Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

On a scale of 1-10. Rate the persons above debating skills.

9.1

9.2

Esp in Reality vs Time Manip and Extant vs Witch.

6/10 havent seen enough to tell, but you did alright against DR

9.0

Always presents proof to back up your statements.

8. I like your work in the tourney, good job!

9. You always make logically and well thought out decisions

8. I haven't seen you acting stupid or immature.

8

You do a good job

8.5 always stating facts

I don't really know you but i'll give you an 8

7 A bit above average, and you've come a long way from whence you started.

You dislike Wolverine fanboys. You deserve a ten.


15.0/10

Haven't seen you post as much so I won't give you an unfair rating...

8/10 for scooping up Wolverine fanboys and bopping them on the heads.

Originally posted by Soleran
8/10 for scooping up Wolverine fanboys and bopping them on the heads.

10 for the little bunny foo foo reference!

havnt seen you around long enoughOriginally posted by grey fox
8

You do a good job

Originally posted by outavodka
havnt seen you around long enough
I'm not really familiar with your posting, so I'll just give you a 7 for never saying anything that stood out in my mind as particularly stupid.

Haven't debated with you that I can remember so no rating

darth goober 9.7/10 great debater! knows his stuff!

5

Originally posted by batdude123
5



8.5/10

you always debate very well

7/10..seen you debate kinda sorta around....nothing stupid so yeah

Originally posted by invisiblewoman
darth goober 9.7/10 great debater! knows his stuff!
Wow. Thanks a lot IW.
Originally posted by NiñoAraña
7/10..seen you debate kinda sorta around....nothing stupid so yeah
I figure somewhere around 8.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Wow. Thanks a lot IW.

I figure somewhere around 8.

IW is right tho, i give ya a 9.5

EC's a 8.7

9.5 you seemed to know quite a bit of the X-series and i mostly agree with what you say, mostly .

Knows his surfer. Gotta say 8.5/10 for providing evidence when needed

9.5 Always a pleasure. You really know your Iceman and Red Tornado

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Knows his surfer. Gotta say 8.5/10 for providing evidence when needed BW gets a 9/10, i've seen him debate a few times, good stuff!



i'ma veteran?

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Knows his surfer. Gotta say 8.5/10 for providing evidence when needed
9.5 for turning me into an Iceman fanboy... and being hated in another forum.... B@#$rds....

Originally posted by King_Mungi
1203 posts, yeah you have been around for awhile.
9.1/10 always a good debater and when it comes to Alpha Flight 10000/10

Kiing Mungi is a 9/10. Never understand the stuff he debates on. But he sure knows a heck of alot more stuff about Alpha Flight than we do.

bah! I know more than just AF, I particpate in all debates not just the Canadian badasses

Originally posted by King_Mungi
1203 posts, yeah you have been around for awhile.
Hey ive got higher post than him.. does that make me a veteran..lol
9.5 pretty good debater for Mungi i mean, always have interesting replies...

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Thanks man. Since you got skipped I gotta say 7-8/10 depending on the debate at hand. Ive been noticing more and more of your posts so that may change for the better



yea I dont debate much after the tournies since I like the intensity and regular debates arnt as stimulating. Thanks though cant really say Ive seen you debate all that much. But you havent said anything blatantly stupid so 6/10 for now. I will get better Im sure when I read more

and holy crap, I just realized Ive been on this forum for more than a year now


REALLY Ive done my job then Whats this forum that hates you for being a Iceman fan? 8.5/10

Mungi? 9.7/10 (.3 off for thinking Puck can beat Galactus )

Broly dont know well enough to rate. So if someone rates him I think we can now go back to rating the person on top (I did this since so many people got skipped)
PCS and CBRF... lol Got him beating SS, Insane Genis and the Celestials..lol

Originally posted by Roldz
Hey ive got higher post than him.. does that make me a veteran..lol
9.5 pretty good debater for Mungi i mean, always have interesting replies...
The funny thing is that you've both been here longer than I have, and my post count is at 1,984. I guess I talk a lot.

(Oh yeah, I give Brolly somewhere between 8 and 8.5, when he actually get's serious about the debate at hand.)

Yeah you cause a lot of Ruckus on this forum, just kidding..
9.5 pretty familiar with SS.. Scans you've provide a lot.. lately..

