Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Im really interested in which comics everyone is reading, and im sure others are aswell. I think this will be really helpful in providing a good guide to any newbies as to what/what not to pick up. For example, you can look at what comics your favourite members are reading, and this may help in deciding which comics you want on your 'pull list' and which you want to ditch. To help everyone out, you should divide your comics into sepearte categories.

You can make your list as user friendly as you like, as long as you split the list into its sepearte Comic book Companies (E.G. Marvel, D.C., Image, Wild Storm) I think it would also be helpful to give quick reviews and raitings out of ten. The raitings should be based on how good the recent story arcs have been, and how they compare to the original arcs.

It will also be helpful to note whose writing the books, as many (Such as myself) use our favourite writers, to help garuntee quality. Also it would be good to mention which comics you are thinking about dropping and why. And which Comics you have heard about, but you need to know more about.

Pics of covers, and inside art will also be appreciated.

My Current Pull List :

Marvel 616 :

New Avengers (Brian Bendis) 5/10
Civil War (Mark Miller) 8/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 7/10
Dare Devil (Ed Brubaker) 9/10
Young Avengers (Weinberg) 9/10
Runaways (Brian K Vaughn) 8/10
Astonoshing X men (Joss Wheedon) 8/10
Iron Man Warren Ellis / Charles Knauf 8/10

Marvel Ultimate :

Spiderman 7/10 (Brian Bendis) (i've only just started reading it)
Ultimates 9/10 (Mark Miller) (If the book wasn't so slow it would get a 10)
Galactus 6/10 (Warren Ellis) (Im so dissapointed in Ellis)

D.C.

Allstar Superman (Grant Morisson) 9/10
Flash 7/10 (Its just started)
Wonder Woman 8.5/10 (Heinberg) (Its just started)
52 8/10


Soon to be getting :

Green Lattern Corps
JLA (Metzler)
BNW Trails of Shazam
BNW Martian Manhunter
Batman OYL - (Grant Morisson)

Wildstorm :

Soon to be getting :

Authority + Wild Cats (Grant Morisson)
Midnighter (Garth Ennis)

Thinking about :
Can anyone recomend these ?
Deus Ex Machina
JMS's Spiderman
Uncanny X-men
Captian Ammerica
JSA (When it comes out)
OYL Superman

I'll find out the other writer names later .....

Ultimate x-men volumes 9/10 Numerous authors
Ultimate spiderman 7/10 Bendis

Astonishing x-men 6/10 so far on this arc ( the first 2 arcs 10/10) Joss Whedon
New Excalibur 9/10 Christopher Yost
Civil War Spiderman i only have one issue so far J. Michael Straczynski

thats all i am reading just now (i think) but i am going to the comics shop today

Originally posted by The Pict
Ultimate x-men volumes 9/10
Ultimate spiderman 7/10

Astonishing x-men 6/10 so far on this arc ( the first 2 arcs 10/10)
New Excalibur 9/10
Civil War Spiderman i only have one issue so far

thats all i am reading just now (i think) but i am going to the comics shop today

Can you write the Authors please ?

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
Can you write the Authors please ?

Ok i have edited the post

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
Can you write the Authors please ?

Nope... i have no idea who writes what... i never look at the names of the creators of the comics i read

My list:

Daredevil (Brubaker) 9/10
Exiles (Tony Bedard) 8/10
New Avengers (Bendis) 6/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 9/10
Young Avengers (Weinberg) 7/10
Runaways (Vaughan) 9/10
Astonishing X men (Whedon) 10/10
Punisher (Ennis) 7/10
Uncanny X-Men (Brubaker)
Ultimates (Millar) 9/10
Ultimate Spider-Man (Bendis) 7/10
Ultimate X-Men (Kirkman)

Everything associated with Civil War 5-9/10:

* Amazing Spider-Man #529-531 Mr. Parker goes to Washington
* Civil War: Opening Shot Sketchbook (one-shot)
* Fantastic Four #536-537 The Hammer Falls
* New Avengers: The Illuminati (one-shot)

* Civil War (seven-issue miniseries)
* Civil War: Front Line (10-issue miniseries)
* Civil War: X-Men (four-issue miniseries)
* Civil War: Young Avengers & Runaways (four-issue miniseries)
* Amazing Spider-Man #532-538 The War at Home
* Black Panther #18
* Cable/Deadpool #30-32
* Captain America #22-24
* Daily Bugle: Civil War Edition (one-shot newspaper)
* Fantastic Four #538-543
* Heroes for Hire #1-3
* Iron Man v4 #13-14
* Marvel Spotlight: Millar/McNiven (one-shot)
* Ms. Marvel #6-8
* New Avengers #21-25: New Avengers: Disassembled
* Punisher: War Journal volume 2 #1-3
* She-Hulk v2 #8
* Thunderbolts #103-105
* Wolverine #42-47 Vendetta
* X-Factor #8-9

I don't really follow DC. 52 is really the only title I read. I will probably get all stuff that has Captain Marvel and Captain Atom. Nightwing used to be good, but now it sucks. It sucks really bad.

