Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I decided to start an official thread to discuss this series.

Personally, I'm disappointed in Miller's writing. He's treating Batman like Marv... which is just wrong. Lee's art is absolutely awesome, as always.

Discuss!

Millar's writing didn't bother me until issue #4.

I mean what the hell is up with that.

"Eat that rat" - Bats

"What?!? No!" - Dick Grayson

"Oh you'll eat it alright" - Bats

What was up with that

Miller has either lost it... Or is sitting at his home reading all the Internet complains while laughing and counting his money.


It's either a joker or miller actually believes this is how batman should be written..

...or he's been at the crack again...

I haven't read, thankfully (based on what I've heard).

It does sound kind of humorous though.

Indeed. I only read one issue a while back... or maybe part of it... I reckon it was a few apges someone uploaded on another site to show how crappy it is....

So does this comic exist in the same universe as All-Star Superman?

Seemingly not...

Originally posted by H. S. 6



So does this comic exist in the same universe as All-Star Superman?
No. Dark Knight Returns universe.

http://www.i-mockery.com/comics/longbox7/default.php

pretty funny summary.

Honestly for some reason the only thing I like about this comic is that Batman is a complete A**hole and that Jim Lee's art is as usual pretty impressive but besides that I really dont acre about this one or Superman. I think their attemp to create an Ultimate universe of their own has failed so far.

It's an entertaining read.

Thanks for that website summary, Black Adam, that was hilarious.

"Bruce Wayne. Billionaire, playboy, creepy boy watcher."

"Dick Grayson gonna learn he'd best not be mouthin' off to the goddamn Batman."

Originally posted by Darth Vicious
I think their attemp to create an Ultimate universe of their own has failed so far.
Why is that people think All-Star is an attempt at an ultimate line? Ultimate DC was done years ago. I believe they called it Kingdom Come.

Originally posted by Validus
Why is that people think All-Star is an attempt at an ultimate line?

I was just about to ask the same thing.

Originally posted by Validus
Why is that people think All-Star is an attempt at an ultimate line? Ultimate DC was done years ago. I believe they called it Kingdom Come.

Kingdom Come is more like Earth X than Ultimate Marvel

Originally posted by Grimm22
Kingdom Come is more like Earth X than Ultimate Marvel
Well Kingdom Come doesn't suck so scratch that. 1234

A more realistic/updated take on the characters and settings is what Ultimate Marvel is and thats what Kingdom Come is as well.

Originally posted by Black Adam
http://www.i-mockery.com/comics/longbox7/default.php

pretty funny summary.

hysterical2

That was awesome!

I kind of liked the first issue. Everything else has been pure wtf lol though.

"Then we cut back to Batman and Robin, sitting in the Batmobile, talking. We're going to see a lot of this, because it takes them the next two goddamned issues to actually make it TO the Batcave, which is apparently somewhere in northern Canada, given the amount of driving they have to do."
"SUPERMAN HATES MILK WITH THE FIERY INTENSITY OF A THOUSAND SUNS!"

Couple samples, that page was the funniest thing I've read in a while.

1st issue - Good

2nd issue - Ok

3rd issue - Good

4th issue - Awful

'You serious? I haven't read 'em... now I REALKLy want to for a laugh that's LONG overdue... scannage?

I just hope that it gets better. The art is enough for me to keep buying it... for now. I bet DC regrets putting Miller on the duo. I think he's lost his mind or something. Meh, I just want the story to go somewhere.

Restart the series... or just burn Miller at the stake...

The thing that made me laugh was when Clark is looking at the kidnapped person ad on the milk carton, and it says "Fifteen hours ago..." Then they cut to Dick and Bruce... who are still in the Batmobile.

That is terrible writing on its own.

EXACTLY! Miller's past his best... and looks like a paedophile...

To be fair, he always looked like a pedophile.

Well...just in case you guys forgot.

Dick Grayson.

Age 12.

I thought Dick Grayson, age 12, was always age 11?

No. dick Garyson is age 12. In cas4e you misunderstood, let me reiterate that: Dick Grayson= 12 years old. and, for those reatrds who piss with the Goddam Batman at home, dick Garyson was age f**king 12 years old!

So Dick Grayson, age 12, isn't Dick Grayson, age 13?


Jeez, they really need to try to clear these things up!

No, I fear that dick Garyson, age 12, may truly be age 12 as miller obsessively needs to point out that Dick Grayson, age 12, is age 12. So I believe Dick Grayson, age 12, is age 12...