9 (At least for LIKING Captain Atom )

9.0. Maybe higher?

Originally posted by bigbran
9.0. Maybe higher?
9.

You remain impartial even when it's your sig character involved in the debate, and are always willing to accept actual evidence.

Originally posted by batdude123
9 (At least for LIKING Captain Atom )

Rating: 9/10
Reason: Your a regular here, and knowledgable with not just one characters but several. Your a regular name here.

Originally posted by bigbran
9.0. Maybe higher?

Rating: 15/10
Reason: Your Canadian, how could I not? really 7.5/10 possbily higher as I'm trying to remember some of your posts...and it's late

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Rating: 9/10
Reason: Your a regular here, and knowledgable with not just one characters but several. Your a regular name here.



Rating: 15/10
Reason: Your Canadian, how could I not? really 7.5/10 possbily higher as I'm trying to remember some of your posts...and it's late
9/10. You're usually level headed and in the know about comics.

9/10

Originally posted by darthgoober
9.

You remain impartial even when it's your sig character involved in the debate, and are always willing to accept actual evidence. My sig character is Jessica Alba...

Originally posted by bigbran
9/10

My sig character is Jessica Alba...
Well, FORMER sig character then.

Originally posted by bigbran
9/10

My sig character is Jessica Alba...
9/10. You've come a long way since your early days.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Well, FORMER sig character then.
9.5/10. You've been impressive since your first post.

Bada 9/10

Only other thing fan on the boards

8/10 u know ur fansastic four stuff good

8.0..........

Because our views never conflict.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
8.0..........

Because our views never conflict.
8.0/10 solid debater

Originally posted by Blair Wind

Mungi? 9.7/10 (.3 off for thinking Puck can beat Galactus )


I never said that , all though midgets in a singlet > power cosmic....anyone?

BW:
Rating: 9.7/10 HA!
Reason: Guy is level headed, regular member, contributes greatly, well versed.

Knows his stuff, and is willing to listen and learn if he isn't familiar with the characters.

8.5 off that alone

I'm going to say 8 although I don't see you around extensively, the one thing that "bothers" me, is that half of these "nominations" have little to do with the said debating talent (which in raw sense is how clearly and effectively one can get their opinion across, no matter the topic.)

Knowledge in general is different.

8.5

Originally posted by batdude123
9 (At least for LIKING Captain Atom )

Have to give Batdude a 9. Knows his Batman and is pretty articulate in conveying his thoughts. And he does a nice job of not coming across as a fanboy.

9 Very well made and logical points, more importantly you stay polite and don't resort to flaming.

9

2/10




















nah, 9/10, because you represent your character right. Without twisting everything in comics.

Originally posted by bigbran
2/10




















nah, 9/10, because you represent your character right. Without twisting everything in comics.


9/10
Because, sometimes I don't like you but you still make me respect your opinions.

Most of the time.

(Whatever I get, I'll laugh or smile )

EDIT: Oh yeah. And a " " to the Capt post. (Capt, I rate you a... 8/10. Because, whether I like it or not, you know your Wolverine stuff.)

Have not read most of your posts, but any good debator worth his salt can quote others....so 5.5/10 until you mess up or get better.

8/10

9/10. lol.. Some really funn ones..

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Have not read most of your posts, but any good debator worth his salt can quote others....so 5.5/10 until you mess up or get better.

Well fine. Then as promised

Now go away








































Oh yeah, and 8.5/10 for Roldz. He knows his stuff, but sometimes the view seems to be the same, repeated one from the past posters. I know what he means, but it would be nice to see it put a different way, or having new evidence/etc. brought to the table. I haven't seen him that often though, so don't take this the wrong way.

Originally posted by Roldz
9/10. lol.. Some really funn ones..
9.5/10 knows his Surfer.

Originally posted by thedude1948
9.5/10 knows his Surfer.
9.7 always agreing with what replies you post man..

8.5 for SpunkySmurph havent crossed with you yet..

7.5

8.7

8. A 9 in any Iceman thread.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
8. A 9 in any Iceman thread.
8, Doing pretty well against Wolverine worshippers and generally. Not a nine because of certain Thing vs Cap thread

Originally posted by Jyppe
8, Doing pretty well against Wolverine worshippers and generally. Not a nine because of certain Thing vs Cap thread Hence changing my name to "hater slayer". Though admittedly I don't get involved as much as is unless something strikes my fancy. Happens to all the older members.

