Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

How many elders of the universe would it take to beat darkseid?
and which ones can beat him on there own
For this battle the elders arent immortal

Darkseid wins. All the elders combined aren't powerful enough to beat him.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Darkseid wins. All the elders combined aren't powerful enough to beat him.
How do you figure when the Elders include guys like Grandmaster, Ego, and the Collector(his true form's actually pretty powerful)?

The runner, collector and grand master

Um, DS leads a whole pantheon of New gods. He can beat them all. I'm Sure It would take the combined collective might of the Elders and some prep from the Grandmaster to win.

The Runner is enough to kick the crap out of Darkseid.

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
The Runner is enough to kick the crap out of Darkseid.

Not. DS mind rapes the runner, or OE's him into non existance. or simply depowers him. Remeber, DS rarely ever like to go fist to fist. And he has enough power to simply wave his hand and pwn the runner.

Or, Runner is just to fast fo Darkseid, and humiliate him, before spank him like a little girl.

Runner is like Flash, + infinite more power.
Hell, he overpowered Friggin Silver Surfer!

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
Or, Runner is just to fast fo Darkseid, and humiliate him, before spank him like a little girl.

Runner is like Flash, + infinite more power.
Hell, he overpowered Friggin Silver Surfer!

Is that what you think? let me show you something right fast.

http://i267.photobucket.com/albums/ii315/darkseidres2/NewGodsv310-19.jpg

Now what was that about the runner being too fast for DS?

Seriously, what does that prove?

Originally posted by Mr Master
Seriously, what does that prove?
Read the damned thread.

Originally posted by fangirl101

Read the damned thread.
I did, as I always do before posting to avoid circles.

That scan lets us know he's fast,
but how does that prove he's faster or = to the Runner?

How does that prove Runner can't dodge and/or outrun DS' omega effect?

How does that prove he can "de-power" the Runner?

Hoe does that prove he can wave his hand and pwn the Runner?

If it helps, he was traveling to the Source wall which resides at the end of the Dcu.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Seriously, what does that prove?

I was wonderin d same thing.

Because it's said that he move at "unthinkable speed"?

Let me put this on an another way: Surfer goes faster than light, he travel at Warp Speed. And Runner outrace him. And without his gem.
He's that damn fast. Darkseid would have his head in his own ass before he knows what touch him.

Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom

If it helps, he was traveling to the Source wall which resides at the end of the Dcu.
That's better, thanx, at-least it gives us some perspective.

Question, is it stated how long it took them to get there?

Silver Surfer has some incredible speed feats to the ends of the universe,
even across universeS I learned recently,
and writers have even clocked some of those exhibitions of speed.

We know Runner is much faster than SS.

I'll see if I can find specific gauges concerning the Runner's speed,
I have all his appearances, let me check.

Still no time frame is given. And we really cant dtermine what unthinkable speed is

Originally posted by Mr Master
That's better, thanx, at-least it gives us some perspective.

Question, is it stated how long it took them to get there?

Silver Surfer has some incredible speed feats to the ends of the universe,
even across universeS I learned recently,
and writers have even clocked some of those exhibitions of speed.

We know Runner is much faster than SS.

I'll see if I can find specific gauges concerning the Runner's speed,
I have all his appearances, let me check. I don't know how long it took them, but I'm assuming it wasn't that "long"....

Anyways, can the Runner manipulate time?

Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom

I don't know how long it took them, but I'm assuming it wasn't that "long"....
Unfortunate, it's anyone's guess then.
Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom

Anyways, can the Runner manipulate time?
Not to my knowledge.

You know what, I just found the second part of that scan and from the looks of it, it seems like he arrived there instantly.

http://i267.photobucket.com/albums/ii315/darkseidres2/NewGodsv310-20.jpg

Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom

You know what,
I just found the second part of that scan and from the looks of it,
it seems like he arrived there instantly.
I guess it's plausible, but it's still not concrete,
at-least not based on that scan alone.

