Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

really would have been a fascinating confrontation.
anyone got any thoughts on it?


hmm, or what about a Moriarty and Doom versus Holmes and Mr. Fantastic ...

Joker.

This isn't CBR we only do comicbook battles here.

Holmes would win.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
This isn't CBR we only do comicbook battles here.

Holmes would win. Nah, Holmes is grounded in logic, Joker is the wrench in the gears of logic.

Plus, Joker has thrown down with some of the best martial artists on the planet.
His intelligence is vastly beyond Holmes, although most of the time he just acts crazy.
And. . .he's a crack-shot.

Originally posted by Juntai
Nah, Holmes is grounded in logic, Joker is the wrench in the gears of logic.

Holmes is a ruthless psychopath and Joker is what some English dude?

Sherlock Holmes must have been in a comic strip or book over the years... like Tin Tin.

Originally posted by janus77
Sherlock Holmes must have been in a comic strip or book over the years... like Tin Tin.

He's still best known as a novel character and according to forum rules thats what counts.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Holmes is a ruthless psychopath and Joker is what some English dude? I edited and added.

Originally posted by Juntai
I edited and added.

I see.

Holmes has demonstrated borderline superhuman strength and knowledge of at least one composite martial arts style. (these are not jokes)

I never knew The Joker was a towering intellect. I remember him being a psychopath and quite intelligent but not so remarkably intelligent.
whereas Holmes is quite simply brilliant.

Holmes would take a while to understand The Joker's mentality, quirks, habits and "issues", then probably effectively combat him.

Originally posted by janus77
I never knew The Joker was a towering intellect. I remember him being a psychopath and quite intelligent but not so remarkably intelligent.
whereas Holmes is quite simply brilliant.

Joker is smarter than Batman. He's crazy but brilliant.

It depends on which version of Joker you are talking about. While some versions of him has showed hand-to-hand abilities that should defeat Sherlock Holmes, the more weak and flomboyant versions of Joker is going down easily. All in all, it depends on which Joker we are speaking about

Besides, this should have been closed a long time ago... Sherlock Holmes dont fits in here with crazy geeks like Joker

wtf is this thread?

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
wtf is this thread?

Shit