Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I think the title says it all.

Create a what if that you'd like to see and explain what would happen in it (and why if possible).

What if : The Avengers debuted in the 1800's

"It is a grim time in London , a serial killers daubs the walls , and mocks the law , with almost Supernatural prowess he makes his way through the sooty London highway's. People cry for blood in return , vengeance. There is another way though , a way..of avengment ! "

Featuring : James Howlett , 'Charles 'Charlie' Xavier' , Luke Cage , John "Jack" Starsmore , Jacob Montgomery and Nathaniel Essex.

What if Odin had not died?

Originally posted by Fanboy
What if Odin had not died?


Never mind I said that.

What if Wasp had never been born?

The marvel universe becomes a better place.

What id Deadpool became a herald of Galactus.
That would be a interesting read

Originally posted by Priest
What id Deadpool became a herald of Galactus.
That would be a interesting read

That would be Awesome.

Originally posted by Priest
What id Deadpool became a herald of Galactus.
That would be a interesting read

That would be one of the best sells in Marvel history.

Originally posted by Martian_mind
What if Wasp had never been born?

The marvel universe becomes a better place.

Why all the hatred towards Wasp?

Damn you for coming up with that first. That has to be one of the best What If's I've ever heard.

What if Cable...., got infected by Joker Venom? Or, what if.....Rugal Bernstein took over the hand? Or.... Sebastian Shaw convinced Jean Grey to rejoin the Hellfire club as the black queen? And have her face off against Selene for the title. Can you say: "catfight"? naughty


Edit: the first part was in reference to DP being a herald. And Wasp just sucks.

"What If... People stopped making stupid threads?"

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
What if Cable...., got infected by Joker Venom? Or, what if.....Rugal Bernstein took over the hand? Or.... Sebastian Shaw convinced Jean Grey to rejoin the Hellfire club as the black queen? And have her face off against Selene for the title. Can you say: "catfight"? naughty

Uh? No, What If Apocalypse?

Ok, I was tempted. But I decided since they're either going to bury the character as garbage, or bring him back as the badass he is, no point. The reason I say that: Apoc was contacted by the celestials and told that the time for repayment has come. Which means, he's either coming back even more powerful (or back to his old levels), or he's staying dead for good this time.

Besides, he kicked your ass didn't he, Mr. High Evolutionary?

Originally posted by Martian_mind
That would be Awesome.
Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
That would be one of the best sells in Marvel history.
yea, imagine all the laughs we would able to get out of that book.
When deadpool had thor's powers that made me

"GET THEE A LIFE!"

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Besides, he kicked your ass didn't he, Mr. High Evolutionary?

Do you wanna gonna back in the box? glare

What If

"Superman was getting really old and started to loose his powers"

Originally posted by Evil_Ash
Do you wanna gonna back in the box? glare


apocalypse *slumps down* No. It's not fair. You're just some crazy mad scientist and you don't even show up in comics that much. I'm in the top 10 of mutants on earth (not counting reality warpers) and for some reason, they pick me to job out to the Xmen. I need a new agent...and new writers. I feel like Hudlin did the writing for the last couple of years. but....I still kicked your ass. *turns arms into jet engines and flies off*

What if Wolverine's claws came out his eyeknobs?

Originally posted by Beta Ray Howard
What if Wolverine's claws came out his eyeknobs?



well the artists would have to be clever in order to draw the fights (and find his eyeknobs)

What if Wasp was more popular then Wolverine.

Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
What if Wasp was more popular then Wolverine.

fanboys would be much funnier in debates



What If Batman managed to conquer DC earth?

Not entirely a what-if, consider what Ra's did in the tower of Babel arc. He was using Batman's plans, which means it's within the realm of possibility that Batman, with enough prep, could beat most of DC earth.

As for afterwards, well, didn't they do this with the Justice Syndicate in the anti-matter universe?

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Not entirely a what-if, consider what Ra's did in the tower of Babel arc. He was using Batman's plans, which means it's within the realm of possibility that Batman, with enough prep, could beat most of DC earth.

shocking Batman has plans to conquer the world!?!?!?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
shocking Batman has plans to conquer the world!?!?!?

That's just in case the world would ever go rouge

What IF...
Danny Phantom, the Mon Colle Knights and the Teen Titans
defeated the Justice League and were the only heroes
of DC?
Now that's a mouth full...

