Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who do you think is the best music producer, or the most under/overrated producer? Also, if a song is good enough, does it really matter how well it's produced, so long as you can hear it?

Butch Vig - Garbage were amazing. You'd find a number of different production styles jammed together all in one song, making for some pretty dynamic sounding stuff...

And the answer to the second question is no

Rick Rubin,maybe.

ethan jones

Terry Brown!

Trevorn Horns stuff from the 80s is pretty nifty
particulary Slave To The Rythmn by Grace Jones and his FGTH 12" mixes.

Rick Rubin, hands down.

rick rubin and steve albini are pretty much legendary (even though albini makes everything sound kind of the same).

I think Nigel Godrich is pretty good

Rick Rubin, just for versatility.

Martin Hannet