Gwen or MJ?
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
steverules
Who does spidey love more?
Sparkz
Well overall I'd say Gwen, she's been dead for years and he still loves her, if Gwen hadn't died he would have gone with her not MJ, but because she is dead and he's grown alot closer to MJ, currently he loves MJ more, it all depends what era of Spider-man you talk about.
Mr Parker
well NOW M.J obviously since he got married to her -the biggest sin in spiderman comic history,

and since gwen has been long dead.Before Gwen died though,it was easily Gwen.Matter of fact he would even talk about gwendy at times for several issues after gwen died.
Black Adam
Originally posted by Mr Parker
well NOW M.J obviously since he got married to her -the biggest sin in spiderman comic history,
sin?
how is it a sin?
Sparkz
As a matter of fact Peter still loves Gwen to this day, MJ knows it, just look at Spider-man blue. If Gwen came back from the dead (which I hope she dosn't otherwise it would ruin a realy good story) I wouldn't be suprised if peter eventualy left MJ for Gwen again.
steverules
I wish I added a poll to this thread.
Sparkz
Originally posted by steverules
I wish I added a poll to this thread.
But its hard to choose as it is...
Mr Parker
I wish that spiderman blue would become a permanent series.It would bring back the cleverly written storys from the good old days when the comic first got started.I hated it when they killed gwen.

Black Adam
Originally posted by Mr Parker
I wish that spiderman blue would become a permanent series.It would bring back the cleverly written storys from the good old days when the comic first got started.I hated it when they killed gwen.
Gwen was a boring character...
Sparkz
Originally posted by Black Adam
Gwen was a boring character...
I disagree, but I just realy like gwen's character lol.
Sparkz
Originally posted by Mr Parker
I wish that spiderman blue would become a permanent series.It would bring back the cleverly written storys from the good old days when the comic first got started.I hated it when they killed gwen.
I agree, even if Spider-man blue was full of continuity errors, but it was still a brilliant series.
Black Adam
Originally posted by Sparkz
I disagree, but I just realy like gwen's character lol.
guess well have to disagree then...
Wasn't alive to really care when they first killed her and looking back and reading some of those old stories I really didn't find her that interesting.
Sparkz
Originally posted by Black Adam
guess well have to disagree then...
Wasn't alive to really care when they first killed her and looking back and reading some of those old stories I really didn't find her that interesting.
I wasn't alive either, but I'v been through and read the first 200 issues or so in order, and kind of learned to like her. I didnt much like early version of MJ she seemed to like playing harry against Peter for some reason.
DBZ MAN
I'd Do MJ-....oh You mean euh..yeh MJ

Sparkz
Originally posted by DBZ MAN
I'd Do MJ-....oh You mean euh..yeh MJ
Hmmm methinks you have a dirty mind.
SpyCspider
The readers liked Gwen...but the writers wanted MJ (cuz they thought Gwen was starting to get boring).
All in all, Peter loves MJ more, but Gwen is that love that "got away" so it affects him in a deeper manner and why he keeps reminiscing. Even when he woke up on the bridge after being injured (recent bad story arc), he thought he saw Gwen but it was really MJ
Mr Parker
Originally posted by Black Adam
Gwen was a boring character...
no she wasnt.
Mr Parker
Originally posted by SpyCspider
The readers liked Gwen...but the writers wanted MJ (cuz they thought Gwen was starting to get boring).
All in all, Peter loves MJ more, but Gwen is that love that "got away" so it affects him in a deeper manner and why he keeps reminiscing. Even when he woke up on the bridge after being injured (recent bad story arc), he thought he saw Gwen but it was really MJ
the thing thats so stupid about their reasoning is after he married MJ,MJ became boring after that.

Dan-El
Maybe early on, but I think that towards the end of the original series, and after the reboot (which was later retconned, though I'm not positive if that's the correct term for going back to original issue numbers...) they covered the marriage with a new, fresh style.
Peter being single for so long would get old after a while too. How many chicks must he go through before he meets the right one? I mean, he IS a nerd, after all! lol
Doc Ock
Originally posted by Mr Parker
well NOW M.J obviously since he got married to her -the biggest sin in spiderman comic history,
OH.MY.GOD.
The movies are a sin. The comics are a sin.
It's official. Mr Parker cannot be pleased. Here's an idea, why don't you write your own comic book where you can play by your own rules, safe from the evils of the comics and the movies.
Dan-El
Originally posted by Doc Ock
OH.MY.GOD.
The movies are a sin. The comics are a sin.
It's official. Mr Parker cannot be pleased. Here's an idea, why don't you write your own comic book where you can play by your own rules, safe from the evils of the comics and the movies.
That's what I've been saying, to put his money where is mouth is!
Wait... maybe that was White Rat...