Here I got Silver Surfer reaching a spot located a thousand UniverseS away

in 3 pages:

http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462765_SS1.jpg http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462766_SS2.jpg http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462767_SS3.jpg http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462768_SS4.jpg

Doesn't say how fast he was going,
but notice he even had a pit stop at Zenn-La,
had a quick conversation with his love,
and proceeded with his journey,
and still got there in 3 pages,
one of which focuses back on Earth,
so it was really 2 pages.
Not to mention he managed to attract the Decimators
and get them to do what he went there for.

All in 3 pages.

That's ridiculous, and the Runner is far faster.

Originally posted by Mr Master
I guess it's plausible, but it's still not concrete,
at-least not based on that scan alone.

Here I got Silver Surfer reaching a spot located a thousand UniverseS away

in 3 pages:

http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462765_SS1.jpg http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462766_SS2.jpg http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462767_SS3.jpg http://s2d2.turboimagehost.com/t/462768_SS4.jpg

Doesn't say how fast he was going,
but notice he even had a pit stop at Zenn-La,
had a quick conversation with his love,
and proceeded with his journey,
and still got there in 3 pages,
one of which focuses back on Earth,
so it was really 2 pages.
Not to mention he managed to attract the Decimators
and get them to do what he went there for.

All in 3 pages.

That's ridiculous, and the Runner is far faster.

And they say pre-crisis Superman was ridiculous.

Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom

And they say pre-crisis Superman was ridiculous.


I have an issue where pre-crisis Supes travelled across the entire infinite Multiverse,
he literally broke out of the Multiverse,
and nearly crashed into the gates of heaven itself,
the Spectre was sent by the Presence to stop him before he did so.

Madness, but I love it.

Yet, funnier than that,
is the fact that Supes was trying to catch up to, (get this)
an un-conscious Supergirl.
(oh yea, you read that right, her un-conscious body was zooming uberdiculous style)

Originally posted by Mr Master


I have an issue where pre-crisis Supes travelled across the entire infinite Multiverse,
he literally broke out of the Multiverse,
and nearly crashed into the gates of heaven itself,
the Spectre was sent by the Presence to stop him before he did so.

Madness, but I love it.

Yet, funnier than that,
is the fact that Supes was trying to catch up to, (get this)
an un-conscious Supergirl.
(oh yea, you read that right, her un-conscious body was zooming uberdiculous style) Gotta love the wackiness of the pc era.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Doesn't say how fast he was going,
but notice he even had a pit stop at Zenn-La,
had a quick conversation with his love,
and proceeded with his journey,
and still got there in 3 pages,
one of which focuses back on Earth,
so it was really 2 pages.
Not to mention he managed to attract the Decimators
and get them to do what he went there for.

All in 3 pages.

That's ridiculous, and the Runner is far faster.

You know that's an impressive speed feat in and of itself when you take into consideration the fact that Zenn-La's system is 6,000 lightyears from Earth(Reed talks about it in the last panel)...
http://img518.imageshack.us/img518/329/silversurferannual0236ln4.th.jpg

Originally posted by darthgoober

You know that's an impressive speed feat in and of itself when you take into consideration the fact that Zenn-La's system is 6,000 lightyears from Earth(Reed talks about it in the last panel)...
Holy!

Originally posted by Mr Master
Holy!
And just think, that part of the trip only took 3 panels(and that's including the panels where Surfer leaves Earth's atmosphere and the one where he arrives on Zenn-)La .

I wonder what Ego can do against Apokolips if the other elders preoccupy DS for a bit.

Originally posted by darthgoober

And just think, that part of the trip only took 3 panels(and that's including the panels where Surfer leaves Earth's atmosphere and the one where he arrives on Zenn-)La .


Now just think that Runner is far faster. fear

Originally posted by Mr Master


Now just think that Runner is far faster. fear
IDK Mr. M... I mean I'll readily acknowledge that the Runner was the faster of the two during their fight but then again that fight was a LONG time ago and Surfer's showings of power/speed are far more impressive now. Back in those days Surfer wasn't even sure he could survive a black hole.

I'm not saying that Surfer's the faster of the two now or anything like that though, just that it seems like a stretch to use the fight as concrete evidence of Runner being far faster than Surfer's current depiction.

Originally posted by darthgoober

IDK Mr. M... I mean I'll readily acknowledge that the Runner was the faster of the two during their fight but then again that fight was a LONG time ago and Surfer's showings of power/speed are far more impressive now. Back in those days Surfer wasn't even sure he could survive a black hole.

