Students vs Mentors

Mentors
Batman
&
Captain America (Steve Rodgers)

vs

Students
Batgirl (Cassandra Cain)
Nightwing
&
Captain America (Bucky)

Fights take place in an abandoned warehouse at night.

Fight 1: No weapons, no gadgets. Pure H2H.
Fight 2: Anything goes.
Fight 3: Add Robin (Tim Drake).

Nothing? Nothing?! Gah! I hate you all.

Also I have no idea why I spelled it "Rodgers."

1st fight, batgirl solos
2nd & 3rd mentors win

Batgirl isn't soloing both Captain America and Batman h2h... ermm

There's arguments to be had over whether she'd stalemate or take the majority from either one or the other... but she's not taking both.

Mentors
Mentors
Students

1students
2mentors
3mentors (if its still anything goes)

1. even split, maybe students...
2. mentors
3. students.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Batgirl isn't soloing both Captain America and Batman h2h... ermm

There's arguments to be had over whether she'd stalemate or take the majority from either one or the other... but she's not taking both.

I don't get what you mean by saying Batgirl could solo them both... and then saying she would split them up... ermm

It's still anything goes in 3.

I would go 1. Leaning towards students, 2. Mentors, as well... Not sure about 3 yet though.

With 1, it basically depends on whether one thinks Nightwing and Bucky can take down either Captain America or Batman, and take them down fast enough, so they can help Batgirl with the other one. Or vice versa so that Batgirl can help take down the other...

I don't know if Tim adds enough oomph for them to take 3...

up til winter soldier, bucky was essentially useless, it'll take nightwing to help him win anything

Rodgers is quite the guy

Originally posted by llagrok
Rodgers is quite the guy

😮

It's not as bad as every Rogue thread being about a make-up product though. 😊

Originally posted by george '06
up til winter soldier, bucky was essentially useless, it'll take nightwing to help him win anything

Go read the entirety of Brubakers run on Captain America, then come back and realise how wrong you are.

Bucky was nowhere near "essentially useless".

agree w/raoul

In the fights with weapons, do both Captain Americas have the shield?

Originally posted by Soljer
In the fights with weapons, do both Captain Americas have the shield?

Mentors to the three.

If Batgirl is a good h2H, the Bat and Cap are too.

The difference is that Cap is a 10 toner.

😑 10 toner? (sic)

1: Students
2: Mentors
3: Adding Robin in either side gives a win to that side