Okay if you read my previous thread called Some Idiot... then you know about how he said he has the audio. Well he showed me the link and it seems that it is the audio (I didn't bother to download it). So we are having a debate. He says he will be giving credit to Rowling when he buys two copies of the book. But I say that he is still doing something illegally because he has the audio without purchasing it giving no credit to Jim Dale. So is what he is saying correct or is he incorrect?