Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

In what ways, is the respective writer a better writer than the other writer?

Characterization?
Plot?
Themes?
Foreshadowing?
Heroes?
Villains?
Dialogue?
Prose?


For example, I think Joss Whedon excels at characterization. He can make any character instantly "characterized"with a single spoken sentence from the said character.

Geoff Johns.

Talking from an X-Men perspective, I think Joss wins when it comes to characterisation, prose, foreshadowing and dialogue. Morrison had a total disregard for continuity. He had his pros and cons...For instance equating Emma Frost to Paris Hilton was a big no no for me. That's one of the few things I hated about his run. But then again he brought bitchy Emma back to the X-Men and came up with the mass orgasm thing so I can't really complain. She had her good and bad days in his run. The whole Drug Addict Nazi Magneto thing was a bit extreme IMO. He made the Phoenix/Jean thing even more convoluted. Plus he created characters like Beak and Angel but I can forgive him for that since he also created Cassandra Nova and the Cuckoos. The psychic affair and Gladiator peeing in his pants were high points for me.

Joss' weak points are villians but I really don't have a problem with crappy villains since his characterisation of the X-Men is so good. I like his plot pacing but most people don't so I guess that's another one of his weaknesses.

Overall I'd say Joss is better, well I'm enjoying AXM more then NXM...and the art being an improvement helps as well. Plus Claremont has little say about the core X-Books so that also makes a major difference.

Morrisons New X-Men manifesto was an interesting read.

Oh and Colourful Spandex >>>> Then Black Leather...what were you thinking Grant.

Sadly, Morrison seems incapable of writing a really good Xmen story most of the time. But....his JLA is among the best runs I've ever seen. The whole thing leading up to Mageddon and the various other stories, like Rock of ages, Obsidian Age, those are brilliant.

Morrison is a good writer, but sometimes his stuff gets a bit too artsy for me.

For instance some of his work on New X-Men and Batman is just a bit too melodramatic.

However, All-Star Superman is one of the best comics i've read in a long time so i'll forgive him.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak

Oh and Colourful Spandex >>>> Then Black Leather...what were you thinking Grant.

It was the early 00's, give the guy a break

Besides, thats not nearly as bad as when he tried to make Beast gay, but then ended up retconning it a few issues later because he realized it was one of the worst ideas he's ever had

Joss is consistent.

Morrison isn't.

Joss, pretty easily.

Whedons AX is astonishing,but Morrisons JLA was spectacular.

hard to call.

Not too happy with the way CN took care of the Superguardians, that was just wrong. However, I think Morrison's run on the New x-men was a good one, if only they hadn't killed off Jean once more.

Whedon takes him 7/10

Jean getting killed off was something that should have occured and remained 30 years ago, so I never really had a problem with that. Biggest problem with it IMO was that he left it open for Jeans return...she should become the Gwen Stacey of the X-Men.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Jean getting killed off was something that should have occured and remained 30 years ago, so I never really had a problem with that. Biggest problem with it IMO was that he left it open for Jeans return...she should become the Gwen Stacey of the X-Men.

You mean retcon the story so she's ****ing Mr. Sinister? naughty

Originally posted by CasanoVa
Joss is consistent.

Morrison isn't.

Joss, pretty easily.

You cant really make that kind of comparisson until Joss Wheeldon has done nearly the same amount of work Grant Morisson has.

Originally posted by Rainbow Kiss
You cant really make that kind of comparisson until Joss Wheeldon has done nearly the same amount of work Grant Morisson has.

That's true, Grant has done alot more work than Whedon has. I prefer Whedon though, he manages to get the characterisation of the characters he's writing spot on IMO.

Edit- There are a few exceptions to this though, Grant Morrison has stints where he's absolutely awesome and then others when he's a bit "meh".