyclops returning in another movie.

Originally posted by NoFate007
Idk about any soul things but what I got out of the movie is that the people that Jean "killed", actually are in the astral plane now cause look at how they were taken off - it appears as though their molecules were transported and not actually destroyed.

I think she killed them. If they were in as you said astral plane, then why did the professor return in another body? Where are you getting this info anyways?

Ask this in the X-Men: The Last Stand Discussion thread.

gambit12

I think you should keep this discussion here because reading through 4000 posts is more difficult than answering a person's single question here. There is no proof scott is dead. There's a good chance he's not. The phoenix's power is very complicated and it is always possible for someone to come back. The asastral plane seems plausible.

What matters here is RULES. I hope you get that.

To review such, here we go:

Posting In The Relevant Forums
A forum this size gets a lot of traffic and a lot of threads. It makes life a lot easier for everyone- both for those trying to keep things in order, and those trying to simply find the threads they want to read- if threads are posted in the correct area. Check to make sure you are posting in the right place.

Duplicate Posting
Do not post the same discussion more than once on a discussion forum or on many forums. Duplicate discussions are frustrating and counterproductive for other members, especially for those whose time and energy is limited. Duplicate discussions will be deleted.

Also, if you guys only read what our dear Moderator is instructing:

Originally posted by Paola
Please Read

Before opening a thread please use the SEARCH feature to ensure that a thread on your subject does not already exist.

Please also report any inappropriate posts using the REPORT option (located at the bottom right hand corner of every post).

Clear as sunrise, mon ami.

gambit12

Now, as far as TOPIC is concerned, since this is a part of the X3 movie, you guys can discuss this as well in this thread: X-Men: The Last Stand Discussion thread...

Or, for a more specific location, you can discuss this in here: Cyclops Dies?

Originally posted by Jury
What matters here is RULES. I hope you get that.

To review such, here we go:

And...

Also, if you guys only read what our dear Moderator is instructing:

Clear as sunrise, mon ami.

gambit12

Now, as far as TOPIC is concerned, since this is a part of the X3 movie, you guys can discuss this as well in this thread: X-Men: The Last Stand Discussion thread...

Or, for a more specific location, you can discuss this in here: Cyclops Dies?

i think someone wants to be a mod!!!

Originally posted by Jury
What matters here is RULES. I hope you get that.

To review such, here we go:

And...

Also, if you guys only read what our dear Moderator is instructing:

Clear as sunrise, mon ami.

gambit12

Now, as far as TOPIC is concerned, since this is a part of the X3 movie, you guys can discuss this as well in this thread: X-Men: The Last Stand Discussion thread...

Or, for a more specific location, you can discuss this in here: Cyclops Dies?