Darkfall: Better than WoW and WAR combined

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Bardiel13
http://youtube.com/watch?v=_bYYT6Wg3Gg

Watch yonder trailer and prepare to weep tabasco sauce tears.

SaTsuJiN
tears shall not be wept until they deliver those promises

Bardiel13
Originally posted by SaTsuJiN
tears shall not be wept until they deliver those promises

Beta should be up by August. We shall see then...

Ushgarak
Good Lord... that looks awful.

What a silly idea, that 'completely free' means 'good'.

MadMel
runescape is a perfect example of the contrary...free = rubbish

The Highlord
That game looks amazing no doubt, but too early to say if its good or bad, but from teh clip yeah looks absoulty spectaculer, just imagine the possiblitys -.-

BlaxicanHydra
This game looks truly amazing. I dunno why Ush is hating on it.

SaTsuJiN
the idea is most definitely good... but its all going to depend on how players use them, and if they are actually implemented

DarkC
Just by watching the first minute and a half I can already tell that it's not going to be nearly as good as WoW.

BlaxicanHydra
WoW sucks though.

no expression

Burning thought
i doubt it will beat WoW, not a chance

simply because Blizz have already more subscribers than there are living in quite a good many countries and more or less dominate the market but even if they did pull all this "interesting" things off

its all going to be ruined...a player crafts a beautiful boat and hes spent all week making resources......BUT, an imba player who already has the ultimate ship comes over laughing BANG the ship sinks....a guy who has a masterful spell blows the ultimate ship to pieces and calls a rain of fire on the little dude, owning all their hard work...then that guy gets stabbed in the back by the dude with the ultimate daggers

then somewhere else a beautiful city is being built, after weeks of fun making it.....woosh, in come a whole legion of players on horses, smashing it apart, captured it.....

see what ime saying, its going to get ruined by the players themselves

The Highlord
You need skill to do those things, it wont be like wow where just cause you got some nice weapon you can beat the living crap out of the others, when there is fights you need to think and play right to win. thats what it looked to me.

Burning thought
it wouldnt be that way after a few months, it will obviously be a case of some mean or simply careless players ending up ruining it for so many players

it goes without saying after a few months there will be people far more developed than some beginners and the cruel people with their superior skills/weapons or items will end up ruining it for newbies, for example a guy in a weak little ship or who is preparing to get a better ship which just happens to be a big deal to them could be a time for a bully in the game to simply sail up in his big galleon and blow this other players work into the dust, constant pvp anywhere and everywhere you please is too mean and risky unless they create a sort of penalty for players like this

it will be the same as WoW when it comes down to player time in the game, i mean in WoW a guy with better equipment can lose to a guy with lesser equipment but who is a better player

Ushgarak
Originally posted by The Highlord
You need skill to do those things, it wont be like wow where just cause you got some nice weapon you can beat the living crap out of the others, when there is fights you need to think and play right to win. thats what it looked to me.

Making it 'skill' based is actually a bit of an error for an RP game. The whole point is that you are playing someone who CAN do these things, not that you have to do them yourself. It delivers control of the game to those who are best at action based games which is an awful path to go down. it will indeed simply ruin the experience for many players who will- simply and straightforwardly- be bullied. And I bet you, if this game ever actually comes out, they will dilute this idea of total freedom pretty damn quick when they find that no-one really wants to play in a system like that.

But just look at the damn claims of that video. "PvP or PvE as you like."

LIE. That is actively impossible.

If there are a. no instances and b. complete freedom then that is complete horseshit, simply because PvP will be forced on you whenever anyone else wants to, and that completely removes your chosen style of game.

It's an awful, awful collaboration of ideas, it really is.

SaTsuJiN
Originally posted by Ushgarak
But just look at the damn claims of that video. "PvP or PvE as you like."

LIE. That is actively impossible.

If there are a. no instances and b. complete freedom then that is complete horseshit, simply because PvP will be forced on you whenever anyone else wants to, and that completely removes your chosen style of game.

While that is very true.... the game is being advertised as such. If people play knowing that this will occur then they only brought it on themselves

and on a side note, I rather enjoy real-time combat... stick out tongue

Ushgarak
Nothing wrong with Real Time combat per se, just no good in that sort of game, is all.

And players might not know it will poccur, because of silly claims such as 'PvP or PvE as you like'.

Burning thought
i think ill probably enjoy the game, if you Can actually pull off finding an area, since the game world is supposed ot be enormous, even beyond WoW and any other online game there is, so if you can find your own area, you could probably have some enjoyment

but it is important to note that although one may enjoy the game, it will only last till some moron or mean dude gets some max skills, builds a great fleet/army or some amazing spells and goes out to ruin it for noobs trying to play

Bardiel13
Originally posted by Burning thought
i think ill probably enjoy the game, if you Can actually pull off finding an area, since the game world is supposed ot be enormous, even beyond WoW and any other online game there is, so if you can find your own area, you could probably have some enjoyment

but it is important to note that although one may enjoy the game, it will only last till some moron or mean dude gets some max skills, builds a great fleet/army or some amazing spells and goes out to ruin it for noobs trying to play

Consider this: max skills are hard to come by and I doubt many will reach that level.

SaTsuJiN
Originally posted by Ushgarak
Nothing wrong with Real Time combat per se, just no good in that sort of game, is all.

And players might not know it will poccur, because of silly claims such as 'PvP or PvE as you like'.

lol well technically they're not lying... you can do it as you like.. but its not guaranteed to be hinder-free laughing out loud

that type of gameplay reminds me of lineage 2.. and yes I had a miserable time on that game

killing mobs for 6 hours to gain half a level and then someone comes up and shanks me and I lose 1/4th of what I gained

Burning thought
Originally posted by Bardiel13
Consider this: max skills are hard to come by and I doubt many will reach that level.


thats not the point, were not talking about max skills, were talking about skills much better than another player and that someone gets crushed and all his stuff stolen

you dont need max skills to be someone new to the game

Bardiel13
Originally posted by Burning thought
thats not the point, were not talking about max skills, were talking about skills much better than another player and that someone gets crushed and all his stuff stolen

you dont need max skills to be someone new to the game

There will be "noob areas" that will probably be well guarded to counter this. The idea of high level raiding parties attacking the newbie areas 24/7 is very unlikely.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.