Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

i think mark steven jonson is absolutely rediculos! after daredevil, wich was bullshit, with bullshit casting (except jon fav) and a bullshit story, would you let him anywere near ghost rider, it was even worse! what is it with this guy? he cant write! he sure as hell cant cast!(watchin nic cage in that role made me want someone t shoot jonson) and he cannot direct! at all! how has this guy ever gotten a job?

Brett Ratner! the last stand was a joke! there are so many things Wrong with it! when wolverine walks out from behind the sentinel head in the danger room anyone? and take juggernaut! they said the comic book version looked to 'out there' and 'unrealistic' does he even know what juggs looks like? all he had to do was make a tight sleveless top and a couple of arm band kind of things(well just look at a comic) but instead he made him some kind of bondage lookin freak with leather straps and a metal bolt around his neck! it makes him look like a complete tool!
i know it was mathew vaughn that cast him but he was shit! the rubber muscle suit was so fake looking! could they not have gotten a bulky guy who can actually act? the film just sucks, there is no decent character development and the whole cure thing is shit!

ive left out a lot of what was wrong with TLS because there is not enough room and i dont have enough time but you get the point

please tell me why you hated these movies(or why you didn't) and mention any other films/directors you had a problem with!

BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBl
ahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlahBlah
BlahBlahBlahBlah......








X-Men: The Last Stand was good. Vinnie Jones looked very good in the suit, and Juggernaut as a whole had enough of his comic look made to look realistic.

Totally agree with Mark Steven Johnson. He messed up both Daredevil & Ghost Rider.
Rob Bowman certainly made a lousy Elektra movie.
Joel Schumacher still hasn't repented for his Batman movies.
Jim Wynorski made a laughable attempt to capture Alan Moore's greatness with Return Of Swamp Thing; Stephen Norrington failed the same way with The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen.
Pitof on Catwoman - horrible.

how exactly was the last stand a good movie?

Joel Smaucher is saved based on the fact that Batman Forever was decent.

Person who directed Elektra or Catwoman.

Originally posted by scuzz
how exactly was the last stand a good movie?

I just said how it was, and it was the biggest box office hit of the three, though X2 is the best film.
You have an easier time proving your case on a film where it bombed, or disappointed finacially.

actaully I thought the DD story and movie was good, but DD simply not that interesting for a movie

Originally posted by Battlehammer
actaully I thought the DD story and movie was good, but DD simply not that interesting for a movie

A lot of things were right on Daredevil - the casting, the story for the most part, the visual use of his radar, and they stayed true to the costume and made it look good on screen. But it's plagued by bad touches and rushed moments throughout. I wanted an epic score, not a junk collection of hard rock songs. And Johnson didn't seem to know what Matt would really do in some scenes - he wouldn't chase a criminal down into the subway and allow him to be run over. And that iso tank he slept in was silly off the top - show him relaxing with earplugs or something when he gets home. If he's had a really bad day, then show him resorting to that tank to shut out the world. And Los Angeles is an unconvincing stand in for New York.Plus, I didn't want that narration, and where was the teacher who showed Matt how to use his radar? They make it look like he got hit with the chemicals, and became a super-agile fighter because of it, with no training. That's Spider Man, you doofus.

Uwe.

Boll.

But now I'm thinking he never directed a comic book movie. Ah, well... I'm keeping this post here. He's terrible.

I agree with mark steven johnsan but as for X-men 3 i do not agree whats been said from scuzzle butt it was a good film i enjoyed it

If they actually went and made a decent ghost rider film for johnny blaze i would've gone with Matthew McConaughey to play him.

Originally posted by roughrider
I just said how it was, and it was the biggest box office hit of the three, though X2 is the best film.
You have an easier time proving your case on a film where it bombed, or disappointed finacially.