chucktaylor
MJ...But I would've liked Peter and Gwen to get together more if she hadn't died...
spencerspider
Peter loves MJ more
Richv1
Right now he loves Mary Jane more. Originally yes Gwen but not now.
doctorstrongbad
I always liked Gwen better. There is a rumor that they will kill off MJ in part 3, since Dunnst doesn't want to make any more movies.
DigiMark007
Felicia.

maham
I havn't read the comic,but I suppose it's MJ he loves more.Atleast that's how it all seems.
doctorstrongbad
I'm thinking he will end up with Gwen.
the_satan32
If they kill MJ in the third movie I'll trow a party! I don't like her anyway and Dunst makes the character even worse. I hope Venom eats her brains .
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by the_satan32
If they kill MJ in the third movie I'll trow a party! I don't like her anyway and Dunst makes the character even worse. I hope Venom eats her brains .
That would take an R rating, but it could happen.
the_satan32
Who cares about ratings it would be worth it. Besides those ratings are crap, when I was 6 i watched my first horror movie on the big screen but I wasn't bothered at all. My point is that maybe MJ shouldn't be killed so... graphic but should die in this movie. And Peter should get with Gwen and well The End until part 4 ( if there is one).
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by the_satan32
Who cares about ratings it would be worth it. Besides those ratings are crap, when I was 6 i watched my first horror movie on the big screen but I wasn't bothered at all. My point is that maybe MJ shouldn't be killed so... graphic but should die in this movie. And Peter should get with Gwen and well The End until part 4 ( if there is one).
It didn't bother you at The Satan32? hehe Yeah MJ has to go.
the_satan32
Sorry I didn't understand that first part. Can you explain?
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by doctorstrongbad
It didn't bother you at The Satan32? hehe Yeah MJ has to go.
It was suppose to be a joke. You watched a horror movie at 6 and your s/n is The Satan32. lol
Gannon
MJ duh!

Ultraman Baltan
I say tie. He loves both, but for different reasons and in different ways. Not that easy to compare, in my opinion.
the_satan32
Well it is normal to love MJ more because she's alive but if Gwen didn't die he probably would have stayed with her. I think she's just more his type.
doctorstrongbad
Gwen will be in part 3 so watch out.
Spiderman_RJ
right now he loves mj more becouse, well there no one else thre,BUT he has a unresolved love with gwen, like when the sin arc started, he said something like there is 2 things he dont like to be messed, one was her and the other was gwen.not to say gwen was his first true love,betty was only a girlfriend,gwen was true love, mj was a hooker who took advantage of gwen death,even though LATER they made her know he is spiderman ( i still wonder why) from the begining and made that the reason she wanted to confort peter in a way.
in fact since she knew that spider man was peter, i believe mj planed gwens death, after all she wanted peter but convinced gwen to go back to peter,knowing the green goblin was around! so she set up gwens death!
forever gwen!
and dusnt will be up for spider 4, its all about money or you dont get it what they mean when they say "as long as there are good stories to tell" ,so here is s translation : i WANT more money!
she told on a interview her character would be up for spider 4,although that not much decisive since ben was dead on first and keep coming, but i doubt raimi would waste 3 movies seting up peter and mj just to kill her off, and put gwen on her place,after all gwen will be nothing in the movie,so far as i heard, gwen is also a cop in the movie, so the movie gwen is actually the comic jean dewolf (who i also love).
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Spiderman_RJ
right now he loves mj more becouse, well there no one else thre,BUT he has a unresolved love with gwen, like when the sin arc started, he said something like there is 2 things he dont like to be messed, one was her and the other was gwen.not to say gwen was his first true love,betty was only a girlfriend,gwen was true love, mj was a hooker who took advantage of gwen death,even though LATER they made her know he is spiderman ( i still wonder why) from the begining and made that the reason she wanted to confort peter in a way.
in fact since she knew that spider man was peter, i believe mj planed gwens death, after all she wanted peter but convinced gwen to go back to peter,knowing the green goblin was around! so she set up gwens death!
forever gwen!
and dusnt will be up for spider 4, its all about money or you dont get it what they mean when they say "as long as there are good stories to tell" ,so here is s translation : i WANT more money!
she told on a interview her character would be up for spider 4,although that not much decisive since ben was dead on first and keep coming, but i doubt raimi would waste 3 movies seting up peter and mj just to kill her off, and put gwen on her place,after all gwen will be nothing in the movie,so far as i heard, gwen is also a cop in the movie, so the movie gwen is actually the comic jean dewolf (who i also love).
Its a good idea. Do you have any info or links to back it up?
steverules
Yer I would like to see some links, sounds interesting

