Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

in straight 1on1 combat bats can't win. too many advantages to wolverine who is SUPERHUMAN. but, in this case, the winner is dependent on who scores better in h2h combat. scoring is based on contacts. killing blows are worth more than simple strikes.

simple strikes are 1 point, killing blows are 3 points. wnner is first to 25 points.

who wins? how close is it in terms of score do you think?

This sounds even less favorable according to your description of the two.

Batman is able to land some of the most deadly strikes "in all of the fighting arts" in quick succession.

I think in these circumstances, Batman takes it.

Batman for sure.

I'm going with Batman.

Batman.

Originally posted by leonidas
in straight 1on1 combat bats can't win. too many advantages to wolverine who is SUPERHUMAN. but, in this case, the winner is dependent on who scores better in h2h combat. scoring is based on contacts. killing blows are worth more than simple strikes.

simple strikes are 1 point, killing blows are 3 points. wnner is first to 25 points.

who wins? how close is it in terms of score do you think?

When you say "killing blows" do you mean shots that would kill a human or shots that would kill Wolverine?

Batman

tie or wolverine

Batman

I would say wolverine, because IMO they are close in skill, but wolverine still has his speed advantage. Faster hands=more points for logan.

Originally posted by Scoobless
When you say "killing blows" do you mean shots that would kill a human or shots that would kill Wolverine?

they'd kill a normal person.

Do blocked strikes count as a strike or only those that land on the head/torso? Would attacks directed at the arms and legs count even is blocked?

Originally posted by Creshosk
Do blocked strikes count as a strike or only those that land on the head/torso? Would attacks directed at the arms and legs count even is blocked?

strikes must land, only in this case they do NOT incapacitate. assume a perfect judge is ruling over the match and calls out the points as blows land.

can't believe jinzin hasn't given an opinion yet . . .

Originally posted by leonidas
strikes must land, only in this case they do NOT incapacitate. assume a perfect judge is ruling over the match and calls out the points as blows land. So does intentionally attacking body parts other than the torso count? like a sweep kick, or snap kick to the back of the knee for example.

Originally posted by Creshosk
So does intentionally attacking body parts other than the torso count? like a sweep kick, or snap kick to the back of the knee for example.

yeah, any attack that could potentially cause harm or incapacitate even briefly. but it has to be cleanly landed to score the point.

batman has greater knowlege of presure points and how to damage them.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
I'm going with Batman.

does logan get to use his claws or not? I think that might be determinative

Wolverine.

Originally posted by Starscream M
does logan get to use his claws or not? I think that might be determinative

no. pure h2h. skill v skill.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Wolverine.

... loses. We know.

Wolverine should win this pretty easily - he's god knows how old, trained in who knows how many fighting arts and far more agile, with keener senses and far faster reaction times... Batman won't get a chance .

Nice match-up.

But I'm still rooting with Batman 6/10

Wolverwienner takes 6/ for reasons alredy stated - aglity / reaction time/ xp and knowledge - close though.

Originally posted by leonidas
in straight 1on1 combat bats can't win

Originally posted by Obsidian Fury
In a straight one on one combat Wolverine has his healing factor and claws. Meaning ALL of his strikes with his fists can be considered incapacitating if not lethal, plus with his healing factor any damage that Batman does will be healed off. Batman doesn't have such an advantage. At least as far as melee combat is concerned. Now here Wolverine's healing factor isn't a factor. as points scored do not go away. Plus Wolverine doesn't get to use his claws. So this is just off of pure skill.

Oh, melee. Yeah, Wolverine got bats there.

Originally posted by janus77
Wolverine should win this pretty easily - he's god knows how old, trained in who knows how many fighting arts and far more agile, with keener senses and far faster reaction times... Batman won't get a chance .

Originally posted by leonidas
can't believe jinzin hasn't given an opinion yet . . .

Hey the only thing that my vast and useless comic book knowledge could possibly help me be informed of about this battle is one clear and simple thing.....














Punisher wins.

Originally posted by jinzin
Hey the only thing that my vast and useless comic book knowledge could possibly help me be informed of about this battle is one clear and simple thing.....














Punisher wins.

Well one thing's for certain... Punisher's will power is >>>>> everybody else considering he preformed surgery on himself. mhmm

Originally posted by janus77
Wolverine should win this pretty easily - he's god knows how old, trained in who knows how many fighting arts and far more agile, with keener senses and far faster reaction times... Batman won't get a chance . That's it more or less. Wolvie FTW