My friend, box office has nothing to do with it. What are you, a studio accountant, only looking at numbers, or a fan, looking for the best (or worst, in this case) comic book film?
X 3 wasn't awful, but it wasn't very good. Weakest of the three.
Considering the budget, actors, director, I thought Hulk was a huge disappointment, tho hardly the worst comic movie or director.
I think it has to go to Shumaker on Batman and Robin. This turd put the Bat-franchise in a near fatal coma, hell... it almost killed ALL comic book movies.
The guy behind Daredevil and Ghost Rider is quite a hack, and the ones who did Superman II and III- pshew!
Still, Shumaker's the one I'd most like to kick in the 'nads. Can you believe studio execs give this anus millions and millions of dollars to make movies? You could probably pick a person at random off the street who would do a better job. My grandmother knows nothing about superheroes or movies, but if she ever watched Batman & Robin, even she would stop at the nipples and homoerotic ass shots, and ask me;
"Oh my! Tell me dear, was the man who directed this film mentally ill?"
Yes Grandma, he was.

Originally posted by Cap'n Happy
My friend, box office has nothing to do with it. What are you, a studio accountant, only looking at numbers, or a fan, looking for the best (or worst, in this case) comic book film?
X 3 wasn't awful, but it wasn't very good. Weakest of the three.


No, but box office is a factor. If a film is as terrible as so many on message boards claim, it wouldn't pull in that much money would it? Especially if it continues to do well after its opening weekend. People can be fooled a little bit by good marketing, but not all the way.
And the reviews for X3 weren't bad - just mixed. It cracked the top 50 for Rotten Tomatoes 50 Best Reviewed Films Of 2006.

Originally posted by roughrider
No, but box office is a factor. If a film is as terrible as so many on message boards claim, it wouldn't pull in that much money would it? Especially if it continues to do well after its opening weekend. People can be fooled a little bit by good marketing, but not all the way.
And the reviews for X3 weren't bad - just mixed. It cracked the top 50 for Rotten Tomatoes 50 Best Reviewed Films Of 2006. Really?
Home Alone is 32nd on the Worldwide ALL TIME list.
Really great movie, then?

Originally posted by Juntai
Really?
Home Alone is 32nd on the Worldwide ALL TIME list.
Really great movie, then?

Look at Titanic - huge box office winner, but can anyone stand to watch it now? For a period of six months ten years ago, people just lost their minds (especially the women, who packed theatres to see Leonardo & Kate go down again & again.) It happens sometimes. Small kids were dragging their families to the first two Home Alone films, but people had more than enough after two of those; 3 & 4 had virtually no audience.

Originally posted by roughrider
X-Men: The Last Stand was good.

Lulz.

Originally posted by batdude123
Lulz.

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y37/Nightmareman95/x3advanceonesheetfinal1dc.jpg

Originally posted by roughrider
Look at Titanic - huge box office winner, but can anyone stand to watch it now? For a period of six months ten years ago, people just lost their minds (especially the women, who packed theatres to see Leonardo & Kate go down again & again.) It happens sometimes. Small kids were dragging their families to the first two Home Alone films, but people had more than enough after two of those; 3 & 4 had virtually no audience. Titanic was actually a good movie however. Not -my- type of movie, but I understand a good movie when I see one.

Originally posted by scuzz
i think mark steven jonson is absolutely rediculos! after daredevil, wich was bullshit, with bullshit casting (except jon fav) and a bullshit story, would you let him anywere near ghost rider, it was even worse! what is it with this guy? he cant write! he sure as hell cant cast!(watchin nic cage in that role made me want someone t shoot jonson) and he cannot direct! at all! how has this guy ever gotten a job?

Brett Ratner! the last stand was a joke! there are so many things Wrong with it! when wolverine walks out from behind the sentinel head in the danger room anyone? and take juggernaut! they said the comic book version looked to 'out there' and 'unrealistic' does he even know what juggs looks like? all he had to do was make a tight sleveless top and a couple of arm band kind of things(well just look at a comic) but instead he made him some kind of bondage lookin freak with leather straps and a metal bolt around his neck! it makes him look like a complete tool!
i know it was mathew vaughn that cast him but he was shit! the rubber muscle suit was so fake looking! could they not have gotten a bulky guy who can actually act? the film just sucks, there is no decent character development and the whole cure thing is shit!

ive left out a lot of what was wrong with TLS because there is not enough room and i dont have enough time but you get the point

please tell me why you hated these movies(or why you didn't) and mention any other films/directors you had a problem with!

