Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who would win a star destroyer or the enterprise D <(Captain Picard)>

I think Enterprise D would win, but i am holding my vote for now. I think Enterprise would win, because they have shields around their ship an it always seemed to me, that ST ships are more powerful, then SW, except the Death Star. I could be wrong though.

Its a stomp in favor of the Star Destroyer. The Star Destroyer as well, has its very own set of shields which are merely visually, less noticable and its bristling with far more guns due to its more militaristic nature compared to the Enterprise.

Well, let's see:

Type XII phaser arrays are in the low to mid terawatt range and photon torpedoes are in the double - digit megaton range.

Medium turbolasers are in the triple - digit gigaton range, and the Star Destroyer's shields are in the Teraton - Petaton range.

Yep, I'll go with the latter.

The Enterprise. Capt. Picard will find a way to win.

Originally posted by LORDSIDIOUS01
The Enterprise. Capt. Picard will find a way to win.

That doesn't mean anything unless you explain how

seeing how it takes an entire rebelion fleer to topple a star destroyer, and even without thier sheilds activatted, it requires a certain class of weaponry to effect the ship, i doubt a single starfleet ship of any kind stands a chance

Star Destroyer

hahaha

turbo lasers are way about phasers. If the Enterprise could beam a bomb on board they could win.

Originally posted by zozo_yoyo_xoxo
turbo lasers are way about phasers. If the Enterprise could beam a bomb on board they could win.

Except for the fact that they can't beam through shields

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Except for the fact that they can't beam through shields

According to StarDestroyer.net and Spacebattles.com but not every site.

Originally posted by zozo_yoyo_xoxo
According to StarDestroyer.net and Spacebattles.com but not every site.

According to the canon of the show itself.

It's repeatedly stated and shown that they can't beam through shields.

Star Destroyer, easily.

In fact, every weapon, character, or ship from Star Wars just about shits on anything from Star Trek.

(i.e, Wookies would rip the arms right off of a klingon, and a regiment of Clone troops would WtFpWn some Borg.)

Nope, Q could destroy everything from SW, probably the hole universe, with a snap of his finger.

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Nope, Q could destroy everything from SW, probably the hole universe, with a snap of his finger.

Except he's never demonstrated any feats anywhere on that scale ever.

Star Destroyer.

I love watching Trek and Star Wars nerds *****. .

A shadow vessel would tear them both apart.

http://img.search.com/7/71/B5_shadows.jpg

Originally posted by Starhawk
A shadow vessel would tear them both apart.

http://img.search.com/7/71/B5_shadows.jpg

The ship from serenity would own them all

I know practically nothing about Babylon 5, but Firefly/Serenity is one of the weakest scifi universes in terms of combat ability