Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

The great wisdom of LS said that ROTJ can pwn Dooku. Can he pwn the duo?

Luke wouldnt even be able to beat one of them let alone both at once.

This is close. Luke could probably take either of them one on one but together? Anakin will rush Luke like he did with Dooku but Luke ain't got nothing to take out Anakin quick like Dooku used the lightning so he'll fight Anakin saber-to-saber and then Obi-Wan'll join in and I can't see Luke taking both of them at once. Luke looses.

By RotJ, I can see Luke losing. He is actually not that experienced in lightsaber combat, even at this point (he hasn't had much to go up against). One at a time, I can somewhat believe Luke squeezing out a win, but not simultaneously.

I just hope we don't see any fanboys stating NJO facts here...

the combination of obiwan and anakin can beat almost any adversary.

Lol, no, AOTC Anakin and Obi-Wan taking about almost anyone? No way.

Yeah but Luke was able to use Emerald Lighting and...to make you happy Dubya.

I can see Luke taking down Anakin or Obi-Wan one on one but both of them would mean the end of Luke Skywalker.

anakin as a padawan vs. luke is a good fight. anakin is way quicker so he'll prolly chop is arm off. luke takin both obi and ani is a hell no. but luke might just might beat obi AOTC. In AOTC obi 1 sucked man.

Good fight, actually...but Luke is at a disadvantage. So im leaning towards AOTC.

Originally posted by stone7
anakin as a padawan vs. luke is a good fight. anakin is way quicker so he'll prolly chop is arm off. luke takin both obi and ani is a hell no. but luke might just might beat obi AOTC. In AOTC obi 1 sucked man.

Anakin is not quicker. No way. In ESB look how fast Luke jumps up from the Carbon Freezing thing. Also,
http://www.swcomics.com/Empire_Era_c.php?i=103&f=29&name=
http://www.swcomics.com/Empire_Era_c.php?i=113&f=29&name=

Anakin doesn't have the smarts to take Luke, and Obi Wan would just be overwhelmed.

http://susanmernit.blogspot.com/chewbacca.jpg
This is Chewbacca. Now why am I talking about Chewbacca in Obi-Wan and Anakin vs. Luke thread? It don't make no sense.

http://money.cnn.com/2003/09/04/pf/saving/pepsi_monkey_game/monkey.03.jpg
Here look at the monkey, look at the silly monkey. Now then when you ask yourself who wins, ask yourself this: Does it make sense?

Thank you

...?

That is a dashing picture of Chewbacca if I do say so myself... sorry...

AOTC Anakin could beat Luke alone. Luke swings his lightsaber like a bat and while he is doing that Anakin severs one of his arms or probably both

Luke is faster.
Luke beat Vader.
Luke is stronger.
Luke had Boba Fett beat.
Luke took out 20-ish mercs worthy to guard Jabba.
Luke lifted C-3p0 up with the force, kept him there, moved him around, with no hand gestures or apparent strain.
Luke effortlessly subdued two guards with the force.
Luke would have been good enough to help Vader overthrow the Emperor.
Luke has a lot of accomplishments in EU, also: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f6/t410420.html

Remember this isn't EU Luke! It's RotJ!

Originally posted by ESB -1138
http://susanmernit.blogspot.com/chewbacca.jpg
This is Chewbacca. Now why am I talking about Chewbacca in Obi-Wan and Anakin vs. Luke thread? It don't make no sense.

http://money.cnn.com/2003/09/04/pf/saving/pepsi_monkey_game/monkey.03.jpg
Here look at the monkey, look at the silly monkey. Now then when you ask yourself who wins, ask yourself this: Does it make sense?

Thank you



Haha using the Chewbacca argument ey?

Luke with a lightsaber is no better than a 2 year old with a baseball bat, they both have this in common, swing and hope for the best.
Now How the hell is he supposed to beat two experienced jedi/ (that actually use forms of combat)

EDIT

EDIT

Originally posted by jollyjim311
Luke is faster.
Luke beat Vader.
Luke is stronger.
Luke had Boba Fett beat.
Luke took out 20-ish mercs worthy to guard Jabba.
Luke lifted C-3p0 up with the force, kept him there, moved him around, with no hand gestures or apparent strain.
Luke effortlessly subdued two guards with the force.
Luke would have been good enough to help Vader overthrow the Emperor.
Luke has a lot of accomplishments in EU, also: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f6/t410420.html

In case you missed it.

Originally posted by Darth Ownage
the pair exert more effort take really big dump so big infact thaey have to have new robes made (and they kill him that way) no i didn't vader was handicapped with the suit he is only comparable to Qui-Gon in EU this is ROTJ

Huh? And stop quoting yourself.

The only thing ROTJ Luke has over AOTC Anakin is that he's older (even though some things which usually come with age such as experience is in Anakin's favour) and rushed training (which had both pros and cons). it could be argued that he was stronger and faster, but I disagree. Luke loses badly.

Well, he appears physically stronger, that's what I was basing it on, and, they are probably about as fast, but, Luke has more said of his speed.

the pair fart and kill him

This thread is absolutely stupid. Obi-Wan beats Luke effortlessly while Anakin leaves and bangs Padme.

Seriously? ROTJ Luke Vs. Anakin and Obi-Wan? Any movie incarnation of Obi-Wan would tool ROTJ Luke. Anakin just might as well leave, or laugh at the slaughter at hand.

What the hell are people thinking?

People are thinking that Luke is actually good, and they're right.

Originally posted by Darth Ownage
the pair fart and kill him