I hate you all
so anyways here are the ideas that were in the other thread
Originally posted by Sea King
we could set up something with antoher group like 10 chars. 5 from dc and 5 from marvel. have a debate draft who knows the most about those chars can sing up then we down size the sing up list by seeing who knows more in a debate on that char till certin team sizes are made.
then the other does the same and the we set up a time and what place witch debates will be placed.
numbers are just inputs does not mean thats how big or small it should be
Originally posted by DigiMark007
Yeah. It would be rough. I can list on maybe one hand the number of people that aren't in question (Mungi, DC, Val with GLs, I'd say you for Logan, but even that might be debatable). And determining the consensus 'best' for most characters would be nigh-impossible.
Maybe a nomination thread first. Like I'd come on and nominate the people I just listed for those characters (and a few others) and so would others. Then make poll-style thread for each character that's in question (like Batman for example) to determine a winner....and the nominees could make cases for themselves at that time if they want. So, for example, we wouldn't need a poll for namor, but we'd need one for Superman.
Still, that's lots of time and work. But a possible solution. And it doesn't involve extended debates for those who can't be on as much.
Originally posted by Blair Wind
We could start work now, tackle the problem with logic, then take action sometime later
I understand what you sayin about certain characters, and hell even about past debators. But a set number of teamates in a team for various characters will be easier than an expert on a certain character.
Personally I think people who can debate (those who can take information and apply it creatively) better should be put on the forefront of the battle, while the true experts on only specific characters supply them with the knowledge and scans they need. Alot of the time they ARE some of the best debators. But I like Digis idea as well on nomination thread.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
So we wouldn't narrow it to 1 for each character (except for ones that no one else cares about like Alpha Flight.
). And instead, team of 3-4 for more popular or well'known characters?? I like it....makes it a bit easier than havign to pick 1 for each.
Originally posted by Blair Wind
Basic idea. Doesnt need to be only popular characters. IF there is an obscure character out there, a good debator given facts and scans and prodding by an expert (knowledge on a character and debating skills are two very different things) should be able to debate him efficiently.
Originally posted by jinzin
yeah i like that...
the REAL question before picking any members is simply revolved around the previously stated matter that sea king mentioned...
we should make a list of suitable characters that we would use in the tourney first. I mean I know we wouldn't be using every character located in the respect threads for example...
so which characters are we narrowed down to? which one's should we use? etc etc... that's first and foremost what we need; an adequate list of characters for each forum to use and debate with...
after that we can divvy who will represent the selected characters. Another good point that was brought up was that a person may know a TON about a specific character but may not be able to give very compelling or persuasive arguments for said character...
So we should pick people who are not only sufficient in knowledge of the character but also very articulate in the method of debate. And then the experts can back up the representatives with facts and scans as previously mentioned.
thanks for the mention but I agree entirely.. I know for a fact that both srank, capt, and riceroost know wayyy more about logan than I do, the only question is "who's the master debater between them/us"...
those are the kinds of things that need to be considered... since we would be repping the KMC forums we want to throw out the best we've got, not just the most knowledgeable. (and no I'm not implying I'm a better debater either, I'm just making a point)
but like I said... first we need a list to see which charcters would need representation since we can't debate using them all...
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
I have to say honestly that there is perhaps only one person in this planet that comes close to my Namor knowledge. Avenging Son of the Alvaros Comic Book Boards. However, I think I have jumped ahead of him with the massive respect thread, and the Namor website that is most likely ready by the end of this year.
And I certainly have not met an Alpha Flight fan come even close to King_Mungi. Only one guy who is similar to demigawd in Magneto knowledge (Mightily Oats of SHC). Draco89 might be the best soource for Wonder Woman knowlege I know. GalacticStorm is defenitely the best Phoenix and general cosmic know-it-all guy. I have not met anyone who knows Aquaman better then Lucid. And snoopdogg is defenitely the number one Colossus guy.
Also the depth that is put to debates are probably matched by no-one.
So yes, in some areas and some characters, I think we are the best there is.
Originally posted by leonidas
to show who the real debaters are, it would be cool to have 2 random characters picked. neither participant would know who the characters would be and be given maybe one day to prep for the debate. of course the characters would need to be 'mainstream' -- no silly, obscure characters -- and of relatively comparable power levels (superman v gladiator, for example) but that would be very cool. it would also prevent need of 'experts' and polls (though it would bring experts in because the forum rep would be hitting up the experts for scans and strategies!) overall though, general comic knowledge and debating skills would be the prime requirement.
as they should be.
it WOULD be cool to see the experts on each debate each other. could be spiderman v spiderman. each expert would have a spiderman and the winning representative would earn a point for their forum.
this sounds really cool.