I'm not saying that Surfer's the faster of the two now or anything like that though, just that it seems like a stretch to use the fight as concrete evidence of Runner being far faster of Surfer's current depiction.
Imo, Surfer may have surpassed Runner in power after his several upgrades,
but in speed, that's what the characters was designed for,
only Makkari is faster in Marvel historically speaking.
Now grant it, after the famous race across the cosmos,
we haven't seen much of the Runner,
he made a cameo appearance in Annihilation, but didn't do anything.

So who knows.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Imo, Surfer may have surpassed Runner in power after his several upgrades,
but in speed, that's what the characters was designed for,
only Makkari is faster in Marvel historically speaking.
Now grant it, after the famous race across the cosmos,
we haven't seen much of the Runner,
he made a cameo appearance in Annihilation, but didn't do anything.

So who knows.
I agree. Like I said I'm not saying that Surfer's actually faster now(for that matter I'm not even saying that Surfer's "as fast", just that Runner has too few appearances to positively determine how he and Surfer match up nowadays because Surfer's come a long way since they butted heads.

But even back in the day Surfer was ridiculously fast so the Runner trumping him in the speed department back then is still impressive as Hell. And aside from the Surfer fight the Runner DID take Moondragon on something of a "cosmic stroll" that spanned multiple galaxies in just two pages...
http://img98.imageshack.us/my.php?image=defenders14316kx4.jpg
http://img98.imageshack.us/my.php?image=defenders14317fz7.jpg

Originally posted by darthgoober

I agree. Like I said I'm not saying that Surfer's actually faster now(for that matter I'm not even saying that Surfer's "as fast", just that Runner has too few appearances to positively determine how he and Surfer match up nowadays because Surfer's come a long way since they butted heads.

But even back in the day Surfer was ridiculously fast so the Runner trumping him in the speed department back then is still impressive as Hell.

Originally posted by darthgoober

And aside from the Surfer fight the Runner DID take Moondragon on something of a "cosmic stroll" that spanned multiple galaxies...
http://img98.imageshack.us/my.php?image=defenders14316kx4.jpg
Yea, I remember that issue,
he stood on a blazing Sun with MD,
and she wasn't affected due to simply being with him.

Nice.

Even though The Runner's much faster than Darkseid, he's been hit by those who are slower than him before. Aside from the fact that The Silver Surfer managed to land an attack and grapple with him, a few issues later Mantis managed to trip The Runner over while she and Surfer fought the Elders. Also, Darkseid could use an area effect attack, like what he did in Legion: Foundations, or occupy him with something like Shadow Demons before using the OE.

It's kind of hard to say who'd win, though, since The Runner's only major displays of power are his win over Surfer and sucker-blitzing Thanos, while the only limitations we've seen of him are losing a race to Makkarri, being tripped by Mantis, and being defeated by Infinity Gems. Add to this Darkseid's wild inconsistency since 2000, and the fight is pretty much at the whim of whoever's writing it.


I'd give "average" (quotations as his power level changes from one appearance to the next these days) Darkseid a small edge against The Stranger, a sizable advantage against Champion, and probably a significant disadvantage against Grandmaster (although he's also hard to define).

This is notwithstanding Final Crisis ... Apparently Darkseid in his true form is the most powerful of about 10 different beings all in Galactus' ballpark. The first two issues of FC are confusing as hell, but that's how most of Morrison's stories start off. Hopefully it'll be good.

I don't think SS managing to tag the runner speaks against the runner, but more for SS, by indicating that SS does indeed have certain combat reflexes. Of course, there is also the "flash" syndrome, in which characters which should not be getting hit actually do get hit. It still does not excuse getting tripped by Mantis, even though martial artists seem to benefit from slight PIS against speedsters. She has had good showings against Cap and Thor, so it isn't so bad.

As for his showings, runner performed pretty well in all his combat showings. I don't think that either the mantis nor makkarri race constitute combat showings, which basically leaves a gem-wielding Thanos and SS. That alone sets a pretty high bar for his average level. Add that to the fact that DS will not be performing optimally due to his likeability, and I reckon the runner could do very well against him. Up in the air, and at the mercy of the writers, but I would expect a 5/10.