Chris Nolan, he did not take care of HL now look...........

Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Chris Nolan, he did not take care of HL now look...........

That's a low blow. Don't hang Ledger's death on Nolan.

Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Chris Nolan, he did not take care of HL now look........... You, sir, are a muppet, and deserve to be rent limb from limb by cannibalistic dwarfs.

Originally posted by Almighty Bauer
You, sir, are a muppet, and deserve to be rent limb from limb by cannibalistic dwarfs.

Amen. Whether this guy thought he was being funny (he failed), or whether he was serious (frightening), the fact remains, he showed his ass. Ledger was a real, living human being. Show some class.

I vote for Tim Robbins and Ang Lee as the worst.

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
I vote for Tim Robbins and Ang Lee as the worst.

What did Tim Robbins direct?
If you're talking about Howard The Duck, he only co-starred in that.

and also with ang lee he tried to turn the hulk into an arthouse film.

Tim Robbins ? maybey he ment Tim Story lol

ok ur all shitters X-3 was ok it wasnt bad like spiderman 3 it was just abit cheesy in some parts nd it wasnt as epic as the others! dd was average but watch the extended edition u mite be happy it just wasnt anything spectacular, ghost rider was half amazin half shittest thing ever but atleast it didnt bore me (all the way through lol), stuff like catwoman is shit........ haters

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Batman Forever was decent.

On what planet?

Originally posted by shksprtx
On what planet?

Dog Doo 8

Brett ratner by far. Daredevil had much potential, The first half hour or so was fairly well done but the elektra storyline slowed the move down and forced it down a most ridiculous path. I blame the screenplay more than the director. Ang li produced a very good movie with Incredible Hulk. The movie was very well done and the characters were all organic and believable. The movie was only bad as a Hulk movie, not a movie

X-men 3 was awful, it was not even a good stand alone movie. X-men 3 was almost as bad as rush hour 3. After seeing rush hour 3 and x-men 3 im convinced brett ratner is the worst driector atm, worse than even Uwi Boll.

I know I'm going to get a lot of hate after I comment on who I think is one the worst directors but here goes....

These are my choices not because of their movies but how bad of a director they are.
From bad to the worst -

5. Brian Singer
4. Mark Steven Johnson
3. Rob Bowman
2. Sam Raimi
1. Joel Schumaucher

i vote uwe boll witht the potential to be the worst comic book movie directer

Originally posted by chickenlover98
i vote uwe boll witht the potential to be the worst comic book movie directer

I agree!!!

List Change -

6. Brian Singer
5. Mark Steven Johnson
4. Rob Bowman
3. Sam Raimi
2. Joel Schumaucher
1. Uwe Boll

What comic book movies did uwe boll do ?

Ang Lee, Tim Story and the guy who directed the Original FF movie from 1994. That shit was nasty.

that honor goes to tim burton making the worst casting choice ever in comicbook history.Pudgy gut,receding hairline,half bald,short runt michael keaton for tall,muscular,handsome,full set of hair bruce wayne.a total insult and joke to batman fans. same applys to jack nicholson.He was totally physically wrong for the role of the joker.horrible casting decisons and a horrible and boring story. so Burton gets my vote.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Joel Smaucher is saved based on the fact that Batman Forever was decent.

Person who directed Elektra or Catwoman.

it was the ONLY decent batman flick of that pathetic Burton/Schumacher Batman franchise.he at least cast someone who LOOKED the part of bruce wayne.He screwed up royally in his casting choise of robin though who was wayyyyyyyyy too old for the role not to mention clooney as bruce wayne was a moroinc choice as well.that guy is an ugly looking dude..the burton/schmacher batman movies need to be burned.the one and only true batman movie is BATMAN BEGINS.