Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Ok so whose the worse writer in all of comics history? Or more so who's screwed up a character the most of all?

So it can not be necessarily a bad writer just someone thats made the all time worse decisions or contributions to a single character or comic universe over all!

IMO after just reading the final part of One More Day, I gotta say Quesada 100%
My frustration over that is beyond words. Just ask my friend Primetiva who I was with when I heard the rumor and rushed to the comic store where I saw the horrible ugly truth and who saw my terrible reaction. Allot of people stared.

So anyway back to main topic.
Whose your choice and what exactly did they do?

Was it J. Michael Straczynski and Joe Quesada with Sin's Past and One More Day?

Or Maybe Huddlin with the infamous Armbar?

Or something entirely different?

Some of those aren't right...

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Some of those aren't right... Whats not right?

Wil Pfeifer.

According to JMS, he didn't even want his name attached to One More Day. Lulz

And the correct answer is Rob Liefeld.

Originally posted by Val
According to JMS, he didn't even want his name attached to One More Day. Lulz

And the correct answer is Rob Liefeld. I know I read that but still.

Anyway thats why I attach the blame almost entirely to Joe!

btw, also add what they did that pissed you off the most!

Originally posted by Entity
btw, also add what they did that pissed you off the most!
Well in the case of Liefeld, he was born.

Originally posted by Val
According to JMS, he didn't even want his name attached to One More Day. Lulz

And the correct answer is Rob Liefeld.

I thought Liefeld was an artist?

I'd go with Loeb personally. I've never seen anything remotely well written from him.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
I'd go with Loeb personally. I've never seen anything remotely well written from him.

Wow... talk about over exaggeration.

Loeb has done some great work.

I think Loeb is in the same boat as Morrison.

Both done great works before but lately they drop the ball quite too often.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
I thought Liefeld was an artist?

I'd go with Loeb personally. I've never seen anything remotely well written from him.

Ever read Batman: The Long Halloween.

Originally posted by Rorschach
Ever read Batman: The Long Halloween.

Or Hush for that matter.

WTF @ Morrison/Loeb comparison

And yes, Liefeld has written in the past. It's just as shitty as his art.

Originally posted by Rorschach
Ever read Batman: The Long Halloween.

Never heard of it....

Originally posted by batdude123
Or Hush for that matter.
Jim Lee made Hush. The story was mediocre at best.

WTF @ Hush as a mediocre story.

Originally posted by batdude123
Or Hush for that matter.

happy bday ermmhappy

Loeb has done some fantastic works such as almost all his Batman works (most notably IMO Batman: Hush) however I hate what he has done with Ultimates vol 3. He has managed to turn my favourite comic book series of all time into my least favourite (No exaggeration) which is quite a feat of destruction

Originally posted by Val
Jim Lee made Hush. The story was mediocre at best.

crylaugh

Originally posted by Capt Spaulding
happy bday ermmhappy

Thanks... that was two days ago.

Originally posted by batdude123
crylaugh
I'm glad you agree.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
WTF @ Hush as a mediocre story.
I asked first.

Originally posted by Val
I'm glad you agree.

God, you're such a ****.

Originally posted by batdude123
Wow... talk about over exaggeration.

Loeb has done some great work.

Then I obviously haven't read it srug

Originally posted by batdude123
God, you're such a ****.
That's why you love me though. peaches

Anyone who compares Morrison to Loeb deserves to be shot. In the face, repeatedly.

Morrison is wacked, but he's a genius when he gets going. Seven Soldiers and his run on JLA are godly.

God dammit, Trick. Take your medication.

How can you call liefield bad when he created the "merc with a mouth" Deadpool.

I sense this thread was started to honour Jeph Loeb ...

But he has done great work in the past. A decline just started after the Hush storyline, though - and it's become a nosedive.
However, who's gotten more criticism the last few years than Hudlin or Pfeifer?
I know someone's going to say Bendis, but at least he does some experimental narratives that take some thought.

Actually I think this thread was probably made primarily in response to Joseph Quesada's "One More Day" storyline.

Originally posted by Superherovandal
Actually I think this thread was probably made primarily in response to Joseph Quesada's "One More Day" storyline. Now where would you get an idea like that?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
I thought Liefeld was an artist?

I'd go with Loeb personally. I've never seen anything remotely well written from him.


Hush was great.

Greg Pak

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Then I obviously haven't read it srug

http://progressiveboink.com/b/images/rob/liefeld%20002.jpg

Originally posted by Creshosk
http://progressiveboink.com/b/images/rob/liefeld%20002.jpg

Seems to be down at the moment.


Perhaps I'll check out Hush (just to shut you guys up)

Reggie Hudlin

(Oh and I don't know if you noticed but the title of the thread is misspelled)

Originally posted by Superherovandal
Actually I think this thread was probably made primarily in response to Joseph Quesada's "One More Day" storyline.

So this was all JQ's idea, and JMS was forced into doing it?
That's a bit heavy handed for the easy-going JQ. It smacks of Dan Didio.

Originally posted by tkitna
Greg Pak

WWH was bad, Planet Hulk was awesome.

Originally posted by roughrider
So this was all JQ's idea, and JMS was forced into doing it?
That's a bit heavy handed for the easy-going JQ. It smacks of Dan Didio. well JMS didn't even want to put his name on the work. so yeah..all JQ's idea.

After Reading Ultimate Power 9, Loeb is for sure on this shit list.

Originally posted by Kazenji
How can you call liefield bad when he created the "merc with a mouth" Deadpool. He created Deadpool (debatable if I remember) and Badrock, no one else is liked or remembered even know these two are good.

Even then both are copies.

Liefeld also had a hand in creating Domino, Cable, and Supreme. They're all good characters, but they all pretty much sucked at first when Liefeld was writing them, along with Deadpool and Youngblood.

It wasn't until other, better writers took over those characters that they developed into better characters tat we're more familiar with today.

Originally posted by Accel
Liefeld also had a hand in creating Domino, Cable, and Supreme. They're all good characters, but they all pretty much sucked at first when Liefeld was writing them, along with Deadpool and Youngblood.

It wasn't until other, better writers took over those characters that they developed into better characters tat we're more familiar with today.

I liked Supreme. He was pretty cool at first. When he changed I hated it and never read him again after 2 issues.

Any writer of any Wolverine title... Because they all somewhere in the storyline give him some sort of upgrade on something.

Originally posted by Nod
I liked Supreme. He was pretty cool at first. When he changed I hated it and never read him again after 2 issues.

You mean, you hated it when Alan Moore took over and actually did something with that character?

Originally posted by endrict
After Reading Ultimate Power 9, Loeb is for sure on this shit list. he might be crap right now but he wrote Batman: The Long Halloween, and Batman: Hush, and Batman: Dark Victory. So he's far from the worst writer.