Originally posted by darthgoober
How do you figure when the Elders include guys like Grandmaster, Ego, and the Collector(his true form's actually pretty powerful)?

Don't forget Contemplator. Im not too sure about DS but beings such as Grandmaster and Contemplator on their own would be tough enough. Hes certainly not beating them all.

Originally posted by Ouallada
I don't think SS managing to tag the runner speaks against the runner, but more for SS, by indicating that SS does indeed have certain combat reflexes. Of course, there is also the "flash" syndrome, in which characters which should not be getting hit actually do get hit. It still does not excuse getting tripped by Mantis, even though martial artists seem to benefit from slight PIS against speedsters. She has had good showings against Cap and Thor, so it isn't so bad.

As for his showings, runner performed pretty well in all his combat showings. I don't think that either the mantis nor makkarri race constitute combat showings, which basically leaves a gem-wielding Thanos and SS. That alone sets a pretty high bar for his average level. Add that to the fact that DS will not be performing optimally due to his likeability, and I reckon the runner could do very well against him. Up in the air, and at the mercy of the writers, but I would expect a 5/10.


Surfer's almost never been portrayed as having comat-related reflexes beyond Spider-Man level to my knowledge. He's done things implying he should have that sort of speed outside of battle, but in battle it rarely if ever is shown. And Thor is definitely not faster than Captain America in the minds of most writers, so Mantis hitting Thor doesn't really mean anything. The bottom line is that a few issues after beating Surfer -- The Runner's only definitive combat showing -- he was tripped by Mantis. That implies that Darkseid would indeed be able to land attacks on him as per the writer of the Surfer encounter.

Talking about "averages" when it comes to The Runner is pretty irrelevent. We really have no idea where he stands in the MU hiearchy, aside from being above Surfer and likely below Odin. The Runner's power appears to be somewhere in the same ballpark as Darkseid's, but it's impossible to say where, exactly. His limits haven't been defined.

my squad of elders;

-ego (pure power)
-grandmaster (master strategist/power)
-runner (speed/durability/power)
-caregiver (team healer)

----------------------------

the runner can assault ds quite effectively while ego manufactures 5 ego primes to finish ds.

grandmaster can just chill and coordinate his "siblings" next attacks.

the caregiver can heal anything really fast, even abstracts, so if anyone on the team needs it she can do it instantaneously.

you cantheal the omega effect, it erases you from existence

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan
Surfer's almost never been portrayed as having comat-related reflexes beyond Spider-Man level to my knowledge. He's done things implying he should have that sort of speed outside of battle, but in battle it rarely if ever is shown. And Thor is definitely not faster than Captain America in the minds of most writers, so Mantis hitting Thor doesn't really mean anything. The bottom line is that a few issues after beating Surfer -- The Runner's only definitive combat showing -- he was tripped by Mantis. That implies that Darkseid would indeed be able to land attacks on him as per the writer of the Surfer encounter.

Talking about "averages" when it comes to The Runner is pretty irrelevent. We really have no idea where he stands in the MU hiearchy, aside from being above Surfer and likely below Odin. The Runner's power appears to be somewhere in the same ballpark as Darkseid's, but it's impossible to say where, exactly. His limits haven't been defined.

Well, SS was shown to blitz Nova in the latter's own series. To be honest, if wonder woman is assumed to have near light speed reflexes by being able to block lasers with her bracelets, surfer should get the benefit of that doubt as well, using the same coin. Dodging asteroids while traveling at multiples of light speed is very arguably a better relative feat than blocking lasers, where relative is used because neither are combat feats per se, but rather how the two characters react with relation to situations. I'm not going to argue about whether or not Thor fights faster than Cap, even though he does have some combat speed feats, but am rather going to say that the point is that Mantis isn't exactly some no-name can, and that if runner's lowest feat is being tripped, it bodes well for him.

I'm not doubting that DS will in all probability be able to hit runner, the same way I don't doubt that Flash can be tagged as well. The only problem is consistency, and whether or not the severity can put down a being of runner's physical stats. The surfer fight, of course, should have little bearing on whether or not DS can hit runner consistently, as he is undoubtedly quicker than DS -- Tyson being able to knock someone out has no bearing on whether or not the man on the street can. The fact that SS only came close to touching the runner after the latter saw fit to engage in close quarter combat and a test of strength illustrates the context even better.

