Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

both of them are at their strongest incarnation (not odinforce thor though). all out brawl, no holds barred, just start to finish punchfest!
who wins?

Are u allowing RKT

Originally posted by guy222
Are u allowing RKT

He said no Odinforce, so I doubt it, friend.

Superman wins. Stronger, more durability, way faster, and you took away Thor's only leveller - Mjolnir.

Strongest version of Superman being PC Supes, Superman takes it handily.

No odinforce = no contest. Supes wins.

This is Superman's game, Thor is strong, but Supes wrote the book on slugging it out.

Thor would be playing right into Superman's hands.

Supes wins 9/10 in a brawl.

strongest version of Superman is Golden Prime, who is a true God, which means Thor doesn't stand a chance in Asg...hell

Superman wins.

pc supes but no RK Thor? booo

Originally posted by nimbus006
This is Superman's game, Thor is strong, but Supes wrote the book on slugging it out.

Thor would be playing right into Superman's hands.

Supes wins 9/10 in a brawl.

Superman is not a better fighter/brawler than Thor

Originally posted by TheBadguy
pc supes but no RK Thor? booo



Superman is not a better fighter/brawler than Thor Yes Supes is. Thor uses the hammer and relies on it way too much.

Trademark victory for Supes.

Originally posted by Sundipped
Trademark victory for Supes.

With these stipulations, there's absolutely no contest.

Superman wins.

Superman 9/10

Thor - No hammer no win.

Originally posted by Soljer
He said no Odinforce, so I doubt it, friend.

Superman wins. Stronger, more durability, way faster, and you took away Thor's only leveller - Mjolnir.

Thanks buddy

Supes win

Under these circumstances wouldn't Thor be Warrior Madness.

I bet that makes it somewhat closer than people would give Thor credit for.

Originally posted by Newjak
Under these circumstances wouldn't Thor be Warrior Madness.

I bet that makes it somewhat closer than people would give Thor credit for.
Even wm thor would catch a beatdown from pc supes.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor uses the hammer and relies on it way too much.

He even needs it in bed. 131

CORRECTION: THOR HAS HAMMER!!!

just not king thor.

i know this is a very old gambit however lets drag the entire superman is weak against magic argument into the works... let us forget that poor JLA/AVENGERS crossover that probibly isnt even cannon anymore. thors hammer is enchanted thus magic... thus any blows it produces are magical in nature thus supermans weaknessss...

little confused how come you are allowing the most powerfull vertion of superman but not the strong thor seems like this thread is specfically writtern with a biast towards a certain kryptonian

Supes

Originally posted by Sado22
CORRECTION: THOR HAS HAMMER!!!

just not king thor.

Assuming you still make him slug it out, meaning he can use the hammer to bash, but not use any exotic mjolnir powers; it'd still go to Superman.

If Thor starts remembering that he's more than a brick, he could take it.