Brains vs Brawn

Started by Entity1 pagesPoll

Brains vs Brawn

Brains vs Brawn

My top Brain picks vs top Brawn picks. Who would win?

Brain Team
Batman (Bruce Wayne)
Black Panther (T'Challa)
Mr. Fantastic (Reed Richards)
Mr. Terrific II (Micheal Holt)
Iron Man (Tony Stark)

Brawn Team
Superman
Thor
Captain Marvel
Black Adam
Sentry

And if the brain's can take team one can they take team 2 under the same conditions?

Brawn Team 2
Silver Surfer
Full power Hulk
Superboy Prime
DOS Doomsday
Juggernaut

Brain team gets all their resources.
Can they win with 1 day/week/month of prep?

"Full Power" Hulk would be WWH and that'd basically be Dr. Bruce Banner's IQ + Hulk's power. quite a bit of brains there.
on top of that, Surfer's supposed to be a scientist, he has cosmic awareness and should be quite a genius himself with that.

anyway, no way are the "Brains" team beating Brawn Team 2. Surfer and SBP provide too much versatility and The Hulk and DD provide too much power.

Originally posted by janus77
"Full Power" Hulk would be WWH and that'd basically be Dr. Bruce Banner's IQ + Hulk's power. quite a bit of brains there.
on top of that, Surfer's supposed to be a scientist, he has cosmic awareness and should be quite a genius himself with that.

anyway, no way are the "Brains" team beating Brawn Team 2. Surfer and SBP provide too much versatility and The Hulk and DD provide too much power.

Well I'd actually considered your statement about The Hulk and I almost put mindless but didn't know if he was the strongest or not for certain. But to answer that question I did want him without Banner's mind.

Thanks for the response on the rest thou.
Personally I think with all their combined resources and a week's prep they could take them but that's just me.

Originally posted by Entity
Well I'd actually considered your statement about The Hulk and I almost put mindless but didn't know if he was the strongest or not for certain. But to answer that question I did want him without Banner's mind.

Thanks for the response on the rest thou.
Personally I think with all their combined resources and a week's prep they could take them but that's just me.


fair enough, there's always the Batman with Prep© possibility. just personally imagine that they should have enough brains in the brawns team, to use their superior power effectively. then again, this could always be countered with arguments for 'better prep...'.

wrt mindless hulk, I don't think he is as strong as WWH arc Hulk, though he obviously is more powerful than Prof. or Savage.

if you take away Dr. Banner from the Brawns Team 2, you're still left with Surfer and SBP who can destroy the Brains team with but a thought (well Surfer literally could do that, SBP not so). regardless of whatever prep the team came up with, either Hulk would bust it ('cos he's unimaginably strong - ie, beyond their capacity to measure/comprehend) or Surfer would do some molecular/atomic re-jigging and destroy their machinery, imo (of course) 🙂.

the brain team wins,

silver surfer- black panther uses the same method, silver surfer tries to vaporize him he has his power cosmic removed the power cosmic is then used to drain hulk of gamma energy and sbp of solar energy

doomsday can be transported to another time using the cosmic frogs or some other means of teleportaion

and all of them against juggernaut is a win for them

Batman has a boomtube generating gauntlet, and several androids who have all the powers of the JLA (read that in the UltraMarine arc).

And thats just for starters. Ironman has the reality gem, Mr. Fantastic has the power gem, and thats not even counting in their tech.

I dont even need to mention the rest. I think Brains would win overall.