Roldz vs. Scoobless

Rosters:
Roldz - Dane, Warbird, Grail
Scoobs - Sasquatch, Hank Pym, Moonstone??

Battle Location: Antarctica. An invisible impenetrable forcefield will surround the continent in a bubble, extending a mile beneath the surface and approximately 10 miles above the surface. Combatants will start .5 kilometers away from each other, but behind large snow drifts and not in plain sight of one another.

Match Length: Match will end Tuesday the 14th at midnight EST.

Notes: Previous match rulings and post limits apply

Judges: TBA

Have fun.

🙂

Roldz wrote on Aug 8th, 2007 04:39 AM:
PREP (10 MIN)
* Dane (Mind) fully merged w/ Symbiote..

Unlocking Warbirds (Body) potential; BINARY.

Below are scans why this is possible..

Note. Any powers not belonging to physical attribute in the body's pick are only turned off but not remove.

Originally posted by darthgoober

As a basic rule of thumb, your "Body" comes with any abilties that don't require mental effort to control. So if it's automatic(like someone shooting Reed and his body stretching in automatic response) then it's "Body". If it DOES require mental control(like Reed stretching to wrap around an opponent) then it falls under the "Powers" category. Because of this, I've decided to alter a previous ruling I made via PM where I classified Healing Factors as a "Power". Under the new system it WILL fall under the "Body" attribute as long as it doesn't require any mental effort on the characters part.

So w/ the right meshing, its perfectly legal to activate the rest of the body's abilities, providing proof course..

Symbiotes activates Dane's turned off powers..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=activates.jpg

Activates genetic potential..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=latent.jpg

Increases host abilities and unleashes full potential..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=latent3.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=Wetworks_14_13_g-seti.jpg

As stated/seen in Avengers (vol. 3) # 4, New Avengers # 17 and # 18 Warbirds still possess her abilities as Binary but lacks suitable power supply to maintain it in that form.

Notice Carols fiery flame, a sign that her Binary form still there..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=carol36.jpg

Finally transforming into her Binary form when struck and absorb energy from the collective..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=b1.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=b2.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=b3.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=b4.jpg

Dane's link to the Psi/Astral-Plane should be a suitable power supply; the entire Psi/Astral-Plane houses unlimited supply of psionic energy..

Like most high level Psi-talent, Dane can travel/traverse the Astral plane.

http://img144.imageshack.us/my.php?image=outofmind110jv4.jpg

http://img96.imageshack.us/my.php?image=outofmind210jr9.jpg

Fully merging w/ symbiotes allows him accessed to the stores of wisdom/Knowledge from the Symbiotes original mass, This would incl. Grails knowledge and exp. in the manipulation of energy gathered in the orignal mass.

Symbiotes a living stores of knowledge..
Note: "Each galaxy assigned a hub-transference that returns information
from the original mass".

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=Sym.jpg

Grails an energy manipulator, below is a scan of his bio..

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grail_%28WildStorm%29

Now it might seem that it requires a lot of time for this transformation to happen but as you look at the scan below it does not..

Grails transformation from organic to energy brought about by the Symbiote..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=latent2.jpg

So Warbird Full potential + Danes link/access to Astral Plane ( the power source) = Binary w/ Grails skills/knowledge in the manipulation of energy..

* So for the remainder of the prep, Dane farther familiarized himself w/ this newly acquired powerset but mostly concentrate in achieving faster than light speed within the battle fields..

* Amps up strength just before the battle starts..

FIGHT
A scan within the battle field either via Telepathic or E.M spectrum scan should locate Scoobs char..

Right after the scan Arcknight FTL speed across the battle field towards Scoobs char.

Doubt he could master a defense to counter FTLS..

Speed of thought<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<FTLS.

If in someway he manage to turn intangible which i really doubt possible his does not posses FTL reflexes, the resulting effect of FTLS should wreck havok on the battle field, a few of those would tear and destroy the battle field not too mention causing great injury toward scoobs char.

