X-Men Manga

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



srankmissingnin
Take a look at this monstrosity.

http://anime.ign.com/articles/840/840435p1.html
http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=139064

http://animemedia.ign.com/anime/image/article/840/840435/nyaf-x-men-and-wolverine-manga-due-20071209023747614-000.jpg

Akuki
It's gonna be crap. Basically they're cutting corners and expenses by hiring crappy artists. Wolverine Snikt! was good example of doing a blend right with a good author. I mean come on look at the bio of one of the authors "Raina Telgemeier is best known for her work as the writer and illustrator of The Babysitter's Club graphic novels"

King_Mungi
Well...that's...an..interesting take on Wolverine


http://youtube.com/watch?v=yUjJywCyY2A

Creshosk
Hopefully that was just a quick sketch of wolverine and they're going to use GOOD art for it... seriously.. that shit looks like art drawn by 12 year olds...

*goes to check links*

srankmissingnin
I just want to know how you take a manly badass and turn him into some pre-teen girl-boy on his way to an AFI concert?

Akuki
Originally posted by King_Mungi
Well...that's...an..interesting take on Wolverine


http://youtube.com/watch?v=yUjJywCyY2A
Why are you posting a clip of the japanese dub of the english cartoon?

Creshosk
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
I just want to know how you take a manly badass and turn him into some pre-teen girl-boy on his way to an AFI concert? Have 12 year old fangirls draw him as indicated above...

srankmissingnin
Hopefully the artist on the Wolverine manga will be decent, since the X-Men manga and Wolverine manga don't share a continuity. Maybe he won't like girly Shojo Wolverine.
... Stupid Shojo Wolverine. sad

King_Mungi
Originally posted by Akuki
Why are you posting a clip of the japanese dub of the english cartoon?

Just showing X-Men meeting anime, as that intro was just used in Japan

Akuki
Originally posted by Creshosk
Have 12 year old fangirls draw him as indicated above...
it's just wrong. You don't have shoujo artists draw Wolverine it looks as if it was drawn by a stoned Yuu Watase, now if they had some like Takeshi Obata or Kohta Hirano draw it then it would be a dream come true.

srankmissingnin
Originally posted by Akuki
it's just wrong. You don't have shoujo artists draw Wolverine it looks as if it was drawn by a stoned Yuu Watase, now if they had some like Takeshi Obata or Kohta Hirano draw it then it would be a dream come true.

A Takeshi Obata Wolverine would be pretty sweet but I have problem with Kohta Hirano's art. His proportions are all wonky... everyone has super long arms and legs. sad

Akuki
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
A Takeshi Obata Wolverine would be pretty sweet but I have problem with Kohta Hirano's art. His proportions are all wonky... everyone has super long arms and legs. sad
Yes but his drawing of a badass Wolverine fight would just be amazing.

Creshosk
Originally posted by Akuki
Why are you posting a clip of the japanese dub of the english cartoon? That intro wasn't on the English cartoon.
Originally posted by Akuki
it's just wrong. You don't have shoujo artists draw Wolverine it looks as if it was drawn by a stoned Yuu Watase, now if they had some like Takeshi Obata or Kohta Hirano draw it then it would be a dream come true. Yuu Watase would be an improvement over that crap.

But yeah... What would you think of Yutaka Minowa doing it?

srankmissingnin
Originally posted by Akuki
Yes but his drawing of a badass Wolverine fight would just be amazing.

Yeah the fights would be pretty sweet.

Akuki
Originally posted by Creshosk
That intro wasn't on the English cartoon.
Yuu Watase would be an improvement over that crap.

But yeah... What would you think of Yutaka Minowa doing it?
he'd be pretty good, I loved the designs for Vampire hunter D, but I'd be a bit afraid of some of the characters being turned into bishonens.

SaintSmurph
Originally posted by Akuki
he'd be pretty good, I loved the designs for Vampire hunter D, but I'd be a bit afraid of some of the characters being turned into bishonens. That would depend...

... is Gambit in this? ermm

Mr. Slippyfist
Oh for f*cks sake... anime bullshit should never touch comics... ever. no expression

God... I hate you for bringing this to my attention. no expression

Akuki
Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Oh for f*cks sake... anime bullshit should never touch comics... ever. no expression

God... I hate you for bringing this to my attention. no expression
Wolverine Snikt! was actually pretty good.

TricksterPriest
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hirohiko_Araki

I really hope he does some of the characters, or at least 1 book. The man's art style is completely unique in the world of mangaka.

SaintSmurph
I actually think it's a pretty clever way for Marvel to strike out at manga.

Veteran to the comics world doesn't know whether to try out manga... sees horrible, horrible, godawful rendition of Manga X-Men. Decides to buy latest edition of Astonishing X-Men instead, and will never buy manga again. Ever.