It is not irrelevant. It is simply inconclusive. That works the same way as it does for Scathan and Protege. If the former's only appearance has him at LT level, that is his established level, simply that the lack of appearances makes it inconclusive as to whether or not it is PIS. As for runner, his only two combat feats, one in which he humiliates SS, and the other in which he blitzed a gem-wielding Thanos (the point on whether or not he tapped into the space gem is of course arguable) place him on a pretty high pedestal. I place less emphasis on his non-combat feats, even though I do not call PIS on any of them. In any case, I can agree that his place is above SS but lower than Odin. I would put him at Thanos level or slightly above, which in my opinion is good enough to take at least a split against DS.

Originally posted by george '06
you cantheal the omega effect, it erases you from existence who says it will even work on an elder, the very universe itself wants to keep them as they are and death is not complete without her brother oblivion, the personification of nullification (heh that rhymes)
she barred them from ANY afterlife so they stay in the 616 permanently.

sure in this thread they aren't immortal but the power primordial wasn't taken away so i'm assuming they are essential to the universe as galactus is.

galactus even ate several elders and they continued living within his "stomach".

Originally posted by Ouallada
Well, SS was shown to blitz Nova in the latter's own series. To be honest, if wonder woman is assumed to have near light speed reflexes by being able to block lasers with her bracelets, surfer should get the benefit of that doubt as well, using the same coin.



Thing is, I don't consider WW's combat speed that high up there honestly. I'll consider her ability to block stuff very high (although I haven't seen her do anything near light speed even in her best portrayals), but in terms of combat, pretty much everyone is able to hit her, speedsters have been able to blitz her, and she doesn't blitz anyone. Honestly, I think the writers of both Surfer and WW don't even take into account what their respective blocking ability and flight speed should imply in a HTH fight for the most part.

Bottom line is this -- regardless of whether or not Surfer may have Superman-like speed, if the writers are leaving this potential aspect of his power out of his battles 99.9% of the time and there's no indication that it was in play here, Occam's Razor suggests that it wasn't an active factor here. The encounter with Mantis a few issues later makes this a moot point, in any event.



Originally posted by Ouallada
I'm not doubting that DS will in all probability be able to hit runner, the same way I don't doubt that Flash can be tagged as well. The only problem is consistency, and whether or not the severity can put down a being of runner's physical stats. The surfer fight, of course, should have little bearing on whether or not DS can hit runner consistently, as he is undoubtedly quicker than DS -- Tyson being able to knock someone out has no bearing on whether or not the man on the street can. The fact that SS only came close to touching the runner after the latter saw fit to engage in close quarter combat and a test of strength illustrates the context even better.

It is not irrelevant. It is simply inconclusive. That works the same way as it does for Scathan and Protege. If the former's only appearance has him at LT level, that is his established level, simply that the lack of appearances makes it inconclusive as to whether or not it is PIS. As for runner, his only two combat feats, one in which he humiliates SS, and the other in which he blitzed a gem-wielding Thanos (the point on whether or not he tapped into the space gem is of course arguable) place him on a pretty high pedestal. I place less emphasis on his non-combat feats, even though I do not call PIS on any of them. In any case, I can agree that his place is above SS but lower than Odin. I would put him at Thanos level or slightly above, which in my opinion is good enough to take at least a split against DS.


My point is that -- as you mentioned -- his showings thus far have been inconclusive. As I consider Darkseid's "average" raw power level above Surfer's, it's hard to say exactly how The Runner ranks next to him except to say that they're in the same ballpark. Assuming The Runner is comparable to Darkseid in raw power, versatility, and competence (the latter of which he seemed to lack in Thanos Quest, but I don't hold it against him since the same applied to everyone except Thanos and Warlock in those stories), his speed advantage should give him the win. At this point, though, it would be up to a future writer to give a definitive response. I just don't think The Runner's been defined enough yet to say how he'd do against other opponents who are above top tier.