Grail achieving faster light speed velocity.. Binary in her energy form is by far more versatile and powerfull than Grail.. So replicatimg the feat below should be quite possile..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=Wetworks_37_17_g-seti.jpg

http://img185.imageshack.us/my.php?image=radiationtrack337cv6.jpg

Even if he survives this blitzes hed have to fight in the vacuum of space, Antartica be in pieces as a result of going FTLS near land masses.

This fight would be in my home advantage as my char. is build for space travel (Binary).
He can survived indefinetly in space, withstand the vacuum pressure, fires massive energy blast..

Multi-energy blast..

http://i78.photobucket.com/albums/j105/Rewmac/Scans/MsMarvel/__hr_09.jpg

Large blast.

http://i78.photobucket.com/albums/j105/Rewmac/Scans/MsMarvel/x-men1983-02uncannyx-men166-20.jpg

Henry Pym's psyche is quite unstable ( brainwashing, inferiority complex, failures), somethin the likes of a high telepath like Dane could take advantage off..

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=Danes.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=Danes1.jpg

A state of the art sattelite w/ evolving cognitive artificial intellegent that could control w/ relative ease all tech and missile sillo in the UN falls victim to Dane's TP/TK assault.. So an increase in electrical impulse in ur char. brain would'nt protect you from my psi assault.. Electrical impulses from the sat. >>>>>> ur char...

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=wetworks_v1_024_05_rougher.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=wetworks_v1_024_15_rougher.jpg

http://s198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/?action=view¤t=wetworks_v1_024_19_rougher.jpg

Modes of attack.:

- FTLS blitz
- TP/TK assault
- Massive energy blast
- Home field advantage; Space..
- 7th senses, EM spectrum scan, tp locate..

Modes of defense:
-Mist form (Ur massive strength wouldnt do you any good)
-Energy manipulation (Increase shields potency, char. durability, speed and dexterity)

that as far as i can go...

Scoobless wrote on Aug 6th, 2007 02:57 PM:

Don't have much time to do this so I'll just get the main points dealt with first.

My character is physically superior to his in terms of strength, speed, durability, flight & energy projection.

Now before Roldz tries to go the telepathy route, here's something that you should know:

Dane - http://www.internationalhero.co.uk/d/dane.htm

The symbiote has no telepathy of it's own (other than the ability to communicate with other symbiotes) the tp/tk powers came from the host and were merely amplified by the symbiote, as the "Dane" host is not present here he does not have any of those abilities to begin with

For a change I'll start the match off by phasing, shrinking to insect size (while retaining normal sized power levels) and turning my armour white to blend in with the surroundings.

This will make Bigfoot virtually impossible to see in Antarctica and without any TP or high-end scanners there is no way for him to find BF .... which gives me all the time I need to fly around until I spot him.

Once BF finds his target he only needs to fly into him at top speed, which will drive him right into him like a bullet, and start blasting and growing from inside his body ... this will cause immense pain followed quickly by blackout and death.

🙂

If he's gone misty then I only have to wait for him to become solid again as Backlash cannot keep that state up indefinitely as it's a big drain on his energy.

The symbiote has no telepathy of it's own (other than the ability to communicate with other symbiotes) the tp/tk powers came from the host and were merely amplified by the symbiote, as the "Dane" host is not present here he does not have any of those abilities to begin with

http://img148.imageshack.us/my.php?image=t7arcklightgent71le9.jpg

Backlash is the one w/ short white hair and a painted arrow on his face, Dane is the big lug w/ a beard..

So i should be able to use Dane's feat through Backlash gen-factor..

The diff. between the 2s gen-factor abilities is just training and Backlash kherubim heritage farther inhance by the gen-factor..

For a change I'll start the match off by phasing, shrinking to insect size (while retaining normal sized power levels) and turning my armour white to blend in with the surroundings

This will make Bigfoot virtually impossible to see in Antarctica and without any TP or high-end scanners there is no way for him to find BF .... which gives me all the time I need to fly around until I spot him.

Locating u shouldnt be a problem..

I doubt ur intangibilitly works against an energy blast..

U have no defense against TP and TK attacks..

