Rate the Comic Signature

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



DigiMark007
New "Rating Rules"

1. Your post must have a 1-10 rating. Decimals are acceptable.

2. No posts of "rated" (or the "rated" smiley). If you have already rated someone's signature, wait until someone else joins in to post yours.

3. Brief commentary on the rating is acceptable and encouraged.

4. It's not personal if someone thinks yours is a 4 (or something similar). Some people judge on varying criteria, and many have different standards of what is good and bad. If you can't accept criticism, stay out.

5. Have fun, stay respectful.

....

This wasn't getting any traffic in the movie forum and was stagnating with many of the same people. I wanted to make the new rules, so making an entirely new thread made sense.

...that's all. Enjoy. smile

bigbran
10/10.

NiņoAraņa
droolio 6-7/10

invisiblewoman
i'm sorry i don't get how this works so do i rate nino's sig or do i rate bigbrans sig?

DigiMark007
Originally posted by invisiblewoman
i'm sorry i don't get how this works so do i rate nino's sig or do i rate bigbrans sig?

You rate the one immediately above you.

8.5 btw thumb up

invisiblewoman
Originally posted by DigiMark007
You rate the one immediately above you.

8.5 btw thumb up

aha.... sorry to mess up the chain this rating is for nino

8/10

Blair Wind
Digi - 8/10
IW - 7/10

Now we are back on track smile

NiņoAraņa
BW 8/10...very nicethumb up

long pig
7/10

I dig it.

Priest
Madd funny...7/10

darthgoober
8.5/10

sbo
cool 7/10

Roldz
7/10... On Roquess, you know what it is...

long pig
This was my old one.

It's friggin hand drawn by jinzin the cyber-ninja! I think it's bloody awesome. Best ever made.

http://images.killermovies.com/forums/user_sigs/customsig_83219_yp.gif

juggernaut66666
8/10

thedude1948
9.5/10

Badabing
8/10. That's a very intense looking Surfer.

grey fox
7.8/10

Thing/Hulk beatdowns are teh awesome

Dreampanther
6.5/10

I would have given it more if it wasn't for the "For one to be remembered one must do something of greatness. For good or evil. Greatness must be prevalent though , always prevalent." which to me is a bit preachy (though quite a nice message).

Without that, it would have been closer to 7.5 or 8/10.

Sorry, somebody else would have probably given you a higher rating!

Dinkus Mayhem
7/10

Kind of grainy, but it reminds me of Guenhwyvar though so I like it.

NiņoAraņa
8.3/10....mmmm taskmaster

Dreampanther
7.8/10 I would have given it more, but I just saw a wallpaper with Spidey in the same costume, but with a web and Cap America's shield - it's such an awesome wallpaper that am now prejudiced against anything that doesn't incorporate that wallpaper! Sorry!

In fact, here it is.

Somebody else would have probably given you more, though.

I changed mine a bit - do you guys think I should rather just have one panther, and make that nice and detailed (i.e. a bit bigger) or do you like the lots of big cats version?

Rewmac
none comics sig....If we have new rules we should put that certainly only comic sigs are allowed...Or comic related stuff on the sig...

Dreampanther
Ah, okay - sorry! embarrasment

Rewmac
Originally posted by Dreampanther
Ah, okay - sorry! embarrasment

It's not against you or anything. But there were some difficulities in the other thread. I'm just asking Digi...

Dreampanther
No biggie - because some of the others didn't have comics related signatures, I didn't think it mattered. But I can see the sense in keeping it comics-related, so no worries wink

Priest
Originally posted by Rewmac
It's not against you or anything. But there were some difficulities in the other thread. I'm just asking Digi...
awsome sig.9/10

DigiMark007
6/10

Originally posted by Rewmac
It's not against you or anything. But there were some difficulities in the other thread. I'm just asking Digi...

I think it's understood that it should be "comics" as much as possible. But honestly, if it isn't, I don't think we should worry about it. 90% of the people that will post in this thread will have comic sigs anyway, so it shouldn't be a big deal to rate a non-comic sig occasionally. Hell, my current one probably isn't either.

Spideys Sister
Choatic... I like it. thumb up 9/10

invisiblewoman
Digimark 7/10 creative reminds me of a collage project i did in high school

masterkit
I Love Your Sig ITs Very Koolbig grin

10

jgiant
7/10

What If...
7/10, I like the contrast/ advancement from white to grey.


My sig wins yes

bigbran
That one makes me laugh. 8/10, maybe 9/10.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
6/10



I think it's understood that it should be "comics" as much as possible. But honestly, if it isn't, I don't think we should worry about it. 90% of the people that will post in this thread will have comic sigs anyway, so it shouldn't be a big deal to rate a non-comic sig occasionally. Hell, my current one probably isn't either.
shifty

Faceman
20/10 for sure!!!!!!

Darth Vicious
7/10 only because i dont like how that Nighthawk looks.

I made this Thor sig(click on link) trying somethings. I think it came out good but too big to put it in my profile.

http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/5760/thoranimated3oc0.th.gif

Soujaboy
I give the one Soujaboy has right right now a 10/10.