The only meaningful debates here are whether or not DS can hit The Runner at all and whether or not he could overpower Surfer the way The Runner did. If we agree that the answer to both of those questions is "yes," beyond that we're just going by where we think The Runner's limits may be.

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan
Thing is, I don't consider WW's combat speed that high up there honestly. I'll consider her ability to block stuff very high (although I haven't seen her do anything near light speed even in her best portrayals), but in terms of combat, pretty much everyone is able to hit her, speedsters have been able to blitz her, and she doesn't blitz anyone. Honestly, I think the writers of both Surfer and WW don't even take into account what their respective blocking ability and flight speed should imply in a HTH fight for the most part.

Bottom line is this -- regardless of whether or not Surfer may have Superman-like speed, if the writers are leaving this potential aspect of his power out of his battles 99.9% of the time and there's no indication that it was in play here, Occam's Razor suggests that it wasn't an active factor here. The encounter with Mantis a few issues later makes this a moot point, in any event.


Fair enough on your first point, but WW's agility is another debate for another thread. The point of contention that I have is with SS' seeming lack of feats pertaining to combat reflexes. SS is both a pacifist and a ranged fighter by default, so I really don't see why a lack of h2h combat speed feats counts against him. To me, we don't ask why Mayweather doesn't engage in wild brawls simply because he is a boxer that is both technical and elusive -- he doesn't and should not be expected to need those feats. The same thing applies to SS, who has shown combat speed recently after his supposed mental upgrade in annihilation. Of course, most beings have been able to tag SS in some way, but then and again, the various flashes have been tagged many a time too. In this case, it is my opinion that an absence of proof is not a proof of absence.

As far as having Superman's h2h speed, I don't think any fair person would expect it from SS, who has not only had many fewer appearances, but who isn't supposed to fight in that way. That isn't so much of an assumption but a fact, the same way SS' lack of feats showcasing immediate transmutation of opponents from the get-go does not equal to an inability to do so, but rather simply being in line with character. Thus, I really do not see where Occam's Razor applies here -- I am simply stating that SS' character takes him away from blitzing opponents, an arrear that was corrected when he blitzed Nova after holding back less. Thus, even if SS wasn't going to try to blitz the runner, he has the ability to react at certain speeds. To be honest, after rereading the fight, SS only hit the runner after the latter deemed it necessary to go h2h, so while it was a good showing for SS to actually tag the runner, it was an even better one for the runner to absolutely humiliate SS.

I'm not sure what the Mantis incident is supposed to prove though, or why it cancels the showings against SS and Thanos. Every single speedster has been tagged by someone much slower, an unavoidable occurence. The thing that sets runner aside, and places him higher than most other speedsters is the fact that he has great physical stats to go along with his speed.

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan

My point is that -- as you mentioned -- his showings thus far have been inconclusive. As I consider Darkseid's "average" raw power level above Surfer's, it's hard to say exactly how The Runner ranks next to him except to say that they're in the same ballpark. Assuming The Runner is comparable to Darkseid in raw power, versatility, and competence (the latter of which he seemed to lack in Thanos Quest, but I don't hold it against him since the same applied to everyone except Thanos and Warlock in those stories), his speed advantage should give him the win. At this point, though, it would be up to a future writer to give a definitive response. I just don't think The Runner's been defined enough yet to say how he'd do against other opponents who are above top tier.


The only meaningful debates here are whether or not DS can hit The Runner at all and whether or not he could overpower Surfer the way The Runner did. If we agree that the answer to both of those questions is "yes," beyond that we're just going by where we think The Runner's limits may be.

Agreed, once again on the point that runner's showings are inconclusive, and the points on DS being comfortably above SS and runner/DS being in the same ballpark in terms of power. I also partially agree with the point that characters seem to be dumbed down in order to portray the supposed intelligence and craft of other characters, but given the context and the difficulty in writing machiavellian characters, I would say that the ends really justify the means in this case, and that we at least got accurate portrayals of Warlock and Thanos from Starlin.