What if the Living Tribunal became a Supreme Court Justice?

What if Wonder Woman had a sex change.

Originally posted by Beta Ray Howard
What if Wonder Woman had a sex change.

I would pay to see that...



What if the Punisher was gay?

What if Thor was identical to the mythological Thor?

what if wolverine and sabretooth become bestfriends ?

Originally posted by Artemis1860
I would pay to see that...



What if the Punisher was gay? maybe he is

Originally posted by Artemis1860
I would pay to see that...



What if the Punisher was gay?

What if Captain America became Bisexual

^ROFL

What if Deadpool got Franklin Richard's powers...

What if Wonder Woman looked like a real amazon (dark straighter hair, one boob, as they cut one off so they can fire a bow properly) and didn't dress like a fashion trainwreck living as a transvestite prostitute?

Originally posted by Artemis1860
What if Wonder Woman looked like a real amazon (dark straighter hair, one boob, as they cut one off so they can fire a bow properly) and didn't dress like a fashion trainwreck living as a transvestite prostitute?

Just because you want to appear in comics doesn't mean they should revamp a character that much

Originally posted by Martian_mind
Just because you want to appear in comics doesn't mean they should revamp a character that much

Hey, at least I'm not silicon and a poor excuse for a fighter!

What If Wonder Woman would of stayed in the kitchen....??

What if Deadpool was sane?

What-If Apocalypse could actually beat someone?

Originally posted by StarsNeverFall7
What If Wonder Woman would of stayed in the kitchen....??


controversial

What if wolverine didn't appear on the cover of every other Marvel comic?

Originally posted by willRules
What if wolverine didn't appear on the cover of every other Marvel comic?

Then Jubilee would take his place. . .

what if galactus and hawkgirl got married ?

What if Superman wasn't a dush?

Seriously did anyone see the last episode of Smallville,"Crimson"?
It was Clark effected by red kryptonite making him lose his inhibitions. This was actually a version of him I could actually find interest in and come to really appreciate. A version of Clark thats still Clark just not so damn unbelievably perfect. I could even come to enjoy all that power if it wasn't just like he could handle it just fine without any level of corruption. I don't want to make him evil or even bad really just far more human.

Some thing like one of these,
What if Clark want so damn perfect?
What if Superman was permanently effected by red kryptonite?
What if an alternate version of Kal-El (without the boyscout personality) had to live on Earth with Clark?
What if Clark's personality was that of an average good person?

What if the all the New Warriors survived Stamford?

what if a mod banned another mod ?

What if the Black Panther had joined the Illuminati?

Originally posted by Psyquis52
What if the Black Panther had joined the Illuminati?

The Skrulls would have been rascist.

Originally posted by Martian_mind
The Skrulls would have been rascist.

See...that's funny.

The idea that a race of shape-shifters could be racist just cracks me up.

Originally posted by Psyquis52
What if the Black Panther had joined the Illuminati?

Now that would be a truely interesting read. IMO

What if Kyle had not given up being Ion the first time?

Originally posted by Entity
What if Kyle had not given up being Ion the first time?

The same thing that happens to every omnipotent mortal....He becomes a whiny emo,rearranges the universe so that he doesn't have to cut himself,Jobbs to Superman,Creates a Crisis that somehow involves Infinity,Jobbs to supes some more,Then has a change of heart and saves the universe.

He is then resurrected years later in a god-awful storyline and fails to contribute to the universe in any way shape or form.

What if Super Skrull joined the FF?

Originally posted by Psyquis52
What if Super Skrull joined the FF?

The others could retire.

More or less. Yes.

What if Wonder Man and Warbird had a kid?

What if Peter inherited Tony's billions?
I know I've said this before but I really like this for a story arc.

Peter would be a very happy and secure individual.

Peter secure? Oh come on now, where's the fun in that!

Originally posted by StarsNeverFall7
Peter secure? Oh come on now, where's the fun in that! Exactly.

Originally posted by StarsNeverFall7
Peter secure? Oh come on now, where's the fun in that!

Thats why its a What if and not perment!

I think there should be a What If Peter Parker Came out of the closet?

Just for fun, would be joyous!

Yes. And then they should have one for Dick Ryder (Nova)

Originally posted by Psyquis52
Yes. And then they should have one for Dick Ryder (Nova)

Best.Name.Ever.