ThePittman
pitt_7

ThePittman
pitt_rated sorry, just had to do it. stick out tongue

Galan777
9/10

Sub_Mariner
9.5/10.

Galactus=The Bomb.

ThePittman
pitt_7

masterkit
10

rate this

i made it for cain marko

Galan777
Originally posted by masterkit
10

rate this

i made it for cain marko its pretty cool 8/10

masterkit
10

thanx

ThePittman
pitt_7

Ext@nt
9.5/10 , very very nice.

ThePittman
pitt_8 9 if it wasn't for the yellow

Ext@nt
9.5/10

Its cause I'm a member of AMC.

ThePittman
Originally posted by Ext@nt
9.5/10

Its cause I'm a member of AMC. K

Blair Wind
9/10. Who drew the hulk in that pic?

Galan777
10/10 i like that pic of RT alot, its very clear

ThePittman
Originally posted by Blair Wind
9/10. Who drew the hulk in that pic? Dale Keown

NiņoAraņa
Originally posted by ThePittman
Dale Keown 10/10

Black Adam
9/10

Avalonofthewind
Cool sig.
9/10

Ext@nt
8. pretty cool

masterkit
10


My New Sig

Mr Master
8.5

invisiblewoman
9.5 verry nice!

Ext@nt
a 10 for the beautiful lady!! smile

SpunkySmurph
7.5/10

Someone who's a bigger fan of Extant might give it a better rating...

masterkit
9.8

ThePittman
pitt_7

Galan777
pitt_10

ThePittman
pitt_9

Mr Master
Originally posted by ThePittman
pitt_9

9.5

Sub_Mariner
9

masterkit
Originally posted by ThePittman
pitt_9

Inhuman
8

ThePittman
pitt_8

Galan777
pitt_10 wink

juggernaut66666
8,5

ThePittman
pitt_9

leonidas
pittman's hulk is awesome. very cool, very different. 9/10.

Blair Wind
Cant wait for the movie. 8/10

Juggs where did you get the original pic for your sig??

DigiMark007
9

...never liked your avy for this one, but the sig rocks.

And yeah, Pitt's sig right now is very good....just glancing through these, it's probably the most technically challenging on this page (besides maybe mine stick out tongue )

And leo?! I thought you died or something. How's it going?

darthgoober
9.5

Soujaboy
6/10

Badabing
Originally posted by Soujaboy
6/10
9/10. Thor = Kick ass and Rew always does a good job.

Soujaboy
Originally posted by Badabing
9/10. Thor = Kick ass and Rew always does a good job.

Rew is good

Always liked your sig with the Hulk and the Thing, and the Hulk and the Thing.

9.5/10

DigiMark007
7.5

I love that pic of Thor, but the text kinda sticks out and the bg doesn't do much for me. Still, not bad overall.

Soujaboy
Originally posted by DigiMark007
7.5

I love that pic of Thor, but the text kinda sticks out and the bg doesn't do much for me. Still, not bad overall.

I love the pic to, just can't believe I paid $15 for the cover and it wasn't even the real Thor. mad

Ext@nt
8 I like it.

juggernaut66666
9

leonidas
Originally posted by DigiMark007
9

...never liked your avy for this one, but the sig rocks.

And yeah, Pitt's sig right now is very good....just glancing through these, it's probably the most technically challenging on this page (besides maybe mine stick out tongue )

And leo?! I thought you died or something. How's it going?

nah, not dead yet, but this chest infection makes me wish i was! just been really really busy. and shouldn't your sig read leo and kahn's dance party!?

laughing

ThePittman
pitt_8

willRules
10/10


How do you make the sigs the center of a post?

Soujaboy
Originally posted by willRules
10/10


How do you make the sigs the center of a post?



put the sig url between them

juggernaut66666
Originally posted by willRules
10/10


How do you make the sigs the center of a post?
siglink you don't need the "+" signOriginally posted by Soujaboy


put the sig url between them
9

ThePittman
Originally posted by willRules
10/10


How do you make the sigs the center of a post?

the image URL

Take out the quotes

Spideys Sister
Go Hulk! 8/10

willRules
9/10 thumb up


Originally posted by ThePittman
the image URL

Take out the quotes


cheers smile

Soujaboy
6/10

juggernaut66666
9

Ext@nt
We may have fought over Extant but that is one hell of a sweet sig.

10

Grimm22
It took me all day to make, but I finally finished it stick out tongue

here's my hellion sig big grin

Blair Wind
You just had to get a quote like mine *that Ive used for the past FOUR sigs* didnt you?! DIDNT YOU!!! mad

8/10

willRules
9/10

masterkit
10

Rewmac
Nice art...Gotta give 7...Really nice work on the art there.

Black Adam
10/10

SpunkySmurph
9.5/10

My first reaction was a 10/10, and then I looked at it a little more, and took off point five 'cuz of the way some of it looks almost pieced together

Blair Wind
is that SPOT?!