I also collect Planetary from Wildstorm.

I will get the following stuff in future:

Marvel:

X-Men (Carey)

Wildstorm:

W.I.L.D.Cats
Authority
Midnighter

Marvel

New Avengers (Brian Bendis) 4.5/10 - Have no idea why I still read it.
Civil War (Mark Miller) 8/10
Young Avengers (Allen Heinberg) 8/10
Runaways (Brian K Vaughn) 9/10
Astonishing X men (Joss Whedon) 9/10
Exiles (Various) 7.5/10 - Haven't read all

Ultimate X-Men (Various, Currently Robert Kirkman) - Currently 7/10. Overall 8.5/10

D.C.

All Star Batman and Robin (Frank Millar) - If you want something for a laugh it's good.
Teen Titans (Geoff Johns) 7.5/10
Flash (Danny Bilson/Paul Demeo) - Okay so far.
Wonder Woman 8/10 (Heinberg) - Okay so far.
52 (Multiple) 7.5/10 - Have only read up to Week 6; I don't really care that much about Booster Gold...

Y The Last Man (Vaughn) 9/10

Might read if/when I have time:
Squadron Supreme
The Authority
Deus Ex Machina
Ion
X-Factor because I liked the Madrox miniseries
The other Civil War stuff

Cool thread. I won't rate books that have less than 2 or 3 issues in their current arc since most take that long just to get started.

DC
52 (Johns/Rucka/Morrison/Waid) 8/10
Checkmate (Rucka) 7/10
Detective Comics (Dini) N/A
Batman (Morrison) N/A
Nightwing (Jones) 3/10
Robin (Beechen) 8/10
Outsiders (Winick) 6/10
Green Lantern (Johns) 7/10
Green Lantern Corps (Gibbons) N/A
Ion (Marz) 7/10
Superman/Action Comics (Busiek/Johns) 9/10
Supergirl (Kelly) 5/10
Supergirl & The Legion of Super-Heroes (Waid) 8/10
Superman/Batman (Verheiden) N/A
Secret Six (Simone) N/A
Teen Titans (Johns) 7/10
Flash: Fastest Man Alive (Bilson/DeMeo) N/A
Wonder Woman (Heinberg) N/A

Ex Machina (Vaughn) 9/10
Y The Last Man (Vaughn) 9/10
100 Bullets (Azzarello) 8.5/10
Fables (Willingham) 10/10

Marvel
Astonishing X-Men (Whedon) 9/10
Uncanny X-Men (Brubaker) N/A
Annihilation: Silver Surfer 7/10
New Avengers (Bendis) 3/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 5/10
Thunderbolts (Nicieza) 7/10
Captain America (Brubaker) 8/10
Civil War (Millar) 7/10
Eternals (Gaiman) N/A
Runaways (Vaughn) 8/10

Coming Soon
Gen 13 (Simone)
Wildcats: Worldstorm (Morrison)
The Authority (Morrison)
Trials of Shazam (Winick)
Justice Society of America (Johns)
Justice League of America (Meltzer)

You people read a ton.

I guess I read lots, but I don't buy much of it.

Originally posted by Validus
Cool thread. I won't rate books that have less than 2 or 3 issues in their current arc since most take that long just to get started.

DC
52 (Johns/Rucka/Morrison/Waid) 8/10
Checkmate (Rucka) 7/10
Detective Comics (Dini) N/A
Batman (Morrison) N/A
Nightwing (Jones) 3/10
Robin (Beechen) 8/10
Outsiders (Winick) 6/10
Green Lantern (Johns) 7/10
Green Lantern Corps (Gibbons) N/A
Ion (Marz) 7/10
Superman/Action Comics (Busiek/Johns) 9/10
Supergirl (Kelly) 5/10
Supergirl & The Legion of Super-Heroes (Waid) 8/10
Superman/Batman (Verheiden) N/A
Secret Six (Simone) N/A
Teen Titans (Johns) 7/10
Flash: Fastest Man Alive (Bilson/DeMeo) N/A
Wonder Woman (Heinberg) N/A

Ex Machina (Vaughn) 9/10
Y The Last Man (Vaughn) 9/10
100 Bullets (Azzarello) 8.5/10
Fables (Willingham) 10/10