What if Gwen had lived and Mary Jane had died?
What if Straczynski hadn't made her a whore later?

What if Bruce Wayne ended up takeing in Peter Parker instead of Dick Grayson?

What if Jason Todd hadn't died?

Okay check this out...

What if Supes became a gay rapist?

I mean could you imagine the fear in the hearts of the other heroes. Who could stop him?

No? I mean i was just saying....I thought it was funny....no?....................................sorry

That was disturbing.


What if Hulk had remained as War?

what if superman left JLA ? u think people would still read the comics ?

Nope. I think they've tried that before.

What if Blob got the gem of cyttorak? Could he even fit in the armor?

Originally posted by littleredhat
What if Bruce Wayne ended up takeing in Peter Parker instead of Dick Grayson?

I have actually imagined this many times!

Originally posted by Jyppe
What if Blob got the gem of cyttorak? Could he even fit in the armor?

Then nobody could stop him from getting to the all you can BBQ Ribs Buffet.

Originally posted by Jyppe
What if Blob got the gem of cyttorak? Could he even fit in the armor?

Would he be able to move himself?

Would the powers cancel each other out?

Would people laugh at him?

What if Cassie was pregnant when Connor died?

Some ideas that I have had:

Captain America picked up Thor's hammer; has captain America's personality and training, combined with Thor's physique and abilities. The two personalities merged would be just awesome.

Galactus gets a hold of the power gem, or alternately finds some way to tap into hyperspace directly the same way that Franklin Richards, the Celestials, can. No more need to eat planets; with not needing to feast, what would he do?

Galactus in an alternate what-if, where the universe has grown cold, stars have died out, and it's time for him to create another universe, or move to the next phase of evolution. Would he evolve beyond the physical form, and become a true abstract? Would he have an epic battle with the Celestials? Would he die in the process? Whatever happens I would be interested in.

Hulk: I would like to see a what-if where either Devil-Hulk or Guilt Hulk breaks free and causes havoc.

Quicksilver: gets the gem of Cytorrak. Now he's got insane speed, momentum, and cannot be stopped. Imagine the sheer destruction he could cause. Or any super-fast moving character for that matter, gaining the gem.

Silver Surfer: Gets the power gem, and feeds Galactus cosmic energy that he created from using the gem.

What if Aunt May had the HOTU?

Originally posted by Kutulu
Some ideas that I have had:

Captain America picked up Thor's hammer; has captain America's personality and training, combined with Thor's physique and abilities. The two personalities merged would be just awesome.

Galactus gets a hold of the power gem, or alternately finds some way to tap into hyperspace directly the same way that Franklin Richards, the Celestials, can. No more need to eat planets; with not needing to feast, what would he do?

Galactus in an alternate what-if, where the universe has grown cold, stars have died out, and it's time for him to create another universe, or move to the next phase of evolution. Would he evolve beyond the physical form, and become a true abstract? Would he have an epic battle with the Celestials? Would he die in the process? Whatever happens I would be interested in.

Hulk: I would like to see a what-if where either Devil-Hulk or Guilt Hulk breaks free and causes havoc.

Quicksilver: gets the gem of Cytorrak. Now he's got insane speed, momentum, and cannot be stopped. Imagine the sheer destruction he could cause. Or any super-fast moving character for that matter, gaining the gem.

Silver Surfer: Gets the power gem, and feeds Galactus cosmic energy that he created from using the gem.


I love all of those ideas, maybe you should send those to Quesada!

What if...

Superman and Lois broke up, divorced and whatnot (sure its not exciting, but i'd like to see it anyway)

We found out Cyclops was being manipulated by the Phoenix ever since Jean was killed by Xorneto, and his reactions and the ensuing consequences...

If Cyclops and Wolverine finally threw down...

If the likes of Surfer, Hulk and the actual Thor were involved in the main plot of Civil War, the X-Men too...

If Batman, rather than Wonder Woman had killed Maxwell Lord...

If Lois took Sue's place in Identity Crisis...

If Bruce and Selina finally got together...

not huge stuff, but stuff i'm curious about nonetheless...

Originally posted by pr1983
What if...

If the likes of Surfer, Hulk and the actual Thor were involved in the main plot of Civil War, the X-Men too...


