Originally posted by Sado22
oh so now ore-sama is required to come up with proof that a person from one game can beat one from another......and yet you all have been going on and on about how Gouki would smash practically anyone from other games. sounds fair.
okay but since you want one:
lets compare feets:
-has Ryu beaten a hightier? no
-has ryu defeated godtier? no
-has Terry defeated hightiers? yes
-has Terry defeated godtiers? yes
so isn't that proof enough that Terry is superior as a fighter?
I didn't say Gouki would beat absolutely everyone, Rugal came damn close, and I did say Orochi would outright rip him, since Orochi is comparable to Darkstalker power levels... Where did I say Akuma would beat anyone he's up against?
RYU DEFEATED SAGAT... stop denying it, stop trying to get around it, Hell I wonder if that cheapshotting argument is just something Tiamat cooked up to fill in the blanks... the fight scene from the animated movie looked more plausable to me... Hovever, lets assume your correct for a moment... Why in the hell did Sagat drop his guard if the match wasn't over? why act like a nOOb and lower your hand and almost get sliced in two?
Ryu killed A3 Bison, there's nothing to disrepute this, and he still defeated Akuma and impressed Oro. so, infact ryu defeated two God Tiers and impressed a third well enough to train him.
Originally posted by Sado22
Logic.
Ryu, a uppertier but by no means a hightier defeated non-serious Gouki (and thanx for the heads up for that one by the way). correct?
Nightmare Geese is godtier. correct?
so if non-serious gouki lost to non-hightier Ryu, and it took Terry Bogard to go beserker to defeat godtier Nightmare Geese, making Terry as berserker a hightier or possibly godtier. correct?
hence Nightmare Geese>>nonserious Akuma
Thats not proof, thats circular logic... even a nonserious Gouki shattered an island
Originally posted by Sado22
Gouken defeated Gouki. then Gouki killed Gouken when Gouken was too old to be at Gouki's level.
Gouki stalemated against Gen in SFA2 (but Gen saw it as defeat since akuma left him). one year later, Gen defeated him in SFA3 as is now generally believed to be true...further confirmed by Tiamat.
Gouki failed to impress Oro.
Gill wasn't even killed by Gouki...not to mention how he just showed up and did the sgs to him like he always does for kicks.
Thats bullshit, Oro is far older than Gouken, and he still lo st despite being at a comparative level to Gouki at the time, there was no excuse for Gouken losing short of the Dark Hadou. (They are brothers, Gouken want that much older than Akuma)
The fight with Gen was a victory for Akuma, Akuma spared Gen because the old man was Dying from Leukemia. the battle in A3 was a stalemate. if Gen had won that match, why is akuma still alive, it was gen who wanted the deathmatch after all... And your still using Tiamats FAQ to justify everything? please... do your own research...
Akuma drew even with Oro, and that impressed the old man, but he certainly couldn't pass his teachings to Akuma, him being a \n evcil soul drenched in the dark Hadou.
Akuma, NEVER just Demons a guy for no reason... even your Tiamat FAQ should have told you that, Akuma seeks the worthiest challenges, they fought, Gill got Demoned, and ressurected later. Akuma won via KO.
Originally posted by Sado22
a little above you were asking for proof for me saying something like that, weren't you?
Ryu cheapshotted Sagat and stop making it sound like it was a fair win.
Ryu didn't defeat bison since it was only YOUR opinion. doesn't count.
Ryu defeated Akuma who was toying around testing Ryu...though i admit it was impressive, it hardly counts as a legimate win since Gouki wasn't serious.
Read above, I'm not repeating myself for your pleasure...
Originally posted by Sado22
and YET a few lines up your commenting on how FF godtiers are not up to the SF godtiers. get real DSZ.
I said there are discrepencies... you make tiers sound like the be all and end all of debates... please man, some of the guys Ryu has had to fight would probably mop the floor with Terry... or vice versa... I'm not Bias about my oppinions, but when I see arguments like that brought up as fact, I get irritated...
"Terry beat Nightmare geese, so he must be better than Ryu since Ryu couldn't beat a fully serious Akuma."
Seriously, WTF does NG have to do with Akuma? what do FF tiers mean to SF? hell man, I never go by Tier lists anyway, I go by each characters individual merrit alone, and that should be enough... generalising characters by tiers is very misleading, it overrates some characters while underrating others.
Originally posted by Sado22
oh wait so YOU can but i can't. please.
stop contradicting yourself.
again:
-Ryu didnot destroy Bison
-Ryu cheapshotted Sagat
-Ryu lost to Sagat in SFA3 as Psycho Ryu
-Ryu DID impress Oro, but Oro wasn't serious
-Ryu beat non-serious Akuma who was only testing Ryu
-Ryu did NOT STOP Akuma (where did you get that anyway)
Terry Board:
-beat Nightmare Geese in a life and death match
-beat godtier Krauser by outlasting him
-beat Jin twins by outlasting them (and of course brainy will pop his head up and say that Geese helped him, yet i dare to ask you what it means to fight two hightiers at the same damn time...probably somewhere around the level of godtier don't it?)
-beat Geese in a life and death match who is hightier
-Ryu didnot destroy Bison - I demand you prove this.
-Ryu cheapshotted Sagat - Addressed above
-Ryu lost to Sagat in SFA3 as Psycho Ryu - which means nothing since it was not Ryu himself, he was being controlled.
-Ryu DID impress Oro, but Oro wasn't serious - Prove it
-Ryu beat non-serious Akuma who was only testing Ryu
-Ryu did NOT STOP Akuma (where did you get that anyway) - Well, he didn't KO Akuma, but he did stop him, and Ryu was fighting him while he was still strong enough to shatter that island... that demonstrates quite a bit to me.
All those terry feats mean precisely DICK if the Opponents arn't a mact for the best opponents Ryu has faced... and this is where your Tier arguments fall apart... name one character out of those lists of feats that can beat the Characters Ryu has faced. Nightmare geese? probably gets stopped by Akuma, Krauser he loses to Bison, the jins probably also fall to Akuma, Geese probably stops at Sagat or Bison.