DAMMIT I want him to be featured more


anyways 8/10 for SS

Roldz
Originally posted by Rewmac
Nice art...Gotta give 7...Really nice work on the art there.
9/10 on that SS sig.. I like how those stars reflect over him..
Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
9.5/10

My first reaction was a 10/10, and then I looked at it a little more, and took off point five 'cuz of the way some of it looks almost pieced together
8/10 is that Joker, scary pic non the less..
Originally posted by Blair Wind
is that SPOT?!

DAMMIT I want him to be featured more


anyways 8/10 for SS
8.5/10 on red tornado.. background is cool..

DigiMark007
7

The orange and yellow don't quite work. But a nice tech-feel to it.

...


Originally posted by Blair Wind
is that SPOT?!

DAMMIT I want him to be featured more

I had even bigger plans for the Spot render there, but my vision kinda exceeded my skill. Still, I like how that one turned out, especially the text.

juggernaut66666
8

Rewmac
Originally posted by DigiMark007
7

The orange and yellow don't quite work. But a nice tech-feel to it.

...




I had even bigger plans for the Spot render there, but my vision kinda exceeded my skill. Still, I like how that one turned out, especially the text. Good on the animation and such. But I can' see what is it. 8/10

Originally posted by Roldz
9/10 on that SS sig.. I like how those stars reflect over him...

I like yours just too much on the color stuff. 7/10.

jgiant
9.3

Galan777
8

Rewmac
7-8

Galan777
I like yours alot 9/10

invisiblewoman
i really like yours alot 9/10

juggernaut66666
9 I like it.

DigiMark007
9

Originally posted by Rewmac
Good on the animation and such. But I can' see what is it. 8/10

It's Iron Man...I didn't think it was that hard to make out.

And I just made it scroll, it's not actual animation.

for example...

Rewmac
Like there is a command to it??? Well didn't know that..

Galan777
Originally posted by Rewmac
Like there is a command to it??? Well didn't know that..

Yeah you type:

{scroll}type here{/scroll}

replace { with type here

masterkit
9.3

Rewmac
Originally posted by Rewmac
Nice art...Gotta give 7...Really nice work on the art there.

willRules
9/10 thumb up

juggernaut66666
8

ThePittman
pitt_10

Rewmac
The cut around Deadpool is the one thing I don't like...Outwise it's a cool sig. 8.5

Blair Wind
always liked that original picture (can you send it to me?)

anyways 8/10....somethings off, but I cant place my finger on it. Good overall though big grin

ThePittman
Originally posted by Rewmac
The cut around Deadpool is the one thing I don't like...Outwise it's a cool sig. 8.5 That is the problem with GIF's you can't get a clean cut.

Rewmac
Originally posted by ThePittman
That is the problem with GIF's you can't get a clean cut.
I know. But you don't need to save it as .gif. KMC does it anyway. Save it as .jpg...

masterkit
9.3

ThePittman

Rewmac
You don't have to. I told you. Save it as .jpg and then upload it to KMC. You'll see what I mean.
After you've done it save the uploaded pic beneath your name it will be .gif and it will be transparent.

ThePittman

Rewmac
Well then you've done something wrong my friend. I did it and it worked.

grey fox
7/10

Genis looks kinda Bulky...

Rewmac
6-7/10. I looks dark for me, too dark.

Some rate this please not my current

ThePittman
pitt_7 not your best, a bit cluttered.

Rewmac
Other than that?? Any opinions? Should I use it?

DigiMark007
Yeah...multiple images are tough to pull off well unless you have an absolutely awesome design, or something else to balance them better than normal.

Rewmac
Quess I gotta take lessons from Inhuman big grin

SpunkySmurph
Originally posted by Rewmac
I know. But you don't need to save it as .gif. KMC does it anyway. Save it as .jpg...

What do you mean by that? I'm curious and confused

Oh, and a 9/10 for Rew

Rewmac
Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
What do you mean by that? I'm curious and confused

Oh, and a 9/10 for Rew

Doesn't matter I confused some stuff...

DarkCrawler
9/10. Nice use of effects. smile

I need to change mine soon...

Tha C-Master
You did... smile

9.5, and rockin' avvy!

Rewmac
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
9/10. Nice use of effects. smile

I need to change mine soon...

9/10 - It's nice to see you still with us sometimes when it comes to sigmakin'

I would give 10 for the sig but it's 9 coz Namor is on it roll eyes (sarcastic) shifty

10/10 for the avy.

juggernaut66666
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
9/10. Nice use of effects. smile

I need to change mine soon...
Damn it that sig is Fcuking awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rewmac
Originally posted by juggernaut66666
Damn it that sig is Fcuking awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Maaan don't overreact...It's Namor in it... stick out tongue wink

ThePittman
pitt_8

invisiblewoman
yours looks really good! very unique i like how he is jumping out at you!

9.5/10 cuz i haven't seen one like that!

jgiant
8

ThePittman
pitt_10pitt_shifty

juggernaut66666
103

ThePittman
pitt_10

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>