Spiderman_RJ
the link i got is in portuguese its say cap stacy is.....a captain..and his daughter is deputy or sth on the same station.she is definitely a cop and its said she likes spider-man, but i guess on a way that is agains what most police think of him,not like love but still maybe..
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Spiderman_RJ
the link i got is in portuguese its say cap stacy is.....a captain..and his daughter is deputy or sth on the same station.she is definitely a cop and its said she likes spider-man, but i guess on a way that is agains what most police think of him,not like love but still maybe..
That would be interesting, anyway to translate the link into English?
Spiderman_RJ
sorry couldnt find the proper article in the site,their search engine sucks, keeps bringing stuff that have NO match to your query.
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Spiderman_RJ
sorry couldnt find the proper article in the site,their search engine sucks, keeps bringing stuff that have NO match to your query.
Don't they have the mirror function? That should translate it into english.
Spider-Chris
dude gwen is HOT!!!
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Spider-Chris
dude gwen is HOT!!!
She was hot in the comics, lets hope they make her hot in the movies.

Arachnid1
I don't know anything about Comic gewn except she was jealous of MJ in the begining. I didn't like her then.
If this where their Ultimate Counterparts, I would pick Gewn. Ultimate Gwen was hot, cool, and had a great personality that I really liked. Unlike Ultimate MJ......
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Arachnid1
I don't know anything about Comic gewn except she was jealous of MJ in the begining. I didn't like her then.
If this where their Ultimate Counterparts, I would pick Gewn. Ultimate Gwen was hot, cool, and had a great personality that I really liked. Unlike Ultimate MJ......
Gwen was more of a free spirit. Mj always seems so needy. ugh
Arachnid1
Originally posted by doctorstrongbad
Gwen was more of a free spirit. Mj always seems so needy. ugh
She used to be that person always smilling and dancing down the Street while calling peter something like Dad or Tiger. She is really different know.
I still like her the best though.
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Arachnid1
She used to be that person always smilling and dancing down the Street while calling peter something like Dad or Tiger. She is really different know.
I still like her the best though.
She always calls him Tiger. When did she call him dad?
Arachnid1
Originally posted by doctorstrongbad
She always calls him Tiger. When did she call him dad?
Way, way back in the day when they where still in highschool.
steverules
Peter is secretly MJ's father!

Arachnid1
Originally posted by steverules
Peter is secretly MJ's father!
I alays wondered why she called him that.

Sparkz
Well that is interesting cause Peter also used to call Harry "Dad"...and both have gone out with MJ...hmmmm
steverules
Ok so here it is Harry is Peters dad and Peter is MJ's dad...it's all one sick twisted circle, with incest.
Arachnid1
Originally posted by steverules
Ok so here it is Harry is Peters dad and Peter is MJ's dad...it's all one sick twisted circle, with incest.
And Norman is Harry's dad and he did it with gwen stacy and had harry so Capatin stacy is the green goblins dad.

steverules
They should be ashamed of themselves!
Arachnid1
Originally posted by steverules
They should be ashamed of themselves!
Seriously though, how did the green goblin get it with Gwen Stacy?!?!?!?
steverules
Rape..or he got her really, really drunk
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by Arachnid1
Seriously though, how did the green goblin get it with Gwen Stacy?!?!?!?
Yeah that was so really bad writing IMO. I think they said he black mailed her into it. ugh
steverules
Black mailed her...wtf!?! Seriously that story should've never been made, who wrote that f***ed up storyline?!?
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by steverules
Black mailed her...wtf!?! Seriously that story should've never been made, who wrote that f***ed up storyline?!?
Yeah i was really disappoined but that story arc.
steverules
Every spider-man fan was, part from maybe my friend who bought the graphic Novel
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by steverules
Every spider-man fan was, part from maybe my friend who bought the graphic Novel
They should of went a different way. I would of rather seen robots or clones than dragging Gwen into it.
steverules
I would've rather actually seen a decent story line rather than some piece of garbage of a story
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by steverules
I would've rather actually seen a decent story line rather than some piece of garbage of a story
Normal the writers do a good if not great job. They really dropped the ball on that one. ugh
steverules
I think and hope that they learnt from the mistakes with that story line
doctorstrongbad
Originally posted by steverules
I think and hope that they learnt from the mistakes with that story line
Yeah it would make the story lines better.
steverules
I don't think they will ever bring back GG and Gwens kids
the_satan32
I heard that the writer intended Peter to be the father of the twins but Marvel went against the idea claiming that it would age him. That story ruined Gwen Stacy I blame Marvel if Peter was the father than the story was going to be much better IMO.
steverules
Mite have been better
Sparkz
Personally I thought the story itself was very well done, but like everyone else I don't like how they portrayed Gwen. It would have been better if they were Peter's kids at least it wouldn't have made Gwen seem like a whore, hell it would have been better if she had been raped and not seduced...
Sparkz
Originally posted by steverules
Life sucks
Rather pessimistic comment that.
steverules
Yer...still true though
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2025 KillerMovies.