Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

http://www.xmenfilms.net/layout/OurRevolution/LegendsOfThePhoenixBACKY.jpg

vs

http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/warner_brothers/superman_returns/brandon_routh/supes2.jpg

superman chucks the continent she's on into outer space

Originally posted by superkronick92
superman chucks the continent she's on into outer space
Sounds correct.

been done and depends if you believe she was going easy on Wolverine witch I do

Originally posted by Broly92
been done and depends if you believe she was going easy on Wolverine witch I do
Are you comparing Movie Wolverine with Movie Superman?

Originally posted by badabing
Are you comparing Movie Wolverine with Movie Superman?
No I'm comparing before that she was splitting apart people's molecules but then didn't to Wolverine who


people believe she couldn't but I don't

Originally posted by Broly92
No I'm comparing before that she was splitting apart people's molecules but then didn't to Wolverine who


people believe she couldn't but I don't
Okay. Thanks for setting that straight.

Superman would beat Pheonix.

Phoenix in the movie was killed by claws....im sure Superman could do something

he could blow here away, freeze her, melt her or punch her lightening fast... you choose

Phoenix by mind-raping him, or tearing him apart, anyway by anything she would chose.

Originally posted by superkronick92
superman chucks the continent she's on into outer space
Are you serious? Phoenix wins this all the way. She demolecularizes him automatically.

Movie Supes has zilch for resisting mind effects, so, Pheonix, I dunno, blows up his head or something?

Movie Phoenix was no where near her comic book counterpart in terms of power.

he'd heat vision crisp her before her first thought.

Superman kisses her, and makes her forget that she was in two sequels. Either that or he goes back in time.

Wow, another easy win for Supes.

superman and phoenix merge to becoem super-phoenix, the overrated retarded everyone-fu'ckin-hate-them superhero/villan.

Originally posted by Tron
Superman kisses her, and makes her forget that she was in two sequels. Either that or he goes back in time.

Wow, another easy win for Supes.
But right before she explodes him and gets back at the director from going to X-man to Superman Returns

Pheonix, by demoralizing him with propaganda, or undermining his beleif system.

Superman throws his chest S shield at her, it wraps her up and she suffocates.... then he starts teleporting around the place, makes holograms of himself, makes her memory dissapear, turns back time... then he kicks the sh!t out of himself in a junkyard

Originally posted by Xplosive
Phoenix by mind-raping him, or tearing him apart, anyway by anything she would chose.

No, Superman is too fast.

stalemate. they're such stupidly powerful characters that they never lose to anyone, ever.

Phoenix loses to superman.

Hell she lost to that rodent.

and got stabbed by wolverine, rofl.

Originally posted by Whittdawg92
and got stabbed by wolverine, rofl.

that's what he meant by rodent.......

This is how the fight would go: Jean/Phoenix does her pyscho ***** thing, everything around her is exploding and demolecularizing. Superman comes in at lightspeeed and gives her the biggest *****-slap ever recorded, a 10.5 on the ***** slap scale, and tells her to stop, just stop.

Superman blows her a kiss... and she's knocked off planet.
He gives her a hug and grinds her to dust.
Notices she's looking hot in her skimpy outfit, and turns her to Ash.
Gives her a high five, and rips her torso in half.

Superman kills Jean. Just by thinking it.

Originally posted by Scoobless
Superman throws his chest S shield at her, it wraps her up and she suffocates.... then he starts teleporting around the place, makes holograms of himself, makes her memory dissapear, turns back time... then he kicks the sh!t out of himself in a junkyard



lol that was funny

That's a lot of stuff to do just to beat a woman with powers like hers,

and to reply to a message before this, it was never shown that he has nor hasn't got resistance to telepathic abilities, but because he is superman he probably DOES

and after looking at the deleted scenes, I'ma say Jean has this one.

Originally posted by complexbrother
and after looking at the deleted scenes, I'ma say Jean has this one.

For real , the cup sence does it for me.

Originally posted by rotiart
Gives her a high five, and rips her torso in half.

This image needs to be put in a comic somewhere.

Originally posted by HandOfFate
For real , the cup sence does it for me.

yeah the cup sence was cool, that was real power, they should have kept the extended fight sense ( wolverine vs juggernaut ) and the cup sence in the real movie, it made alot more sense, anyway in the deleted cup sence, jean demolecularizing a steel cup to it's molecular/atomic configuration, controling it's atoms, colliding them so fast that it created a nuclear reation that she used as a weapon in the camp, now that power, if anyone can control things at supatomoc level, then that person can pretty much do anything, she can manipulate all 4 fundermental forces, hence can control supermans ability to even fly if possible or redirect his heat vision etc. Anyway i would have to say that the fight can go either way, i personally think jean/phoenix should win, but again supermans strong aura(force field) can/might prevent him from being demolecularized. The question is, is she strong in enough to control superman altra-dense molecules that makes his aura/indestructability? my guess is if she can then superman is toast, but if she cannot then, sups wins. but as for now i say phoenix though.

Deleted scenes aren't canon.

Superman 10/10

senario A. supes easily kills her, she couldn't even demolecularize wolverine.

senario B. supes spins the world backwards and stops x2 from happening

senario C.supes gets her pregnent and leaves for five years

Wait, which Superman movies are we talking about here? Cause wasn't the originals based off Pre Crisis Superman, while the new is based of current Supes? If so I don't think his feats should carry over.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Wait, which Superman movies are we talking about here? Cause wasn't the originals based off Pre Crisis Superman, while the new is based of current Supes? If so I don't think his feats should carry over.

Don't know where you got the whole current/pre-crisis based movie Superman, but it is the same Superman.

Phoenix wins due to Halle Berry showing up and boring Supes to death with her acting skills.

Originally posted by Superboy Prime
Don't know where you got the whole current/pre-crisis based movie Superman, but it is the same Superman. Like Superman 1 turning back time.

Originally posted by Superboy Prime
Don't know where you got the whole current/pre-crisis based movie Superman, but it is the same Superman.
Well didn't the first Superman movie come out before Crisis on Infinite Earths?

Originally posted by darthgoober
Well didn't the first Superman movie come out before Crisis on Infinite Earths?
The movies don't pay any attention to the comics, my friend. Superman 1, Superman 2, and Superman Returns share continuity.

Originally posted by Big Sexy
Like Superman 1 turning back time.
Remember he had telekinesis in the fourth one too. Plus the whole memory block on Lois, the list goes on and on.

Movie Superman wins and wins huge.

superman socks that hoodrat at the speed of light.

yup or burns her brain out faster then she can block it

Superman would fly really, really fast around the Earth, go back in time to when the Phoenix was a young child, and then proceed to rip her lungs out of her chest.

Fear the S.