is luke the chosen one

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



yettoh
i talked to a friend and he said luke is the chosen one but its aniken who destorys the sith at the end just wanted to see what u think

queeq
He is not but he should be.

Alliance
Anakin brougt balance.

Count Makashi
Anakin is the Chosen One, GL confirmed this, it is a canon fact. There can be no debate about it.

queeq
Nope. Anakin is, but Luke should be.

Alliance
Nah, Luke is irrelevant smile

coolmovies
I agree luke should be the chosen one

General G
Luke is terrible...

Anakin is definately the chose one.

Tangible God
Originally posted by General G
Luke is terrible...

Anakin is definately the chose one. Anakin chose one, and it is Luke.

But then Anakin was never that bright, and couldn't remember that his Maker had already decreed that HE was the Chosen One.

So says the Ruler of Bent-Hos.

yettoh
well at least i know I'm right and can bangin my mate

queeq
Luke rules.

General G
Originally posted by Tangible God
Anakin chose one, and it is Luke.

But then Anakin was never that bright, and couldn't remember that his Maker had already decreed that HE was the Chosen One.

So says the Ruler of Bent-Hos.

You knew what I meant. stick out tongue

Originally posted by queeq
Luke rules.

NO!!!

Count Makashi
Originally posted by queeq
Luke rules.

What, doesn't rule, never did, never will.

queeq
He did for 30 years, mate.

MasterAshenVor
They Both are......Here is my reasoning

Anakin and Padme' Concieved Luke Skywalker

Anakin Turned to the dark side and CAUSED UNBALANCE to the force when doing this

Luke Alone brung his father back to the light and defeated the TRUE DARK LORD which was the person inside Anakin his ANGER HIS FEAR AND HATRED so in my "Point of View" Luke destroyed 1 Sith and Anakin Killed the Other


so it was the Combined Action of Luke and Anakin that brung the Balance to the force.

Tangible God
Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
They Both are......Here is my reasoning

Anakin and Padme' Concieved Luke Skywalker

Anakin Turned to the dark side and CAUSED UNBALANCE to the force when doing this

Luke Alone brung his father back to the light and defeated the TRUE DARK LORD which was the person inside Anakin his ANGER HIS FEAR AND HATRED so in my "Point of View" Luke destroyed 1 Sith and Anakin Killed the Other


so it was the Combined Action of Luke and Anakin that brung the Balance to the force. So Luke was only an accomplice. Anakin dealt the killing blow.

Then DE came along and f*cked everything over.

exanda kane
Originally posted by queeq
He did for 30 years, mate.

He certainly did. Luke's a real hero. Anakin is just a waste of space in the script.

MasterAshenVor
No Tangeable God thats not what im saying Luke and Anakin have an EQUAL part in it If it wernt for Luke the sith would have ruled the galaxy


Let me spell it out (No Disrespect twords you)


1: Luke - Destroyed the Monster in Anakin which DESTROYED THE DARK LORD CALLED VADER

2: Anakin Killed Sidious neither was an accomplice to the other...THEY WERE BOTH THE CHOSEN ONES

Superguy
Well... hmmm... let me think... wellll... so George Lucas created Star Wars and basically is the God of Star Wars, his word is FINAL. And he says the Chosen One was...
ANAKIN, FOOLS!

Captain REX
Anakin's the Chosen One. Any inane theories on it are mistaken, according to Georgie himself.

Tangible God
Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
No Tangeable God thats not what im saying Luke and Anakin have an EQUAL part in it If it wernt for Luke the sith would have ruled the galaxy


Let me spell it out (No Disrespect twords you)


1: Luke - Destroyed the Monster in Anakin which DESTROYED THE DARK LORD CALLED VADER

2: Anakin Killed Sidious neither was an accomplice to the other...THEY WERE BOTH THE CHOSEN ONES If I destroy the Good man inside you, then the now Evil You kills someone, am I to blame for the dead guy's demise?

No. I indirectly killed him via killing Good You.

Luke killed Evil Anakin (Vader), thus allowing Good Anakin to kill Palpatine. Luke was a secondary role in the Sith's death. And since the prophecy speaks about the DESTRUCTION of the Sith... not HALF the Sith.

