Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Combatants: Captain Hook (Hook) versus Captain Barbossa (At Worlds End). Both are only armed with their swords, though Hook can use his hook as a weapon.

Location: The Black Pearl.


http://img174.imageshack.us/img174/8914/hook3ef1.jpg

vs

http://img174.imageshack.us/img174/8390/piratesyah3oz3.jpg

Barbossa.

Barbossa. He was probably the best swordfighter in the series.

Barbossa, he fights supernatural creatures, Pirates and members of the British military. Captain Hook fights little boys...,and loses.

Captain Ron would destroy both of them.

http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Mansion/6468/ron2.jpg

Originally posted by Robtard
Captain Ron would destroy both of them.

http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Mansion/6468/ron2.jpg
crylaugh

I pick Hook in this one.

lolcaptainmorgan

Barbossa. Hook is too foppish and children's-book material.

Barbossa! He'd have shot little Peter Pan ages ago. He's also more in control of his emotions than Hook, which implies his swordsmanship wouldn't get sloppy.

Originally posted by ragesRemorse
members of the British military I don't know why, but this was funny as hell. haermm

Barbossa, though I would not call him the best swordfighter in the series, I would give Davy Jones that title.

If you watch Dead Man's Chest commentary, well, listen to it, they say that Will is the best swordsman in the series, with Barbossa a close second.

Originally posted by willofthewisp
If you watch Dead Man's Chest commentary, well, listen to it, they say that Will is the best swordsman in the series, with Barbossa a close second. Dead Man's Chest was before At World's End, the only movie Jones fought in.

And that holds no weight as Jones, well he b!tched Will in a fight.

Barbossa

Barbossa, even if living he is crueller. more experienced and freak's awesome

Originally posted by celestialdemon
Barbossa. He was probably the best swordfighter in the series.

Nope Will was the best. Barbossa still wins though.

Originally posted by Surtur
Nope Will was the best. Barbossa still wins though.

I would think the best would be barbossa or jones since jones was able to stalemate jack and didn't he beat Elizabeth and kill a lot of people with his own sword. Also barbossa seemed like a skilled person, fighting jack and forcing him to run even when he was immortal, defeat multiple member of the Davy Jones crew.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
I would think the best would be barbossa or jones since jones was able to stalemate jack and didn't he beat Elizabeth and kill a lot of people with his own sword. Also barbossa seemed like a skilled person, fighting jack and forcing him to run even when he was immortal, defeat multiple member of the Davy Jones crew.

Will is the best, Barbossa is second and Jack is third

Originally posted by juggerman
Will is the best, Barbossa is second and Jack is third

i can agree with that.

Who the f*** voted for Hook?

Let's not forget Hook was having fits fighting Rufio and wouldn't face Robin on his own at first.

Barbossa has slaughtered dozens of people by the last movie, and tons more before it. And he fought the best swordsmen in the series multiple time and did extremely well against all of them, even after losing a leg.