Marvel
Astonishing X-Men (Whedon) 9/10
Uncanny X-Men (Brubaker) N/A
Annihilation: Silver Surfer 7/10
New Avengers (Bendis) 3/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 5/10
Thunderbolts (Nicieza) 7/10
Captain America (Brubaker) 8/10
Civil War (Millar) 7/10
Eternals (Gaiman) N/A
Runaways (Vaughn) 8/10

Coming Soon
Gen 13 (Simone)
Wildcats: Worldstorm (Morrison)
The Authority (Morrison)
Trials of Shazam (Winick)
Justice Society of America (Johns)
Justice League of America (Meltzer)

Bloody hell Ion ..... This is a bit of a 'If i won the lotterey pull list' .... You do have some seriously good taste though. Whats Brubakers Captain America like ? , Im reading his Dare Devil, im getting his Uncanny and his Authority stuff was the best since Warren Ellis was writing it. IMO he's the hottest writer about at the moment. Also i've never heard of 'Y the last man' and Fables, what are they like ?

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Marvel

New Avengers (Brian Bendis) 4.5/10 - Have no idea why I still read it.
Civil War (Mark Miller) 8/10
Young Avengers (Allen Heinberg) 8/10
Runaways (Brian K Vaughn) 9/10
Astonishing X men (Joss Whedon) 9/10
Exiles (Various) 7.5/10 - Haven't read all

Ultimate X-Men (Various, Currently Robert Kirkman) - Currently 7/10. Overall 8.5/10

D.C.

All Star Batman and Robin (Frank Millar) - If you want something for a laugh it's good.
Teen Titans (Geoff Johns) 7.5/10
Flash (Danny Bilson/Paul Demeo) - Okay so far.
Wonder Woman 8/10 (Heinberg) - Okay so far.
52 (Multiple) 7.5/10 - Have only read up to Week 6; I don't really care that much about Booster Gold...

(Vaughn) 9/10

Might read if/when I have time:
Squadron Supreme
The Authority
Deus Ex Machina
Ion
X-Factor because I liked the Madrox miniseries
The other Civil War stuff

I've heard X-factor is the only book that rivals Astonishing, very dark hnoir stuff. Also I cant believe i haven't heard of this 'Y The Last Man '. Although Vaughn has done a great job on Runaways, and Deus Ex machina is highly regarded.

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
My list:

Daredevil (Brubaker) 9/10
Exiles (Tony Bedard) 8/10
New Avengers (Bendis) 6/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 9/10
Young Avengers (Weinberg) 7/10
Runaways (Vaughan) 9/10
Astonishing X men (Whedon) 10/10
Punisher (Ennis) 7/10
Uncanny X-Men (Brubaker)
Ultimates (Millar) 9/10
Ultimate Spider-Man (Bendis) 7/10
Ultimate X-Men (Kirkman)

Everything associated with Civil War 5-9/10:

* Amazing Spider-Man #529-531 Mr. Parker goes to Washington
* Civil War: Opening Shot Sketchbook (one-shot)
* Fantastic Four #536-537 The Hammer Falls
* New Avengers: The Illuminati (one-shot)

* Civil War (seven-issue miniseries)
* Civil War: Front Line (10-issue miniseries)
* Civil War: X-Men (four-issue miniseries)
* Civil War: Young Avengers & Runaways (four-issue miniseries)
* Amazing Spider-Man #532-538 The War at Home
* Black Panther #18
* Cable/Deadpool #30-32
* Captain America #22-24
* Daily Bugle: Civil War Edition (one-shot newspaper)
* Fantastic Four #538-543
* Heroes for Hire #1-3
* Iron Man v4 #13-14
* Marvel Spotlight: Millar/McNiven (one-shot)
* Ms. Marvel #6-8
* New Avengers #21-25: New Avengers: Disassembled
* Punisher: War Journal volume 2 #1-3
* She-Hulk v2 #8
* Thunderbolts #103-105
* Wolverine #42-47 Vendetta
* X-Factor #8-9

I don't really follow DC. 52 is really the only title I read. I will probably get all stuff that has Captain Marvel and Captain Atom. Nightwing used to be good, but now it sucks. It sucks really bad.

I also collect Planetary from Wildstorm.

I will get the following stuff in future:

Marvel:

X-Men (Carey)

Wildstorm:

W.I.L.D.Cats
Authority
Midnighter

I had no idea Ennis was writing Punnisher (Probably on my Pull list now), and im glad to see youre getting Midnighter because of it. What Deadpool and Cable like ?

