Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

They have 1 hour of prep.

Both are supplyed with only two pistols, a combat knife, and some grenades.

Who wins?

Croft

lara

Punisher FTW

Castle

Frank

punisher gets her in the sacc and uploads it on youporn= we all win

Lara may take this 7/10. She is in the peak human category. Olympic level athlete, marksman, and a very capable fighter. And like Frank, she has no problem with killing you. She is faster and more agile on a level near the likes of DD. I'm not taking anything away from The Punisher but he got his hands full in this fight. After all Lara does take on and defeat creatures that are beyond Frank

Frank Castle.
tell me when she can go toe-to-toe with the likes of logan and DD and live to talk about (and even embarrass them on a few occassions). don't forget that Frank has humiliated DD. and i can tell you about three times off the top of my head when he could have killed him if he wanted to. in h2h, frank has humiliated DD on one occassion.
Frank for the win. 9/10

When has Frank taken on something like this and overcome?

lets see:

-he's taken on doombots
-he's humiliated spiderman
-he's humiliated daredevil
-he's humiliated wolverine
-he's stalemated captain america on an occassion
-he's taken on doom (can't remember if it was really doom though)
-he's taken on the russian (who KO'd spidey in a few blows)
-he take on tombstone
heck,
-he's stopped the hulk on an occassion

~Sado

Originally posted by Sado22
lets see:

-he's taken on doombots
-he's humiliated spiderman
-he's humiliated daredevil
-he's humiliated wolverine
-he's stalemated captain america on an occassion
-he's taken on doom (can't remember if it was really doom though)
-he's taken on the russian (who KO'd spidey in a few blows)
-he take on tombstone
heck,
-he's stopped the hulk on an occassion

~Sado

That is not answering the question. Most of the people you just mention are not shooting back at him nor are they anything like what I just shown in my post before, Hulk is. But how many times has he face something like that. He would have to take away Lara's guns or get close enough to get the KO, and that's a big if anyway seeing as Lara can take a hit and get right back up. And she can hit as hard as any man.

the time he humilated DD was when DD was going all out. the one holding back was Frank. anyway, keeping that aside, if i start posting pics of frank soaking damage i would you keep this thread going for atleast another 50 pages.

also you're vague. what is this creature? what can it do? and how did Lara beat it? DID she beat it? and if she did beat it did she use weapons? and what kind of weapons?

~Sado

Originally posted by thadarknite84
When has Frank taken on something like this and overcome?

Like in this thread http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=480925&pagenumber=3 where he fights the bug and Rhino and wins each time.

Edit

those pics don't work

punisher wins, shows time and again how durable he is, defeats tiger shark, goes toe to toe with barracuda, fights wolverine and hangs in there

Originally posted by Sado22
the time he humilated DD was when DD was going all out. the one holding back was Frank. anyway, keeping that aside, if i start posting pics of frank soaking damage i would you keep this thread going for atleast another 50 pages.

also you're vague. what is this creature? what can it do? and how did Lara beat it? DID she beat it? and if she did beat it did she use weapons? and what kind of weapons?

~Sado

Sado22, this is not about h2h if you read the rules of thread you can see that it's all about weapons. so bringing up fight with Daredevil and Wolverine don't really help with your argument to much.

i brought up his h2h to emphasize his durability.
as for the pic you showed....well, that's cool, but lara didn't do ONE THING that frank can't do. so yeah, along with the above pics and points raised, he can pretty much take that thing down, imo.

~Sado

I don't think it would happen like that, now that I really think about it. Lara is on his level when it comes to military tactics and espionage. She has infiltrated Area 51 and has gone up against beings with god like power. She is highly intelligent, a superb gymnast, and her accuracy is very high even while performing acrobatic feats. She is fast enough to out maneuver tigers, wolves, and raptors. Her dexterity and equilibrium are also on a peak human level. She doesn't have to be Wolverine, Hulk, or DD to put a bullet in his head. In this fight she is very capable of doing just that. And I would also say that she would be a much harder target to hit than The Punisher. Because of her speed and agility.

fair enough but i disagree. any man who "purposely misses" the likes of spiderman and daredevil (two of the fastest reflexes you'll get in the whole of MU) can take out Lara who is neither mutant nor does she have enhanced senses. and DareDevil>>lara in maneuverability and agility and gymastics. same goes for Bullseye, another peakhuman frank has beaten on beaten on many occassions.

~Sado

I'll give Punisher the win in a h2h or any close range encounter. Close range, Punisher 8/10. But Lara has the advantage in mid to long range. So mid to long range, Lara 7/10.

how does she have an advantage? I'm not pulling your leg or anything but frank has undergone special training in sniping. heck, he's even "sniped back" snipers with an M60

Originally posted by Sado22
how does she have an advantage? I'm not pulling your leg or anything but frank has undergone special training in sniping. heck, he's even "sniped back" snipers with an M60

Originally posted by thadarknite84
They have 1 hour of prep.

Both are supplyed with only two pistols, a combat knife, and some grenades.

Who wins?

Lara can hit very far targets with standard pistols.

was that your reason?

Originally posted by Sado22
was that your reason?

I wanted to put them both on even ground. I can't stand threads that are so uneven. Just think about it. What's the point of a thread if everyone already knows who the winner is. In my opinion, a good thread is one that has everybody second guesting their selfs. The Punisher has a good chance of wining as well as Lara does. So yes that is the reason why I made the rules that way.

i know what you mean, but i was talkign about you saying that lara is better at long range shooting than frank cuz you said this:

frank has some insane accuracy too.

but meh, whatever, you're entitled to an opinion. besides its not like either of us knows for sure who is going to win*

~Sado
*frank pwns here 10/10

Originally posted by Sado22
i know what you mean, but i was talkign about you saying that lara is better at long range shooting than frank cuz you said this:

frank has some insane accuracy too.

but meh, whatever, you're entitled to an opinion. besides its not like either of us knows for sure who is going to win*

~Sado
*frank pwns here 10/10



Nah.... Lara 6/10.

na-ah! baby

Originally posted by Sado22
na-ah! baby