That would at least make things a bit more exciting (and up the death toll)

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
That would at least make things a bit more exciting (and up the death toll)

yeah... at least dc put all its major players into its big event... i don't see why marvel won't... i know surfer has his own thing, but hulk and thor? seriously...

and i'd love to see the x-men torn apart and fighting each other and other heroes...

Originally posted by Beta Ray Howard
What if Wonder Woman had a sex change.

She'd be far more feminine....

shocking

What if the same chemical thrown into Daredevil's eyes was thrown in Cyclops'?

What is the Punisher TRIED to kill the Marvel Universe?

Sad part is, it probably wouldn't sell well. Damn thing would feature a single pane.

Of Frank getting taken out
....

....

By, well, anyone.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
What if Aunt May had the HOTU? Why would she depower herself?

What if frank castle became the ghost rider.

oh good one...

Originally posted by Jimmy Buggs
What if frank castle became the ghost rider.

Bullets of Hellfire!!

What if our Earth was attacked by the JLA?

what if thanos didnt have so many fanboys

what if apocalypse never started jobbing

what if darkseid never started jobbing

what if the LT actually got off his butt once in a while and tried to help the MU like the spectre does

what if marvel and DC battled but and used every single power to there advantage with out PIS

what if the joker ever went bloodlust on everyone of his enemies

what if bruce waynes parents never had died

what if Lucifer Morningstar wanted to destroy the MU

what if dr strange and the vishanti wanted to destroy the mu

What if MJ caught Peter making out with wolverine

For real... What if Captin America got married?

Originally posted by Mider999
what if dr strange and the vishanti wanted to destroy the mu

What if you posted all the posts in one post.

Originally posted by Kutulu
What if you posted all the posts in one post.

What If Guy222 became Living Tribunal?

Originally posted by guy222
What If Guy222 became Living Tribunal?

scared

Wouldn't too much different from current LT.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Wouldn't too much different from current LT.

It would be closer to Haruhi (think God, but with serious problems in the area of mental stability)

what if soljer married digimark ?

what if drax had the IG

what if magneto stayed evil like in his first incarnations before becomming a baby

what if spawn came to the MU

what if Lobo and wolverine met in a dark ally in actual continuity

what if captian america stoped being a pis machine when would he have died, when thanos tried to punch him the first time, when he fought king thor, when he fought promethius

what if galactus never started jobbing

what if the celestials stayed as beings of eternity and no higher now that there are some who supposidly scare eternity

what if MU stuck to just one multiverse instead of wanting to be all powerful and having its own omniverse which is basically impossible

what if MU and DCU stoped fighting and trying to one up each other and focus on quaility writing with little or no PIS

what if juggernaut knew how to use all his powers

You seem angry . . .

What if LordSidious01 became a Sith Lord name Krayt?

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Wouldn't too much different from current LT.

Cool. I agree

Originally posted by Mider999
what if drax had the IG

what if magneto stayed evil like in his first incarnations before becomming a baby

what if spawn came to the MU

what if Lobo and wolverine met in a dark ally in actual continuity

what if captian america stoped being a pis machine when would he have died, when thanos tried to punch him the first time, when he fought king thor, when he fought promethius

what if galactus never started jobbing

what if the celestials stayed as beings of eternity and no higher now that there are some who supposidly scare eternity

what if MU stuck to just one multiverse instead of wanting to be all powerful and having its own omniverse which is basically impossible

what if MU and DCU stoped fighting and trying to one up each other and focus on quaility writing with little or no PIS

what if juggernaut knew how to use all his powers

Writers write/Editors change

Originally posted by Mider999

what if juggernaut knew how to use all his powers Then he beats Superman and his friends

Originally posted by LORDSIDIOUS01
What if LordSidious01 became a Sith Lord name Krayt?

Sidious, my Lord. Cool sig

What if the Hulk returned to his roots, becoming like the Avatar of Strength? This means he can soundly defeat the likes of Mangog, Doomsday or Juggernaut. There's no point to him otherwise, if there are other characters like him only better. What if he reclaimed his rightful place as The Strongest One There Is?

If everyone was scared of him before Planet Hulk, imagine how they'd be now.

what if marvel went out of bussiness ?

Originally posted by spidey-dude
what if soljer married digimark ?