Once BF finds his target he only needs to fly into him at top speed, which will drive him right into him like a bullet, and start blasting and growing from inside his body ... this will cause immense pain followed quickly by blackout and death.

Going FTL speed around the battle field should wreak all sorts of havok on the land masses, splitting it in diff. peaces and expose us in the vacuum of space..

I doubt Moonstone would be able to survive indef. w/ out O2 and the extreme temp. should have great effect not to mention she's not well verse in fighting outside Earth atmosphere..

It would be quite diff. for her to manipulate her body's specific gravity in space, this is required to turn intangible and it would be even harder if shes being attack TP and TK..

My char. however functions nicely and at home in space..

- FTL Speed Blitz
- TP and TK assault
- Energy Blast

Ways my char. can beat Scoobs char..

Well rounded versatility >>>>>>>>>>> Brute strength..

Sorry for the speed of this match, my fault, haven't been online all week.

Post #1: Bigfoot = Moonstone, Sasquatch & Yellowjacket

Originally posted by Roldz
Both Dane and Backlash where members of team 7 and both where present when exposed to the Gen-Factor (psionic energy)..

http://img148.imageshack.us/my.php?image=t7arcklightgent71le9.jpg

Backlash is the one w/ short white hair and a painted arrow on his face, Dane is the big lug w/ a beard..

So i should be able to use Dane's feat through Backlash gen-factor..

No, you can't:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backlash_(Wildstorm)

Backlash has zero telepathic powers .... arguing that the same cause of powers = the same powers is like saying all mutants can do exactly the same thing.

Dane has TP, not the symbiote and not Backlash.

Originally posted by Roldz
Binary can see u through EM spetrum scan. Dane learnt it from absorbing Grails exp. stored through the original mass symbiote accessed via Dane's own symbiote..

Your "Binary" plan has been shot down in every match so far because of the gaping holes in it.

Carol can't access her white star (or whatever it was) for a power source.
You have no evidence that she can absorb psi energy as it's never happened before.
Her powers are turned off completely for these matches ... it's not a case of messing with her body to try and turn them back on, they just don't exist in this tourney.

All of which means Carol's "Binary" powers aren't a factor and she can't use EM related abilities.

Originally posted by Roldz
I doubt ur intangibilitly works against an energy blast..

Actually it does:

Originally posted by Roldz
U have no defense against TP and TK attacks..

You don't have TK or TP so there's really no need to address that point in this match.

Originally posted by Roldz
Ive got a few defense against that puny attack 😛; i see u and im faster than a speeding bullet, u cant really surprise me.. Mist form is a perfect defense against that, i also have energy shields..

I addressed your limited misting ability in my write up ... should be easy enough to find as it's the shortest opening post I've ever made.

You're not really fast at all as you don't even have Warbird's flight speed, let alone Binary's ... all you can do is turn to mist and float around a little, even that isn't too useful as turning to mist drains Backlash's strength and can only be kept up for very short time periods.

Energy shields are easily bypassed via phasing.

Originally posted by Roldz
Going FTL speed around the battle field should wreak all sorts of havok on the land masses, splitting it in diff. peaces and expose us in the vacuum of space..

Except for the entirely indestructible shield around the battlefield you mean?

😛

Not that it matters as floating gas probably can't even hit 30mph.

Originally posted by Roldz
Well rounded versatility >>>>>>>>>>> Brute strength..

Don't mistake my favouring the use of brute force in previous rounds for a lack of versatility.... in this match BF is faster, stronger, practically invisible, virtually impossible to hit, has more powerful energy blasts, is camouflaging himself to match the background and can easily evade your offence/defence by phasing.

All you have is turning to mist (for short periods), limited super strength and little energy whips.

Originally posted by Roldz
[B] - FTL Speed Blitz
- TP and TK assault
- Energy Blast [/B]

- Nope
- Nope and nope
- Where you getting energy blasts from? BL has those whips ... does that symbiote fire energy? .... doesn't really matter as your lack of TP or EM scanning means you'll never see Bigfoot and even if you could you couldn't possibly connect with an ant sized, intangible character flying around at high mach speeds and blending in with the background.

