Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

These two are both great fighters. Who would win?

Personally, I'd go with Aragorn. It can be argued either way but I based my decision on:
Tolkien states that Legolas accomplished least out of the Fellowship.

Aragorn, whilst not an Elf was trained by them and lived a hard and demanding life as a Ranger.

Aragorn had served both Gondor and Rohan under the alias of Thorongil, before Theoden and Denethor had become rulers. Meaning he probably had extensive combat experience.

But of course, Legolas was skilled certainly.

Yeah, I agree. Legolas is definitely skilled, but Aragorn is probably a better fighter than him.

Aragorn in a curb-stomp.

As I stated earlier, Tolkien even said that Legolas accomplished the least of all the Fellowship. He was good, but Gimli beat him in the Battle of Helm's Deep. Aragorn would annihilate him. The only reason people think Legolas is the best is due to the over-hyped movie version.

Legoals killed a fell beast with one shot in the books, that certainly isn't an easy task. Unless you want to dismiss that as luck, the Elf has some serious skills.

Whilst his Elven eyesight and archery skills cannot be questioned, Legolas did possess one of the bows of the Galadhrim.

It is unlikley he could have made such a shot with his Mirkwood bow. Although, I do think that if given the range Legolas would be formidable against Aragorn. Up close, I don't think he's as good.

Up close Aragon takes this. Legolas would more then likely take it from far off due to his elf eyes.