Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

seems interesting. organic steel v nth metal. which gives?

Colossus is stronger, more durable. Carter's a better fighter. It's not a 10/10 scenario either way. I'd give Hawky the slight majority though. Enough hits with the mace would floor Colossus, and his healing makes up somewhat for the lack in durability.

How much can Hawkman carry? Cause in theory he could just fly around and drop stuff on Colossus.

Drop stuff? Not really a viable tactic for taking out someone who is physically superior to you. Carter's a close-range brawler, even with those out of his league. He can employ flight, but won't be doing many ranged attacks.

colossus 10/10

Colossus 8-9/10

Hawkman 5.5/10

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
How much can Hawkman carry? Cause in theory he could just fly around and drop stuff on Colossus.

Haha. That has about as much a chance at working as does Colossus' tactic of chunking stuff at the airborne Carter.

Not really as a flier he is more agile and more likely to dodge.

prolly piotr

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Not really as a flier he is more agile and more likely to dodge.

Aye but not if he's carrying something heavy enough to maybe hurt big C

I would still say he'd have an slightly easier time to dodge then Colossus.

hawkman wins 7/10, he would be to mobile for colosuss

Colossus
All he needs is to grab Carter and break him and for Hawkman to attack he has to get close.
I know that Piotr has tagged Quicksilver before so I don't see why he can't grab Carter at some point.

But I can also see Carter winning through some kind of hit and fly strategy (his Thanagarian weapons pack a lot of damage)

I still say Piotr 7.5/10

colossus

Does Hawkman have acess to all his weapons? sans the Claw of Horus of course?

Originally posted by -K-M-
Does Hawkman have acess to all his weapons? sans the Claw of Horus of course?

If Hawkman has the claw then Hawkman 10/10 but I think we're talking standard gear.

Originally posted by comicfan11
If Hawkman has the claw then Hawkman 10/10 but I think we're talking standard gear.

He has other weapons without using the Claw which he could get 10/10 :P

Originally posted by -K-M-
He has other weapons without using the Claw which he could get 10/10 :P

Which one's?
And are they standard gear?

Don't get me wrong I love Hawkman and Johns run was top plus his most recent appearances are all great (featwise) like Trinity and JSA.

I'm not saying he can't win I'm just saying that Piotr has the edge due to the fact that Hawkman has to get close in a fight and although he flies fast he is not a speedster and thus Colossus can tag him and take him down...

BTW great job on his respect thread that you update regularly

Don't the hawks control the level of gravity and anti gravity of thier nth metals? I would just drop my Nth Metal on colossus from far with some crazy weight on it. the force plus the actual metal should at least KO colossus.

Can't he just bash Colossus in the face with his hammer? nth metal should be much more durable than ole piotr

Originally posted by comicfan11
Which one's?
And are they standard gear?

Don't get me wrong I love Hawkman and Johns run was top plus his most recent appearances are all great (featwise) like Trinity and JSA.

I'm not saying he can't win I'm just saying that Piotr has the edge due to the fact that Hawkman has to get close in a fight and although he flies fast he is not a speedster and thus Colossus can tag him and take him down...

BTW great job on his respect thread that you update regularly

His Thanagarian weapons such as the neural gun

1. http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/ShadowWarofHawkman03-19.jpg
2. http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/ShadowWarofHawkman03-20.jpg
3. http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/ShadowWarofHawkman03-21.jpg

Tagging Hawkman is going to be a feat onto itself

I agree, I think Hawkman takes this.

Hawkman DOES take this.

Colossus

Originally posted by -K-M-
His Thanagarian weapons such as the neural gun

1. http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/ShadowWarofHawkman03-19.jpg
2. http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/ShadowWarofHawkman03-20.jpg
3. http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/ShadowWarofHawkman03-21.jpg

Tagging Hawkman is going to be a feat onto itself

Nice weapon if he plays with range then Hawkman take's it.

But if he plays it close (like he usually does) it won't be difficult at all for Colossus to tag him. If Batman and Green Arrow can do it so does Piotr.
He flies fast and maybe reacts faster than human. That doesn't make him a speedster.

Originally posted by comicfan11
Nice weapon if he plays with range then Hawkman take's it.

But if he plays it close (like he usually does) it won't be difficult at all for Colossus to tag him. If Batman and Green Arrow can do it so does Piotr.
He flies fast and maybe reacts faster than human. That doesn't make him a speedster.

Except Hawkman beats speedsters regularly because of his abilities and speed, and has super speed himself. Kator has shown to even go lightspeed in space while toeing a spaceship. Plus his vision is so heightened he can see Flash vibrating so fast he's invisable to everyone else except for Hawkman.

No, tagging a serious Hawkman would be diffucult.

Hawkman takes it, but if he loses the mace, Colossus would pulverize him.