Once again, as soon as you de-mist (and you will have to) you're done, Hulk level impacts at thousands of miles per hour concentrated on an area smaller than a square centimeter means Bigfoot (or in this case "Littlefoot"😉 will be able to fly your solid body easier than a knife passing through butter.

Basically it's like a normal human being shot in the head....

Bang - headshotkmc - you're dead.

Judge list:

- DC
- Smurph
- Bada
- goober
- batdude (I think)

No, you can't:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backlash_(Wildstorm)

Backlash has zero telepathic powers ....

arguing that the same cause of powers = the same powers is like saying all mutants can do exactly the same thing.

Dane has TP, not the symbiote and not Backlash.
:

"When first exposed to the Gen-Factor, Marc had extensive psionic powers including telepathy and telekinesis."

Pre - Kherubim Backlash has psionic powers, it says so in the link u provided 😛 .. Which is the char. im using......

In that i totally agree w/ u but in this instant what this specific Gen-factor gives is Psionic powers (Psionic energy manipulation ie. physical attribute inhancement, TP/TK abilities)..

All Team 7 members possess said so powers..

Grifter
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/rushgrifter.jpg

Lynch
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/rush.jpg

Backlash
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/rushBL.jpg

Backlash (Powers) possess psionic powers, Dane (Mind) has experience/training regarding control over said so powers, this should allow me access to Dane's psionic feat..

Your "Binary" plan has been shot down in every match so far because of the gaping holes in it.

Carol can't access her white star (or whatever it was) for a power source.
You have no evidence that she can absorb psi energy as it's never happened before.
Her powers are turned off completely for these matches ... it's not a case of messing with her body to try and turn them back on, they just don't exist in this tourney.

All of which means Carol's "Binary" powers aren't a factor and she can't use EM related abilities.

Carol may not but the Gen-factor is present within Arcknight; the amalgamated char. which gives him the ability to manipulate psionic energy, its just common sense that the body should be able to control/absorbs such energies..

Carols powers comes from her unique Dna matrix; the Whitehole/Star she's link to just provides her energy source to maintain these powers at max ( the Binary form )..

http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/carol26.jpg

Her powers are turned off but not removed when at time for drafting said so char. ( body ) but as presented w/ right power meshing and so long as its proveded proof, it is legal to utilized this char. full powers..

This strategy(power meshing) was presented to Darthgoober way before this tourny even started and he ruled it OKAY. So deaming it illegal is not fair to my case when actual tourny started. + I dont really see any diff. of what Leonildas did in his prep w/ Deathead II as what im doing w/ Warbird (Utilizing the body for additional power)..

BINARY 👆 .. All her abilities incl. EM manipulation..

Actually it does:

http://img370.imageshack.us/my.php?image=phaseln4.jpg

Anyhow my char. can turn you tangible if need be and then attack..

http://img83.imageshack.us/my.php?image=mattermanipulationdeathnr1.jpg

You don't have TK or TP so there's really no need to address that point in this match.

addressed your limited misting ability in my write up ... should be easy enough to find as it's the shortest opening post I've ever made.

You're not really fast at all as you don't even have Warbird's flight speed, let alone Binary's ... all you can do is turn to mist and float around a little, even that isn't too useful as turning to mist drains Backlash's strength and can only be kept up for very short time periods.

Energy shields are easily bypassed via phasing.

My amalgamated char. does not need to breath unlike Backlash, therefore i can be at mistform as long as i want.

Your plan of attack is not going to worked against my char..

Ohh and Backlash mist form doesn't drain his energy, it just the fact that he needs to breath cant mentain it that long a period..

Cosmic level physical stat. >>>>>>>>>>> Superhuman physical stat.
This would make my char. FASTER, REFLEX..

Except for the entirely indestructible shield around the battlefield you mean?

Not that it matters as floating gas probably can't even hit 30mph.

Antartica w/ extra 10 miles above and .5 KM below is wide and long enough to achieve FTL velocity..