Akuki

SaintSmurph
Originally posted by SaintSmurph
I actually think it's a pretty clever way for Marvel to strike out at manga.

Veteran to the comics world doesn't know whether to try out manga... sees horrible, horrible, godawful rendition of Manga X-Men. Decides to buy latest edition of Astonishing X-Men instead, and will never buy manga again. Ever.

Akuki
Originally posted by SaintSmurph
I actually think it's a pretty clever way for Marvel to strike out at manga.

Veteran to the comics world doesn't know whether to try out manga... sees horrible, horrible, godawful rendition of Manga X-Men. Decides to buy latest edition of Astonishing X-Men instead, and will never buy manga again. Ever. laughing How amazingly insidious.

srankmissingnin

TricksterPriest

Akuki
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Ladies and gentlemen, place your bets on the boy on boy action!

Gambit / Wolverine - 5/10 Odds
Gambit / Cyclops - 3/10 Odds
Gambit / Colossus - 1/10 Odds
Gambit / Nightcrawler - 1/10 Odds
I'm placing my bet on a shonen-ai Gambit Cyclops romance. sick

Badabing
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Take a look at this monstrosity.

http://anime.ign.com/articles/840/840435p1.html
http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=139064

http://animemedia.ign.com/anime/image/article/840/840435/nyaf-x-men-and-wolverine-manga-due-20071209023747614-000.jpg That looks like shit

bnone

SaintSmurph
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Ladies and gentlemen, place your bets on the boy on boy action!

Gambit / Wolverine - 5/10 Odds
Gambit / Cyclops - 3/10 Odds
Gambit / Colossus - 1/10 Odds
Gambit / Nightcrawler - 1/10 Odds

Therefore, X-Men: The Manga will be a shojo title, marketed specifically to teenage girls. Editor Tricia Narwani called it "like X-Men meets Fruits Basket."

... ermmnone

TricksterPriest
Originally posted by SaintSmurph
Therefore, X-Men: The Manga will be a shojo title, marketed specifically to teenage girls. Editor Tricia Narwani called it "like X-Men meets Fruits Basket."

... ermmnone

whatdur You're kidding......right? What the f**k?

Akuki
Originally posted by TricksterPriest
whatdur You're kidding......right? What the f**k?
Sadly no. I think it's pretty clear that what Smurph said is correct, there's no way in hell it'll get any real female fans, and it'll just turn off any existing comics fans from looking into good real manga.

SaintSmurph
Originally posted by TricksterPriest
whatdur You're kidding......right? What the f**k? Straight from the links at the beginning.

I seriously think that anybody buying an issue of X-Fruits should have their right to own/spend money revoked.

srankmissingnin
Hopefuly after these fail someone at Marvel loses their job.

Creshosk
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Ladies and gentlemen, place your bets on the boy on boy action!

Gambit / Wolverine - 5/10 Odds
Gambit / Cyclops - 3/10 Odds
Gambit / Colossus - 1/10 Odds
Gambit / Nightcrawler - 1/10 Odds Don't forget the Mary Sue in this instance...

endrict
Is Loeb writing it?

grey fox
A X-men manga written/drawn by Hirano would be GODLY.

The man was a hentai artist for a reason !

But yeah , this X-fruits will most likely feature teh buttsex.

endrict
Originally posted by grey fox
A X-men manga written/drawn by Hirano would be GODLY.

The man was a hentai artist for a reason !

But yeah , this X-fruits will most likely feature teh buttsex.


At least the X-fruitcakes might be written good.

endrict
Originally posted by SaintSmurph
Straight from the links at the beginning.

I seriously think that anybody buying an issue of X-Fruits should have their right to own/spend money revoked.


Why, we bought Ultimates 3 and other Loeb titles, you didn't say anything about that.... confused

-K-M-
Lulz, Beast's next animal look?...a badger

http://blog.newsarama.com/2008/04/22/another-look-at-the-manga-style-wolverine-x-men/#more-7927

llagrok
Originally posted by -K-M-
Lulz, Beast's next animal look?...a badger

http://blog.newsarama.com/2008/04/22/another-look-at-the-manga-style-wolverine-x-men/#more-7927

That's not beast you dumb shit, it's Totoro uhuh

-K-M-
Ummm...what? It says "Hank McCoy/The Beast"

Master-Borg
Originally posted by -K-M-
Lulz, Beast's next animal look?...a badger

http://blog.newsarama.com/2008/04/22/another-look-at-the-manga-style-wolverine-x-men/#more-7927 beast is cute

TricksterPriest
Heh. I actually like the Miyazaki touch with Beast. big grin

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.