8.5
fanoboy slayer!

Originally posted by bigbran
2/10


nah, 9/10, because you represent your character right. Without twisting everything in comics.

I think Capt has a duel personality

Some days he is an 8-9/10

and other days he is a 2-3/10

8.5/10 Sometimes I can disagree with you pretty good but most of the time we agree. One of the only guys I know that stick up for Thing in any situation. I respect that.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
8.5/10 Sometimes I can disagree with you pretty good but most of the time we agree. One of the only guys I know that stick up for Thing in any situation. I respect that.

8/10. You know what you're talking about most of the time, and you've thought up some pretty awesome matches.

7.5 i think you're the one who knows a ton about venom...the score would have been higher, but i happen to dislike venom, i dont hate him, just dislike so you get docked a few points for guilt by association

Always a pleasure. Thanks. You know your Colossus and you stick up for Beast when sometimes no one wants to. 8.5/10

Originally posted by manjaro
7.5 i think you're the one who knows a ton about venom...the score would have been higher, but i happen to dislike venom, i dont hate him, just dislike so you get docked a few points for guilt by association

Woah, that's not me, my friend. I never once suggested I know a lot about Venom.

Me thinks you have me confused with someone else.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Always a pleasure. Thanks. You know your Colossus and you stick up for Beast when sometimes no one wants to. 8.5/10

Thanks. I sure try to at least. It's much harder to stick up for a character when no one else likes him, haha.

i dont want to sound like some little bratty mc matty but i stick up for beast alot, and its well known....SO WHY THE HELL DO YOU WANNA TAKE MY 8.5 AWAY FROM ME?!?

Originally posted by manjaro
i dont want to sound like some little bratty mc matty but i stick up for beast alot, and its well known....SO WHY THE HELL DO YOU WANNA TAKE MY 8.5 AWAY FROM ME?!?

Wha? What did I do?

I assumed he was referring to me because of my constant backing of both Beast AND Colossus.

I give him 8/10. Eventhough I give him a hard time more often than not hes right, but sometimes I can catch him slipping.

P.S. Ignore tha race thread.

I'll say 5/10 haven't seen you debate enough although do seem like a reasonably intelligent person.

Fair enough I usually debate on anything to do with Cap and street levelers. I dont know that much as some of the other because I haven't read a comic in ages. Im stuck in the classic era and I keep finding out people have had upgrades!

Sorry haven't seen you debate, or I can't remember.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Fair enough I usually debate on anything to do with Cap and street levelers. I dont know that much as some of the other because I haven't read a comic in ages. Im stuck in the classic era and I keep finding out people have had upgrades!

Sorry haven't seen you debate, or I can't remember. Thats alright I really don't debate that much

newjak's a 8.5 He always manages to crack me up with one of his jokes.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
newjak's a 8.5 He always manages to crack me up with one of his jokes. Hey Darth why did the Chicken Cross the Road...
To get to the other side

Originally posted by newjak86
Hey Darth why did the Chicken Cross the Road...
To get to the other side




Brilliant! 10/10 just for that!

Originally posted by newjak86
Hey Darth why did the Chicken Cross the Road...
To get to the other side



Seriously, there was this one joke that you made awhile back. Can't remember. Me and a few others were dying laughing.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Fair enough I usually debate on anything to do with Cap and street levelers. I dont know that much as some of the other because I haven't read a comic in ages. Im stuck in the classic era and I keep finding out people have had upgrades!

Sorry haven't seen you debate, or I can't remember.

9. We seem to end up in the same threads alot so I know how you debate. Logically thinking is a must for me and you use that. You try to back up every point you make and if you're sure of something you'll ask cause you want to make sure you've got the right info.

7 not to sure yet, havent read a lot of your post..

I have no idea... so 10, until i see you prove otherwise...

yes, i always think the best of people...

8.8... Hiya PR.

Originally posted by pr1983
I have no idea... so 10, until i see you prove otherwise...

yes, i always think the best of people...
lol, i quess 10 for you too man, till proven otherwise.. One good post deserve another..lol again..

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
8.8... Hiya PR.

howdy...

Originally posted by Roldz
lol, i quess 10 for you too man, till proven otherwise.. One good post deserve another..lol again..

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
8.8... Hiya PR.
9 mostly disagree w/ your replies, once ive crossed that is.. but has merit..