If that were the case, Obi-Wan is also partly Chosen One, since he killed Maul-- half the Sith. Anakin's a Double Chosen One, since he killed Dooku AND Palpatine.

Doesn't work like that, once the Sith are dead, the prophecy is fulfilled, and Anakin killed THE Dark Lord, not Luke.

MasterAshenVor
*DUHHHH* *SCRATCHES HEAD*

queeq
Anakin is the chosen one, but Luke should be. He truly resisted the pull of the Dark Side even whil strongly tempted. Anakin couldn't do that.

Alliance
Anakin destroyed both sides of the force, brought it into balance.

Luke never did that.

General G
Originally posted by queeq
Anakin is the chosen one, but Luke should be. He truly resisted the pull of the Dark Side even whil strongly tempted. Anakin couldn't do that.

But he did use the dark side!! More than once! He used it in ROTJ at the very beginning, when he CHOKED that Gamorrean guard, I didn't think that was very Jedi-like.

Originally posted by Alliance
Anakin destroyed both sides of the force, brought it into balance.

Luke never did that.

Does that really equal him being the chosen one though? Just because he was capable of destroying both sides.

Alliance
I didn't see Luke destroy anyhting.

General G
He choked though.

Alliance
So, just because you can forcechoke doesn't make you the chosen one.

General G
I never said ot did, if that were the case, any Sith or Jedi could have been the chosen one.

Alliance
ahhh, now that is intesting isn't it....

...jedi and sith being interchangible...sounds like a concept I might be using for something.

General G
laughing out loud

Alliance
I'm almost done with chapter 1. woot

General G
Awesome! Can't wait. eek!

How may chapters will there be?

Alliance
I dunno, but I'm doing the whole PT, so quite a few.

Episode One will probably have:

1 - Attack on the cruiser/Druj's office.
2 - Regroup at the barracks/Palpatines office.
3 - Manek vs Maul and the beginning of training.
4 - Preperaoins for battle.
5 - Battle of Iridonia.

So i guess 5 chatpers, maybe 6 I honestly didn't know , I had to count it out.

I also have to have my editor look it over. 13 I'll probably be about 14 book pages when done. Currently its 11 or 5.5 actual pages in Word.

I'm using Darth Maul for the role of QuiGon. That will prove interesting.

General G
Darth Maul for Qui-Gon? Thats weird, can't wait to see how it plays out.

Sounds like it should be good wink

Alliance
laughing out loud I'm trying.

People may be wierded out. I'm NOT Lucas, so this is definately an interpretation of the PT. Its an awkard mix of new EU characters with the traditional ones. Sometimes the cannon characters play the same role as they do in the PT, even say the same things. Othertimes, they play differnet roles. SOme of my characters play cannon characters. Some cannon characters are missing.

There will be lots of room for analysis here.

General G
I will try to keep that in mind when reading it wink

Alliance
Good, I'd actually like to see what people think.

I plan on taking Lucas' analysis of morality to a new level. You will see a side of Maul you've never seen before, which will better explain his role in TPM. At the same time, Palpatine will be the same old bastard he's always been.

My Episode I will be markedly different than any other story because the Jedi are either nonexistnat or antagonists. That will drastically change with Episode II.

queeq
Originally posted by Alliance
Anakin destroyed both sides of the force, brought it into balance.

Luke never did that.

Luke paved the way for Anakin to toss Palpy in the chute. Luke showed him that the Dark Side CAN be resisted and he cleverly distracted Palpy by absorbing lightning so his daddy could chuck him down the bin. wink

So Luke did all the work and Anakin got the glory. Life's not fair.

Count Makashi
But Anakin did it and so fulfilled the Prophecy, hence The Chosen One.

queeq
I agree with you, I just don't think it's fair.

Ushgarak
Well, no-one said being the Chosen One was fair.

Or even made you superior. It just meant you were the one that was going to do the job, realy.

In fact, the only reason we have at all to think that the Chosen One is meant to be powerful is because QGJ identifies him as such from his high count, from which we infer that the prophecy says the Chosen one will be Mr. owerful.

Not that they ever explained what a 'vergence' was.