DC


Detective Comics and Batman ( James Robinson ) 8/10
Green Lantern Corps (Gibbons) 8/10
Flash: Fastest Man Alive (Bilson/DeMeo) 6/10



Marvel

Annihilation: Nova(Andy Lanning & Dan Abnett) 8/10
Annihilation: Silver Surfer(Keith Giffen) 7/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 7/10
Daredevil (Brubaker) 8/10
Civil War (Millar) 7/10
Young avengers (Heinberg) 8/10
X-factor(PAD) 9/10
Ms.Marvel(Brian Reed) 6/10
Hulk (Greg Pak)9/10

Originally posted by Validus
Cool thread. I won't rate books that have less than 2 or 3 issues in their current arc since most take that long just to get started.

DC
52 (Johns/Rucka/Morrison/Waid) 8/10
Checkmate (Rucka) 7/10
Detective Comics (Dini) N/A
Batman (Morrison) N/A
Nightwing (Jones) 3/10
Robin (Beechen) 8/10
Outsiders (Winick) 6/10
Green Lantern (Johns) 7/10
Green Lantern Corps (Gibbons) N/A
Ion (Marz) 7/10
Superman/Action Comics (Busiek/Johns) 9/10
Supergirl (Kelly) 5/10
Supergirl & The Legion of Super-Heroes (Waid) 8/10
Superman/Batman (Verheiden) N/A
Secret Six (Simone) N/A
Teen Titans (Johns) 7/10
Flash: Fastest Man Alive (Bilson/DeMeo) N/A
Wonder Woman (Heinberg) N/A

Ex Machina (Vaughn) 9/10
Y The Last Man (Vaughn) 9/10
100 Bullets (Azzarello) 8.5/10
Fables (Willingham) 10/10

Marvel
Astonishing X-Men (Whedon) 9/10
Uncanny X-Men (Brubaker) N/A
Annihilation: Silver Surfer 7/10
New Avengers (Bendis) 3/10
Squadron Supreme (JMS) 5/10
Thunderbolts (Nicieza) 7/10
Captain America (Brubaker) 8/10
Civil War (Millar) 7/10
Eternals (Gaiman) N/A
Runaways (Vaughn) 8/10

Coming Soon
Gen 13 (Simone)
Wildcats: Worldstorm (Morrison)
The Authority (Morrison)
Trials of Shazam (Winick)
Justice Society of America (Johns)
Justice League of America (Meltzer)


thats a lot of books....

I've been liking the new GLC books so far.

Originally posted by batdude123
I've been liking the new GLC books so far.

Goldie Looking Chain have brought out a comic book

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
Goldie Looking Chain have brought out a comic book

HA HA HA!!!!! WHOO!!!!! Green Lantern Corps

Originally posted by batdude123
HA HA HA!!!!! WHOO!!!!! Green Lantern Corps

R U english ?

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
R U english ?

Nope, I'm from America.

Originally posted by batdude123
Nope, I'm from America. \

So you didn't really get my joke ?

Nope.

Originally posted by batdude123
Nope.

Well it was funnier than this ......

Prep



Originally posted by batdude123
STINKY WINKY AND A MARIO VS. LUIGI WITH A DASH OF BAM!!!!!!!!!!!!! THEN YOU DO WITH THE SHIBBY AND THE BIBBY AND DOO OP DOO OP BEE BOP SHOO BEE BOP KOOKY DOOKY SMOOKY LACKY MACKY NACKY HIHOOOOOO WAKE UP!! WHY DON'T YOU PUT ON A LITTLE MAKE UP???!!! WELL ANGELS DESERVE TO LLLLLLLLLLLLIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
IIIIIVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!! ROKASAYJAMANAHAMINA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
Well it was funnier than this ......

Prep

no2

Originally posted by Black Adam
thats a lot of books....
Isn't it though? I'll be cutting back very soon to about half of that.

Marvel Ongoing:

New Avengers 6/10

Fantastic Four 6/10 (Damn you JMS!)

Thing 10/10

She Hulk 9/10

Amazing Spidey 8/10

Wolverine 8/10

X-Men 7/10

Uncanny X-men 8/10

Astonishing X-men 10/10

Captain America 9/10

Daredevil 10/10


Marvel Mini-Series

Beyond!: 8/10

Civil War: 9/10

Civil War: Front Line: 8/10


Ult. Marvel

Ult. Fantastic Four 9/10

Ult. X-Men 7/10

Ultimates 2 10/10

Ultimate Spidey 6/10


DC Ongoing

Batman 8/10

WW 8/10

Superman 8/10

Flash 6/10

Green Lantern 9/10

Teen Titans 7/10

All Star Superman 9/10

All Star Batman 4/10


DC Mini Series

52: 6/10

I cant think of anymore right now

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
\

So you didn't really get my joke ?

i got it

amazing spider-man 8/10 barker
I'm a Spidey fan and I pick all his books(yes even spider-man loves mary jane.dodgy) Amazing spider-man sucks major ass all his 616 stories do.The one that's good is Spider-man unlimited.