Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

This is an old rumour I'm hoping some Superman expert can help with... I heard somewhere once that there was an old Superman story where he tries to punch Luthor, Luthor dodges, and Superman's fist swings right back up and punches Supe's own face. End result Superman knocks himself out.

The explanation was that Superman was so powerful that writers had to come up with more and more ridiculous ways for people like Luthor to be able to challenge him.

I don't know what decade it was supposed to be from. Is there any truth to this story at all?

IF it happened, , it would have been in the early PC days.


Supes back then was ridiculously powerful, to such a degree that the only way to "beat him" was something stupid like you just described.

How the hell could Luthor dodge one of PC Superman's punches?

Originally posted by Grinning Goku
How the hell could Luthor dodge one of PC Superman's punches? Crappy Golden/Silver Age writing... srug

Actually back in the PC days, Luthor had his own "super power", which was basically taking normal technology and turning it into super cosmic science devices. That's why he was so dangerous.

Yes, also I remember thinking a) how the hell did Luthor dodge, and b) if Superman was hitting hard enough to knock himself out, what was he trying to do? Turn Luthor's head into tomato paste?

I really don't know where it came from, I just heard it when I was a kid and it stuck in my mind for its sheer stupidity.

i have another question,

why are Superman's clothes and cape invulnerable??

Originally posted by stickman618
i have another question,

why are Superman's clothes and cape invulnerable??

Because

A: The bio-electic field generated by his body extends past his clothes, protecting them

or

B. They are made of special materials from Krypton

Both explanations have been given in the comics

Its no suprise. Many normal people have defeated Supes, it just shows that he is overrated

Originally posted by stickman618
i have another question,

why are Superman's clothes and cape invulnerable??

they're not always invulnerable.

supes >>>>>>>>>>>> ssj3 goku

lol normal people? nothing normal about luthor or batman as characters s no one in reality will ever be able to leap like batman and be as deadly and nor will anyone be ridiculously smart like luthor... that's why superman "can" be taken down by these guys because they are not normal at all. plus he has beaten guys many times more powerful than himself, the door swing both ways on that one

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Because

A: The bio-electic field generated by his body extends past his clothes, protecting them

or

B. They are made of special materials from Krypton

Both explanations have been given in the comics

he was wrapped in them clothes when he was sent to earth, they have the same density a superman, because they were made on krypton

Originally posted by basilisk
This is an old rumour I'm hoping some Superman expert can help with... I heard somewhere once that there was an old Superman story where he tries to punch Luthor, Luthor dodges, and Superman's fist swings right back up and punches Supe's own face. End result Superman knocks himself out.

The explanation was that Superman was so powerful that writers had to come up with more and more ridiculous ways for people like Luthor to be able to challenge him.

I don't know what decade it was supposed to be from. Is there any truth to this story at all?

Maybe Luthor trap Supes inside a room made out of rubber and POW! It happen...

Originally posted by MattDay
he was wrapped in them clothes when he was sent to earth, they have the same density a superman, because they were made on krypton

his blanket yes... his suit itself, no...

Originally posted by Sarutobi700
Its no suprise. Many normal people have defeated Supes, it just shows that he is overrated

yes, you being tbe resident expert on superman... quit trolling.

supermans TK ability allows him to make other objects invulnerable like his suit or in the Superman movies case a football plaine or what ever he might be using exponential(sp?) force on.

LOL, only thing close to this has been when jimmy knocked Superman, and when Muhamed Ali beat Superman. Both pre-crisis, both ages ago. But nothign to this extent, knokicng HIMSELF out? lol.