In addition to your two debates, I would add a point pertaining to whether DS would have done as well as runner against a gem-wielding Thanos. Without arguing aimlessly about whether the runner was using his gem or not, keeping the context correct (e.g. space gem may not be optimal for DS, runner may only have been tapping it subconsciously, if he even did so) would allow everyone to place his power level better. As to your other debates, I reckon that DS would do the same to SS, and my answer to the other is "yes, probably". That's enough for me to give the runner 5/10 here, based on what I've seen.

Runner beats him.

wowzers

Originally posted by Ouallada
Fair enough on your first point, but WW's agility is another debate for another thread. The point of contention that I have is with SS' seeming lack of feats pertaining to combat reflexes. SS is both a pacifist and a ranged fighter by default, so I really don't see why a lack of h2h combat speed feats counts against him. To me, we don't ask why Mayweather doesn't engage in wild brawls simply because he is a boxer that is both technical and elusive -- he doesn't and should not be expected to need those feats. The same thing applies to SS, who has shown combat speed recently after his supposed mental upgrade in annihilation. Of course, most beings have been able to tag SS in some way, but then and again, the various flashes have been tagged many a time too. In this case, it is my opinion that an absence of proof is not a proof of absence.

As far as having Superman's h2h speed, I don't think any fair person would expect it from SS, who has not only had many fewer appearances, but who isn't supposed to fight in that way. That isn't so much of an assumption but a fact, the same way SS' lack of feats showcasing immediate transmutation of opponents from the get-go does not equal to an inability to do so, but rather simply being in line with character. Thus, I really do not see where Occam's Razor applies here -- I am simply stating that SS' character takes him away from blitzing opponents, an arrear that was corrected when he blitzed Nova after holding back less. Thus, even if SS wasn't going to try to blitz the runner, he has the ability to react at certain speeds. To be honest, after rereading the fight, SS only hit the runner after the latter deemed it necessary to go h2h, so while it was a good showing for SS to actually tag the runner, it was an even better one for the runner to absolutely humiliate SS.

I'm not sure what the Mantis incident is supposed to prove though, or why it cancels the showings against SS and Thanos. Every single speedster has been tagged by someone much slower, an unavoidable occurence. The thing that sets runner aside, and places him higher than most other speedsters is the fact that he has great physical stats to go along with his speed.

My entire point was that Darkseid would probably be able to hit The Runner with something if the fight happened in a comic. I thought you were saying that Surfer likely was using some sort of super-reflexes entirely beyond Darkseid's ability to land the blast to The Runner's chest.



Originally posted by Ouallada


Agreed, once again on the point that runner's showings are inconclusive, and the points on DS being comfortably above SS and runner/DS being in the same ballpark in terms of power. I also partially agree with the point that characters seem to be dumbed down in order to portray the supposed intelligence and craft of other characters, but given the context and the difficulty in writing machiavellian characters, I would say that the ends really justify the means in this case, and that we at least got accurate portrayals of Warlock and Thanos from Starlin.



Ah, I agree that Starlin's 90's work was still awesome. I was just pointing out that a lot of his more cosmic scenes or attempts to show a character's genius have been IMO lacking compared to what he wrote back in the 70's when he was working on Mar-Vell. It's like he's so eager to get to the "pay-off" that the build-up isn't as well thought out at times, and a lot of characters look dumber for it.


Originally posted by Ouallada


In addition to your two debates, I would add a point pertaining to whether DS would have done as well as runner against a gem-wielding Thanos. Without arguing aimlessly about whether the runner was using his gem or not, keeping the context correct (e.g. space gem may not be optimal for DS, runner may only have been tapping it subconsciously, if he even did so) would allow everyone to place his power level better. As to your other debates, I reckon that DS would do the same to SS, and my answer to the other is "yes, probably". That's enough for me to give the runner 5/10 here, based on what I've seen.


What I remember of the Runner/Thanos fight was The Runner hurting Thanos with a speed-blitz out of nowhere and threatening him, then getting @#$%ed up by the Gem. Granted it's been years since I read that or saw any scans.

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan

What I remember of the Runner/Thanos fight was The Runner hurting Thanos with a speed-blitz out of nowhere and threatening him, then getting @#$%ed up by the Gem. Granted it's been years since I read that or saw any scans. Actually, he never even touched Thanos.

On the panels he only destroyed his chair.
Thanos appeared helpless, grasping at it's pieces.
And then, as you find out, it's only a ploy, as Thanos begins to stand upright on nothing.

