Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

http://img301.imageshack.us/img301/5914/newherculesae5.jpg

Vs.

http://www.brokenfrontier.com/img/2005/mar/marvel/HERCUL003_COV.jpg

Marvel

The real one. The good one. The Marvel character.



(for being much cooler)

They're the same....

Except DC Hercules is a bit of an a-hole.

Stalemate.

Better yet, Hercules vs. Hercules vs. Herakles.

Didn't DC recently seperate the Greek and Roman pantheons? So Captain Marvel's strength comes from a DIFFERENT Herakles than Wonder Woman is superior to?

Apparently there's millions of Hercules and Zeuses in the DCU...whatever.....

Originally posted by Draco69
They're the same....

Except DC Hercules is a bit of an a-hole.

Stalemate.

No they're not.

marvel Hercules is cooler, specially after he killed Clor
so marvel Hercules

Where are the scans on wich Hercules made laugh Galactus?

Marvel Hercules.

This ain't no popularity contest

Originally posted by Milkie
This ain't no popularity contest

No one has viewed it as such. Marvel Hercules wins simply because he's the more established character.

Originally posted by His Airness
No one has viewed it as such. Marvel Hercules wins simply because he's the more established character.

Originally posted by JuanJohnboy
marvel Hercules is cooler, specially after he killed Clor
so marvel Hercules

More established character doesn't mean anything.

Superman is more established then Tenebrous and Aegis but that doesn't mean he can defeat them.

Originally posted by Milkie
More established character doesn't mean anything.

Superman is more established then Tenebrous and Aegis but that doesn't mean he can defeat them.

When you take two characters whom are close in tier the more established character usually takes the majority due to more feats.

Two primordial gods and Superman aren't even comparable characters.

Marvel Hercules takes it. He has more recorded feats than his DC counterpart. Besides DC Hercules often plays the part of a villain. You know he would lose.

They both pale in comparation with the original Heracles tho. He would defeat either those two in fashion.

MarvelHerc takes it.

MythicHerc would still own him though 313

you do know that dc hercules is the same as hercules from myth. plus he is just as strong as marvel hercules but with supersonic speed or better as he speedbiltz cheatah. and as herold champion he could fly. dc hercules is more powerful than marvel hercules because he psooessed a portion of the godwave as do all dc olympians gods

Originally posted by hunbu04
you do know that dc hercules is the same as hercules from myth. plus he is just as strong as marvel hercules but with supersonic speed or better as he speedbiltz cheatah. and as herold champion he could fly. dc hercules is more powerful than marvel hercules because he psooessed a portion of the godwave as do all dc olympians gods

Because that makes sense. DC Herc is the mythic one . . . but he can move at supersonic speeds, fly and chanel the energy of the "godwave".




Aren't both of them supposed to be the mythic one anyway?

Originally posted by hunbu04
you do know that dc hercules is the same as hercules from myth

Sure, in the DC Universe thats who hes suppose to be. But im talking in comparing the comic book versions with the original one. The same way you can compare the comic book Conan with the original Novel Conan.

With that in mind: Mythical Herc would defeat either. Because he was the original, smarter, fast, with more guts, with more powerful gear and much better figthing skills.


Originally posted by hunbu04
plus he is just as strong as marvel hercules but with supersonic speed or better as he speedbiltz cheatah

DC version of Hercules its a shading issue. Either he never did the high end feats hes known for (wich hes been show to say he didnt) or its implied that he did by other characters (wich it has also been, namely WW and Atlas).

Both are top tiers, but since the Marvel version has more feats on its resume against more top tier treats, he gets the nod.

Plus, when did DC Hercules speedblitzed Chetah? WW#3?


Originally posted by hunbu04
B]and as herold champion he could fly. dc hercules is more powerful than marvel hercules because he psooessed a portion of the godwave as do all dc olympians gods

Well yes, but we only know he could, thanks to a retcon recently made. He couldnt against say the DD clone when he helped WW.

Even if he can, wich is cool, fligth alone isent enough to take top tiers down, and i frankly dont see overall the DC Phanteon as more powerful than theyr Marvel counterparts. They have on each some pll more powerful than the others, wich makes it overall balanced in the end.

Marvel Hercules.

, the other ones a boy-loving.. boy-lover.

"Thou art no Hercules!".

The original Herc was Bi, as per usual in his culture, and he was more badass than either the comic book versions.

If i have to chose between either Marvel or DC version tho, i chose Marvel by a fair margim. At least they make an effort to make him alike, instead of messing completley the character like post crisis DC did. The only good thing DC Hercules does have that i like, its sometimes the visual.

dc's herc is stronger he can lift 400,000 tons while marvels can only lift 100 tons

Originally posted by demonslayer03
dc's herc is stronger he can lift 400,000 tons while marvels can only lift 100 tons

The one who regularly has women willingly have sex with him.

Originally posted by demonslayer03
dc's herc is stronger he can lift 400,000 tons while marvels can only lift 100 tons lulz

Go to Marvel Herc's respect thread.

I know DC's Herc recently bloodied superman's nose and knocked him through a building...........don't know if marvel herc could do likewise as he got manhandled by Wonder Woman in the avengers/jla crossover as SHE usually gets manhandoled by supes whenever they fight!

Originally posted by lawest9
I know DC's Herc recently bloodied superman's nose and knocked him through a building...........don't know if marvel herc could do likewise as he got manhandled by Wonder Woman in the avengers/jla crossover as SHE usually gets manhandoled by supes whenever they fight!
He got a free shot on Superman.

Herc also was able to physically restrain her in the same crossover...

Originally posted by Enyalus
He got a free shot on Superman.

Herc also was able to physically restrain her in the same crossover... Perhaps......but he looked hard pressed in trying to do so while her restraining him looked much more impressive, beside she was also being power stinged by hank and jan while he was restraining HER!

Only DC one that stands a chance is the Hercules Unbound one. I believe he was even stronger than Marvel's.

Originally posted by lawest9
Perhaps......but he looked hard pressed in trying to do so while her restraining him looked much more impressive, beside she was also being power stinged by hank and jan while he was restraining HER! We don't use crossovers here.

DC Hercules dose not have marvel Hercules fighting skills.