Floating gas at FTL speed would be funny to look at.. 😛

Don't mistake my favouring the use of brute force in previous rounds for a lack of versatility.... in this match BF is faster, stronger, practically invisible, virtually impossible to hit, has more powerful energy blasts, is camouflaging himself to match the background and can easily evade your offence/defence by phasing.

Faster - NO, Cosmic level >>>>>> super human.
Stronger - NOT really but it is really irrelevant in this match
Invisible - NO, i see all EM spectrum not to mention TP scan..
Impossible to hit (Phasing) - See scan above..
More powerfull energy blast - your kidding..
Camouflaging to match background - Aint going to work...

- Nope
- Nope and nope
- Where you getting energy blasts from? BL has those whips ... does that symbiote fire energy? .... doesn't really matter as your lack of TP or EM scanning means you'll never see Bigfoot and even if you could you couldn't possibly connect with an ant sized, intangible character flying around at high mach speeds and blending in with the background.

Once again, as soon as you de-mist (and you will have to) you're done, Hulk level impacts at thousands of miles per hour concentrated on an area smaller than a square centimeter means Bigfoot (or in this case "Littlefoot"😉 will be able to fly your solid body easier than a knife passing through butter.

Basically it's like a normal human being shot in the head....

Bang - - you're dead.

Well you'll be waiting along time for my char. to de-mist..

Give's me ample of time to proceed w/ my plan of attack.
Even if BF survived the first initial assault, hed find the battle location greatly changed.. Atmospheric pressure/gravity and the likes exposed in the vacuum of space. My char. can fight, is at home in the vastness of space, can survived indefinetly and has no need of Oxygen, i couldnt say desame w/ BF..

Too bad this char. is not normal human..

Bang -- surprise -- Your not dead? Me wah?? 😄

Post # - Bigfoot: Moonstone, Sasquatch & Yellowjacket

Originally posted by Roldz
Pre - Kherubim Backlash has psionic powers, it says so in the link u provided 😛 .. Which is the char. im using......

Then start using Backlash's feats if he has any that back up anything you're claiming ... Dane's psi-feats have nothing to do with this match and should not be considered by anyone reading this.

Originally posted by Roldz
My "Binary Plan" was not presented properly for lack of scan/proof in proving my claim

Carol has had access to thousands of power sources and the best geneticists alive, if her powers only needed an energy source they would have be reactivated long ago ... Beast scanned and tested her thoroughly and came to the conclusion that she would never be Binary again.

It's not happening because it can't happen.

Originally posted by Roldz
Anyhow my char. can turn you tangible if need be and then attack..

http://img83.imageshack.us/my.php?image=mattermanipulationdeathnr1.jpg

Um ... to me that looks like a teleportation attack has been blocked ... regardless though, you're direct interfering with my physical state is offensive matter manip ... if it wasn't then I'd have phased you (and every other person I've faced in this tourney) into the ground for an insta-kill.

All BF would have to do is let go during this and you're either dead or crippled.

Originally posted by Roldz
My amalgamated char. does not need to breath unlike Backlash, therefore i can be at mistform as long as i want.

Carol does breath & Binary isn't happening.

___________________

You've based your entire plan on the false assumption that all Carol needs to do is find a big enough battery pack and she's suddenly Binary again.

You're also using the feats of non-competing characters (Dane, Grail) to argue for the abilities of another character (Backlash).

As your Binary plan has failed, you have nothing to fall back on, which means the match will go as I pointed out in my previous post.

Then start using Backlash's feats if he has any that back up anything you're claiming ... Dane's psi-feats have nothing to do with this match and should not be considered by anyone reading this.

Let me explain this again.

Dane, backlash and the rest of team 7 was exposed to this specific gen-factor giving them exact similar abilities, the only diff. in how some of there abilities manifested is the way they trained in the use of this new powers..

I dont see how Dane's couldnt use his own feat using Backlash gen-factor.. It is basically desame power source Dane used to accomplished all his tp/tk feat..

This is what makes power meshing interesting..