At no point was anything depicted on panel as actually hitting Thanos.
No fist, no kick, no blast.


Thus Runner never beat Thanos, or even came close.
He never even touched him.

Originally posted by Juntai
On the panels he only destroyed his chair.
Thanos appeared helpless, grasping at it's pieces.
And then, as you find out, it's only a ploy, as Thanos begins to stand upright on nothing.

At no point was anything depicted on panel as actually hitting Thanos.
No fist, no kick, no blast.


Thus Runner never beat Thanos, or even came close.
He never even touched him.

true. he left him 'apparently' helpless, but he never used his power against him so we don't know how runner would have fared in direct combat with thanos.

and i'm a little confused on why everyone thinks the runner is 'all that'. what are his biggest speed feats without the gem? he overpowered the old ss (though i've often wondered if that wasn't explained by his psychic powers -- he could have used his 'likeability' against ss to prevent his drawing on all his power) but . . .

as for ss crossing 'universes': he would likely have crossed several dimensional barriers to reach the decimators -- like taking short cuts. not sure reaching across multiple universes is much of an indication of speed. i'm more impressed with the 6000ly he covered to reach zen-la because that distance WAS known. who knows how much actual 'distance' he covered to find the decimators.

as for the thread -- shrug

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan


My entire point was that Darkseid would probably be able to hit The Runner with something if the fight happened in a comic. I thought you were saying that Surfer likely was using some sort of super-reflexes entirely beyond Darkseid's ability to land the blast to The Runner's chest.


I agree, just as I agree that all speedsters would be able to be tagged in a comic. The point on SS' reflexes is more to showcase runner's ability to completely outspeed a character who has never been blitzed before. It certainly is within DS' ability to hit runner, but I don't see him reacting better to runner's speed better than SS.


Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan
Ah, I agree that Starlin's 90's work was still awesome. I was just pointing out that a lot of his more cosmic scenes or attempts to show a character's genius have been IMO lacking compared to what he wrote back in the 70's when he was working on Mar-Vell. It's like he's so eager to get to the "pay-off" that the build-up isn't as well thought out at times, and a lot of characters look dumber for it.


I actually completely agree, although a large part of marvel's cosmology is down to Starlin's work. He has also been the only one to get Thanos' character right, and Warlock's, to a lesser extent. That, IMO, is the real reason behind the clone retcons, not an adversity to his character losing.



Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan
What I remember of the Runner/Thanos fight was The Runner hurting Thanos with a speed-blitz out of nowhere and threatening him, then getting @#$%ed up by the Gem. Granted it's been years since I read that or saw any scans.

My synopsis of the fight:

1) Thanos gets blindsided out of nowhere and his throne gets destroyed before he can react sufficiently.

2) Runner slows down to talk shop with Thanos. Hype and threats are exchanged here.

3) Thanos tries an eyeblast, while runner dodges by literally running rings around Thanos.

4) Thanos states that he was not expecting runner to be so quick, and ends up looking defeated while runner states that he can blitz him to death.

5) Thanos plays possum and tells him the story behind the gems.

6) Thanos devolves runner.

My opinion on this is that Thanos blatantly did not expect the runner to be as fast as he was (even though he clearly knew the runner to be a speedster), and was taken aback before setting his contingency plan into action. It simply isn't in character for Thanos to fool around and be profligate with his chances. A good example would be the grandmaster showing, in which the reader was led to believe that Thanos was suckered, when he was blatantly never in trouble.

Tryco, Ego.. pretty much all of them can take out Darkseid

That Silver Surfer travel speed feat comes from 'Fantastic Four: The End.' It's not canon. Just fyi. Also, the Elders are underrated and so is the Runner's speed. If Superman can outrace the OE, Runner definitely could. Darkseid woud have to resort to his wits, not his power.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0

That Silver Surfer travel speed feat comes from 'Fantastic Four: The End.'

It's not canon.
Where is this stated and/or depicted?

^ Oops. Those scans are actually from the comic, 'The Last Fantastic Four Story.' It was written by Stan Lee a few years back. My bads, got that and 'Fantastic Four: The End' mixed up in my head.