Anyway, yes. Anakin destroys the Sith, hence bringing the Force back into Balance- i.e. what it is with the Light Side. Luke opens the door, but Anakin is the one who steps through it.

queeq
Yes. Besides, it's Lucas that says Anakin is the Chosen One. That kinda sums it up.

exanda kane
Originally posted by Ushgarak
Luke opens the door, but Anakin is the one who steps through it.

That's a lovely quote right there. roll eyes (sarcastic)

General G
Originally posted by queeq
I agree with you, I just don't think it's fair. \

Does it need to be fair?

Ushgarak summed it up.

MasterAshenVor
Hay GG nice sig!

General G
Thanks! big grin

Alliance
no expression

General G
blink

Alliance
What the f**k?

General G
Shall I assume you don't like it?

Alliance
I find it very difficult to like a sig thatsin low quality.

Change it to a JPG first.

General G
I have it in a JPG, I saved another copy in the GIF format.

Alliance
Onl use gif if you want transparency.

queeq
Originally posted by General G
\

Does it need to be fair?

Ushgarak summed it up.

No, it doesn't have to be fair. But I don't have to like it either.

Personally, I found the whole prophecy thing unnecessary and contrived.

Count Makashi
I like it and this question is for Aliance, how do you make a sig.

queeq
Carefully.

General G
Originally posted by Alliance
Onl use gif if you want transparency.

Alright, thanks, I am just starting, so I won't be going very complex right now erm

Originally posted by Count Makashi
I like it and this question is for Aliance, how do you make a sig.

In the signature forum, they have a place that tells you how.

Alliance
Sig is much better now GG

Originally posted by Count Makashi
I like it and this question is for Aliance, how do you make a sig.

laughing out loud

If you want, I can make you one.

queeq
How kind. Better accept the offer.

General G
Originally posted by Alliance
Sig is much better now GG



laughing out loud

If you want, I can make you one.

Thanks. big grin

You are taking requests again?

Originally posted by queeq
How kind. Better accept the offer.

Definately.

MasterAshenVor
I want a siggy =D

One of Clone Troopers Pwease.


If that if you want to do one =D

General G
I thought you liked the CIS?

queeq
Uh-oh...

Count Makashi
I want a sig to.

queeq
Ask him nicely. Maybe he will make you one.

Count Makashi
Ask who.

queeq
*sigh*

General G
Originally posted by Count Makashi
Ask who.

Wow...

MasterAshenVor
I got a better Idea can you make 1 side Cloens and the other CIS =D to do my many moods =D

yettoh
a sig of pizza

Count Makashi
General G how did you make a sig, i cant make the size to fit the specifics.

MasterAshenVor
2guns afro


gun_bandana raygun

General G
Originally posted by Count Makashi
General G how did you make a sig, i cant make the size to fit the specifics.

What program are you using?

Count Makashi
Irfanwiev.

General G
Never heard of that...

Get photoshop, it works a lot better.

Count Makashi
Can i download it for free somewhere?

General G
Yeah, I know a few who have downloaded it, don't know where to go though erm

Count Makashi
How did you get it?

General G
Bought it, it's about $100 though, so I wouldn't recommend buying it for only making sigs.

Count Makashi
No shit, 100#, thats robbery, why do you use it for?

General G
It is actually worth it when you use it almost every day.

gespstylo
it is anakin who brought balance to the force by destroying the emperor as well as himself, i watched the episode III dvd at home with the comment of the directors and producers. lucas said that it was anakin.

besides, why make 6 movies of THE CHOSEN ONE if he only appears in the last 3 (i dont count luke as a baby)

bye
gesp stylo

Alliance
Originally posted by General G
It is actually worth it when you use it almost every day.

droolio

yettoh
lol waiting for queeq to close this thread

General G
Originally posted by Alliance
droolio

Exactly. 131

Originally posted by yettoh
lol waiting for queeq to close this thread

It is still staying on topic randomly.

Alliance
Since we change the topic to whatever we want.

General G
That's ok though.

Alliance
sly

queeq
Originally posted by General G
Bought it, it's about $100 though, so I wouldn't recommend buying it for only making sigs.

$100??? That'd be Photoshop Elements then, the cheap version. the real one is about $900....

Closing anyway.

queeq
Dead

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.