Originally posted by Roldz
9 mostly disagree w/ your replies, once ive crossed that is.. but has merit..

I only slightly recognize you, but I think you usually do pretty well.

8.5-9/10

Good debator when he wants to be

Rated.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
8.5-9/10

Good debator when he wants to be



When I want to be. .

We all already know how good Blair Wind is. Look at all the mad iceman respect he got going in the vs. forum.

8.7 /10

8/10. You usually know what you're talking about.

8.8 You are levelheaded and logical.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
8.8 You are levelheaded and logical.

Damn straight.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Damn straight.

9... always good to see you in a colossus thread...

Originally posted by pr1983
9... always good to see you in a colossus thread...

9. Just as good as it is to see you in a Cyclops thread.

8.7

He gives respect to Beast, when everyone else here thinks he's a punk. He also knows a lot about Colossus.

Originally posted by batdude123
8.7

He gives respect to Beast, when everyone else here thinks he's a punk. He also knows a lot about Colossus.
8.9 knows more about batman then almost any one in these forums

Gracias

8.79856412369875469756315

His Wolverine knowledge is second to none.

9.99 baby! i think we share a common interset in pedophilia....dont we pal?thumbup1

Oh.... yeah.....

you know it....



8.5

Originally posted by batdude123
Oh.... yeah.....

you know it....



8.5 9.3, he knows his comics! not only batman!

Originally posted by batdude123
Oh.... yeah.....

you know it....



8.5
9/10

pitt_8 haven't messed with ya to much.

So I think its safe to assume this thread is just for asskissing

At least until Wolvertooth shows up

Originally posted by Grimm22
So I think its safe to assume this thread is just for asskissing

At least until Wolvertooth shows up
8.5, for sticking by your guy most of the time, but admitting when he's totally outclassed.

9

You've been very impressive from the time you've arrived here...

Batdude is cool when his fanboyism isnt consuming his soul

Batdude- 7-9/10

Inhuman- 7-9.3/10

Originally posted by Broly92
Batdude- 7-9/10

Inhuman- 7-9.3/10

8.5/10

does inhuman get the .3 for the AMC?

I'll say 7/10 he seems to think DB Characters are alot stronger than hat they really are but the sig is sweet.

Originally posted by newjak86
I'll say 7/10 he seems to think DB Characters are alot stronger than hat they really are but the sig is sweet.

Was that for broly? Or Me?

Originally posted by Inhuman
Was that for broly? Or Me? Broly

Originally posted by newjak86
Broly
9.3(when your not drunk )

Originally posted by darthgoober
9.3(when your not drunk )

8.0 haven't read alot of your posts in debates

Why are people giving high scores to others when they haven't even seen them debate?

9

You know I've seen you debate...

Originally posted by batdude123
9

You know I've seen you debate...

Now I know I've seen youuuuuu debate

9/10

bats rox. 8.5.

accl's good too. 8.5.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Damn straight.

9. Logical and knows your stuff

Originally posted by Accel
Why are people giving high scores to others when they haven't even seen them debate?

Don't know but interesting forum nevertheless...

I don't know half the people in this thread but I'm going to give everyone a 10/10 just to keep the status quo going.

4

Originally posted by Accel
Why are people giving high scores to others when they haven't even seen them debate?
I was more perplexed at people getting 9's for knowing one character.

That said, Avalon gets a 9 because the man knows his Superman.

and val gets a 10 because i've not been around much lately and forget how much he sucks.

Originally posted by batdude123
4
9 because you know your...well, I'm sure theres some character you know.

Originally posted by Validus
9 because you know your...well, I'm sure theres some character you know.

10.... because.... um.... yay!!! leftright

This was to Validus:

9.7/10

One of the best debators when he wants to debate. He is second to none in DC knowledge

Batdude:

8.5/10

Only comes accross as a fanboy SOMETIMES...but most of the times he is very knowledgable

My Superman Blue disciple:

That automatically rates a 9 or above.

Avy: 9.25

BW: 8.9

bw -- 8.725

avy -- 8.7251

all the decimals are killin' me. as are all these 9+'s. damn, i never realized how awesome all the debaters on this site were!

9.5 (winner of the tourney)

Originally posted by Blair Wind
This was to Validus:

9.7/10


Batdude:

8.5/10


Ouch.

100/10

7.9/10