Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

No weapons, just wits and fists, going at it, toe to toe. Who wins and why?

John calls indie a dickhead then punches him in the face.

and then Indy punches him back, durh.....who wins in the end?

Indiana of course..

I agree, I see them on par as fighters, but Indy is tougher.

I honestly think that John McClane would take this one after a very difficult fight.

It'd be close, and only after each gives and takes their share of injuries....

Indy takes this fight, hands down. Indy's a scrapper, and has tangled with a lot a Nazi dickheads. McClane, while I certainly agree that he is a badass, just doesnt have, in my opinion, Indy's presence.

Rmember that fight he had with the huge nazi by the airplane in ROTLA?

Indy.

McClane is the superior driver, and has better luck, but I'd give the H2H to Indy.

I'd say John McClane, he seems stronger and more of a fighter. Besides, his amazing luck must be factored in...it does put Gladstone Gander to shame.

the more I think on it, the more I see Indy winning this fight. They can both take a beating, but Indy seems more capable of taking a hard punch and bouncing back.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Rmember that fight he had with the huge nazi by the airplane in ROTLA?

Indy was losing that fight and would have died if the guy hadn't been killed by the airplane propeller.

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Indy was losing that fight and would have died if the guy hadn't been killed by the airplane propeller. No, as usual, he would have found another way to win.

And dont get me started on luck, as B stated, McClanes luck is mystical.

*shrug*

All I'm saying is that fighting that big Nazi isn't exactly a good showing as Indy lost the actual fist fight.

Indy lived, dead Nazi, Indy won. If it wouldnt have been the propellor, it would have been sumthin else. Look at McClaines fights, he should be dead MANY times over.

I'd say McClane, just because he's so resourceful.

thats his only advantage, that and his amazing luck.

McClane would kick his ass all over the place.

I find it ridiculous how they made McClane from scared guy who gets lucky and kills a bunch of terrorists (die hard 1) to the guy that kicks the shit out of anything that moves and kills anyone he wants. (die hard 4)

I'm still cheerin' for Indy.

so you are saying that McClane doesnt have an amazing amount of luck?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
so you are saying that McClane doesnt have an amazing amount of luck?

Sure he does.

I just never cared for what became of him in the sequels. He went from a scared nobody into an Arnold Schwarzenegger character.

Originally posted by McLovin
Sure he does.

I just never cared for what became of him in the sequels. He went from a scared nobody into an Arnold Schwarzenegger character.

I couldn't have put it better myself. Die Hard is an American classic, while the sequels were repetetive and recycled, in my opinion.

remember when Indy takes on a whole german batallion in the last crusade?

Indy.

Indy hands down.

Indy has the intellect behind the power of his fists. Not that John McClaine isn't intelligent, but I think Indy has him beat.

Indiana Jones is second to only Jeremy Paxton.

Indiana Jones dicked on a bunch of real Nazi's. John McClane done similar to a bunch of German men in suits. Slightly different.

Originally posted by McLovin
McClane would kick his ass all over the place.

I find it ridiculous how they made McClane from scared guy who gets lucky and kills a bunch of terrorists (die hard 1) to the guy that kicks the shit out of anything that moves and kills anyone he wants. (die hard 4)

I'm still cheerin' for Indy.

Oh come on, dude, McClane was a ****ing badass in the first one already.

so was Indy in ROTLA.....point?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
so was Indy in ROTLA.....point? The point is that he said he wasn't.

oops.