Carol has had access to thousands of power sources and the best geneticists alive, if her powers only needed an energy source they would have be reactivated long ago ... Beast scanned and tested her thoroughly and came to the conclusion that she would never be Binary again.

It's not happening because it can't happen.[/B]

That scan u posted happened a long time ago and what matters is the present facts.. Warbird w/ suitable supply of energy source can turn into her Binary form..

http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/Collective.jpg
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa312/RRoldz/Collective1.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/53/Ms._Marvel_Repowered.jpg

Guess Beast was wrong..
Warbird w/ near unlimited power source = Binary..

Originally posted by Scoobless
[b][u]Post # - Bigfoot: Moonstone, Sasquatch & Yellowjacket[/u

Um ... to me that looks like a teleportation attack has been blocked ... regardless though, you're direct interfering with my physical state is offensive matter manip ... if it wasn't then I'd have phased you (and every other person I've faced in this tourney) into the ground for an insta-kill.

All BF would have to do is let go during this and you're either dead or crippled.

Carol does breath & Binary isn't happening.
[/B]

If this was allowed you couldnt really do that move in that scan anyway, my char. can so choose to make both char tangible...

Phase or not, your still suceptible against psionic attacks..

As explained above Binary is happening.. But well see what the judges says..

You've based your entire plan on the false assumption that all Carol needs to do is find a big enough battery pack and she's suddenly Binary again.

You're also using the feats of non-competing characters (Dane, Grail) to argue for the abilities of another character (Backlash).

As your Binary plan has failed, you have nothing to fall back on, which means the match will go as I pointed out in my previous post.

Again power meshing, ive explained it in my write up why this is possible.. To make things short Dane fully merging w/ his symbiote allows him accessed/links to wisdom/knowledge garnered by the symbiote original mass; This includes Grails experience and skills gathered by his symbiote then tranfered to the symbiotes orginal mass.. All symbiotes can communicate to each other that of including The symbiotes ORIGINAL MASS (in unknown location, at the very least thats what the comics says)..
Grail is an Energy manipulator..

Ive provided proof why my Binary plan should work..

But even without it ive still got psionic powers including TP/TK..
- I can find u via telepathic scan
- Your not immune to this form of attack, even in your phase form..
- Waiting for my char. to de-mist is not going to work. My char. does not need to stay in mist form all the time as he knows if theres apporoaching opponent via TP locate/scan..
- Full tp/tk blast is all i need to bring u down..

Your plan spoiled even w/ out Binary form..

Binary or w/ out Binary i still win 😄 ...

Time is up. I will have my vote in tomorrow.

judge list:

Originally posted by Badabing
Time is up. I will have my vote in tomorrow.

Judge list:

- DC
- Smurph
- Bada
- goober
- batdude

Bada's Vote

Good match guys.

Roldz has progressed a lot in his debating and presentation during this tourny. I just wasn't totally convinced of the TK/TP powers would be working the way he presented. He had a good amalgam but, imho, didn't use the full array of powers and focused on the TK/TP which I thought Scoobs presented reasonable doubt.

Scoobless showed evidence to support his character and cast doubt on Roldz's character. I found he can back up his plan while discrediting his opponents plan with scans and other evidence.

My vote is for Scoobs

Smurph's Vote

This match surprised me with how close it was. Roldz played the underdog quite well.

I thought that Roldz had the superior offense, but Scoob did a good job casting doubt upon his chosen methods of attack. Scoob had a solid offense and defense, and I think Roldz' weakest area was his defense... after Scoob seemed to prove that the mist form couldn't be held constantly, or at least held it in very reasonable doubt, his whole plan seemed to hinge on his offense, which, while superior, also seemed to be thrown into doubt.

I think the biggest reason that Scoob gets the edge is that his prep is solid and very hard to disprove, which seems to be key in this tourney.

Vote: Scoob.

Well, I don't think it's much use for me to repeat stuff said here, as I agree with the previous judges. It was indeed close, surprised me. But Scoob's showing was just more solid overall, so I vote for Scoobless.

Good match.