It would be a beautiful wedding. X would make a GREAT satirical toast, C-Master would be the bouncer, kicking idiots and fanboys out on their ass, and Digi would look so nice in his gown and veil.

Originally posted by Soljer
It would be a beautiful wedding. X would make a GREAT satirical toast, C-Master would be the bouncer, kicking idiots and fanboys out on their ass, and Digi would look so nice in his gown and veil. crying right now. that sounds so romantic. i hope it comes true

I know I wrote this somewhere else but it applies here as well

Scenario:

Weapon X Kidnaps Sue Storm soon after she and her team (Comprised of Ben Grimm, Reed Richards, and her brother: Johnny Storm) land from their mission in which they acquire their powers.

Over the Course of a year they subject her to millions of brainwashing tests, making her completely loyal to Weapon X and only Weapon X.

They train her... fully. More developed than ever before, she has learned how to use her invisibility to the fullest. She can even cloak herself from telepathy as well. She also has the use of her invisibubbles but, more importantly, the willingness to use them lethally.


Now:

The X-men (on some routine mission) completely destroy Weapon X while Sue is away. Everyone of her leaders is gone.

She wants revenge...... on the world.






Who stops her?

Originally posted by Entity
What if Superman wasn't a dush?

Seriously did anyone see the last episode of Smallville,"Crimson"?
It was Clark effected by red kryptonite making him lose his inhibitions. This was actually a version of him I could actually find interest in and come to really appreciate. A version of Clark thats still Clark just not so damn unbelievably perfect. I could even come to enjoy all that power if it wasn't just like he could handle it just fine without any level of corruption. I don't want to make him evil or even bad really just far more human.

Some thing like one of these,
What if Clark want so damn perfect?
What if Superman was permanently effected by red kryptonite?
What if an alternate version of Kal-El (without the boyscout personality) had to live on Earth with Clark?
What if Clark's personality was that of an average good person?

Read "Red Son" where Superman's a communist. I thought it was actually kind of interesting.

Originally posted by Soljer
It would be a beautiful wedding. X would make a GREAT satirical toast, C-Master would be the bouncer, kicking idiots and fanboys out on their ass, and Digi would look so nice in his gown and veil.

Ahhh so your the Butch eh ?

What if Deadpool got an adamantium skeleton?

What if Daredevil got corrective eye surgery?

What if Dr. Strange was burned at the stake for being a witch?

What if Bruce Banner was strait... but the Hulk was gay?

What if Professor X had hair?

What if Bishop had that stupid M scraped off his face?

What if Thor was a girl?

What if somebody got a high dose of common sense and just shot Falcon like they would a pheasant or something? (Seriously... how is he NOT completely worthless?)

What if Squirrell Girl killed the Marvel Universe?

oooh... that reminds me... last one...

What if The Great Lakes Avengers were the last superhero team on earth?

Originally posted by Blind
What if Deadpool got an adamantium skeleton?

He'd be even harder to shut up ....

Originally posted by Blind
What if Daredevil got corrective eye surgery?

For blindness ?

Originally posted by Blind
What if Dr. Strange was burned at the stake for being a witch?

He'd meet batman in hell

Originally posted by Blind
What if Bruce Banner was strait... but the Hulk was gay?

Think Ultimate Hulk...but worse !

Originally posted by Blind
What if Professor X had hair?

He'd have no soul.

http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e300/nosgothphantom8/019.jpg

Originally posted by Blind
What if Bishop had that stupid M scraped off his face?

He wouldn't act like a douche anymore

Originally posted by Blind
What if Thor was a girl?

She'd be a porn star , all guys like overtly muscled blond haired chicks who speak in Shakespearian prose.

Originally posted by Blind
What if somebody got a high dose of common sense and just shot Falcon like they would a pheasant or something? (Seriously... how is he NOT completely worthless?)

Marvel wont kill falcon because he's a godamned mutant (Yup , he's technically a mutie)

Originally posted by Blind
What if Squirrell Girl killed the Marvel Universe?

Two Words.

Squirrel. Hitler.

Originally posted by Blind
oooh... that reminds me... last one...

What if The Great Lakes Avengers were the last superhero team on earth?

The Earth is screwed.

Originally posted by dominic/wolf
What if instead of "The madder gets the stronger he gets" everytime he came incontact with any force everything increased (size, strenght, speed, IQ)