Talisman Vs. Dr.Fate

Talisman (Elizabeth Twoyoungmen)

vs.

Dr.Fate (Hector Hall)

Location:
-Neutral location

Stipulation:
-No prep for Battle #1-2
-Battle #1, Talisman doesn't have Shaman's medicine pouch
-Battle #2, Talisman has Shaman's medicine pouch
-Battle #3, both have prep

Give reasons why an individual wins

Talisman wins across the board because of her ability to absorb/negate magical energy.

Battle #1 is close, but Liz prevails. Call it 6/10

Battle #2 isn't so close; Liz makes wise use of the spells and artifacts within the pouch and puts Fate down for the count. 8/10

Battle #3 is a blowout. With prep time, she should be unstoppable. 10/10

Originally posted by shksprtx
Talisman wins across the board because of her ability to absorb/negate magical energy. There probably won't be much that Fate can do to her, but she can dish out a lot of hurt to him...

Battle #1 is close, but Liz prevails. Call it 6/10

Battle #2 isn't so close; Liz makes wise use of the spells and artifacts within the pouch and puts Fate down for the count. 8/10

Battle #3 is a blowout. With prep time, she should be unstoppable. 10/10

Originally posted by shksprtx
Talisman wins across the board because of her ability to absorb/negate magical energy.

Battle #1 is close, but Liz prevails. Call it 6/10

Battle #2 isn't so close; Liz makes wise use of the spells and artifacts within the pouch and puts Fate down for the count. 8/10

Battle #3 is a blowout. With prep time, she should be unstoppable. 10/10

First battle is closer to a stalemate. Maybe slight edge to her.

Co-sign on the other two. I don't think Hall is the best version of Fate. But even his best would have trouble taking out the pouch or worse, Talisman with prep time.

Well technically Elizibeth isn't the best version of Talisman either, but she is the current version.

I picked Hall as he was until just recently the current Dr.Fate. Kent Nelson [Pre-crisis] was by far the best version.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Well technically Elizibeth isn't the best version of Talisman either, but she is the current version.

I picked Hall as he was until just recently the current Dr.Fate. Kent Nelson [Pre-crisis] was by far the best version.

That's the name I was thinking of. 👆 Fate's helmet is still floating around, so hopefully we'll see a new one before Final Crisis hits.

Mungi, would Kent fare any better?

Kent Nelson is going to be the new Dr.Fate..well it's not the same Kent, most likely his grandson or something

Well he is definetly stronger then Hector, so I would safely assume he would do better. He had some impressive feats, even physical feats matching up with Superman at that time