Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins here?

1.Sabers
2.Force
3.All out

Location-Palpatine's office where Sidious fought Yoda

Sid the Kid (relatively speaking) wins all three, easily.

Nuh-uh! Sion's invincibibble.

Sidious gets F'd in the A on account of practical immortality. All BS aside, untill we know otherwise, Sion will remain a beast.

Heck, he might actually be able to win 100% of the time for all we know, unless Traya helps Sids out.

This is the guy who practically mindraped Starkiller -- the guy who came to the Death Star to kill him -- by saying "take your rightful place at my side." Starkiller was overtaken by the Emperor's "ghastly charisma."

I'm pretty sure that if the Exile can talk Sion into oblivion, then the man who made a Republic that has existed for 25,000 years unanimously support it becoming a ruthless dictatorship can.

I can see Sion going out the window for disrespecting Paplatine just like Windu did. Buut, Sion can take heavy damage. If I'm right, doesn't he only die when he chooses so?

'Practical immortality?' if Palpatine beheads him? If he fries him to ash? When does Sion's immortality cover this stuff?

Originally posted by Lightsnake
'Practical immortality?' if Palpatine beheads him? If he fries him to ash? When does Sion's immortality cover this stuff?

Taking his head off would more than likely work, other than that, I don't think frying him to bits would do any good, as we've seen how his body is. I mean look at him, don't you think someone has already tried to fry him to bits? Even in the game, lightning doesn't take him down for the count.

no, no, I mean Palpatine is literally capable of reducing Force Users to piles of bone or ash. I sincerely doubt someone with Palpatine's power of the Force or lightning has tried.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
no, no, I mean Palpatine is literally capable of reducing Force Users to piles of bone or ash. I sincerely doubt someone with Palpatine's power of the Force or lightning has tried.

Not that I don't believe you, but do you have any scans or such as an example? The best I've seen from his lightning is eliminating Windu in ROTS, other than trying to kill Luke in ROTJ.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
no, no, I mean Palpatine is literally capable of reducing Force Users to piles of bone or ash. I sincerely doubt someone with Palpatine's power of the Force or lightning has tried.

You going to prove that ROTS Sidious' lightning can?

Originally posted by Darth Raizen
Not that I don't believe you, but do you have any scans or such as an example? The best I've seen from his lightning is eliminating Windu in ROTS, other than trying to kill Luke in ROTJ.

I don't have scans, but I can give you the source: Tales, Volume 3. Story: Resurrection.

Grantd as this is ROTS Palpatine it might be different, as Resurrection takes place between ROTS and ANH

Of course in Visionaries, Story: Sithisis, he reduces a giant Sith wyrm creature to a husk of ash with his lightning as well

Originally posted by Lightsnake
I don't have scans, but I can give you the source: Tales, Volume 3. Story: Resurrection.

Grantd as this is ROTS Palpatine it might be different, as Resurrection takes place between ROTS and ANH

Of course in Visionaries, Story: Sithisis, he reduces a giant Sith wyrm creature to a husk of ash with his lightning as well

The Sith wyrm is a good feat to go by, because its resistant to Dark Side...stuff. Just like powerful Force users seem to be resistant to Force Lightning.

I don't think ROTS Palpatine can disintegrate Sion. I think that'd severely piss him off and cause all kinds of pain, which would make him stronger. I do think Sion would get dominated in sabers, and Palpatine can squish him by throwing something very large at him with the Force, though.

I'm with Lightsnake on this one. Sion doesn't stand much of a chance.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
no, no, I mean Palpatine is literally capable of reducing Force Users to piles of bone or ash. I sincerely doubt someone with Palpatine's power of the Force or lightning has tried.

Yeah. Let's compare two acolythes who's only displays of "power" lie within Sith Alchemy to a fully fledged Sith Lord who apparently killed a nice amount of Jedi on his own.

Especially when said Sith Lord in the cutscenes takes a nice force beating from Nihilus and gets up second after this, as if nothing has happened at all...

^Cut Content=Non-Canon, and he actually limped away and Nihilus taught him why he was still the master, as Sion never tried that again

Originally posted by Borbarad
Yeah. Let's compare two acolythes who's only displays of "power" lie within Sith Alchemy to a fully fledged Sith Lord who apparently killed a nice amount of Jedi on his own.

Especially when said Sith Lord in the cutscenes takes a nice force beating from Nihilus and gets up second after this, as if nothing has happened at all...

Unless you're seriously arguing Sion will win, then is there a point?

Originally posted by Borbarad
Yeah. Let's compare two acolythes who's only displays of "power" lie within Sith Alchemy to a fully fledged Sith Lord who apparently killed a nice amount of Jedi on his own.
Three Acolytes. And when was it said Sion had killed a bunch of Jedi? That, and he was an assassin which doesn't imply direct combat and confrontation.

That's non canon. And this was Nihilus disciplining him rather than aiming to do actual harm

Originally posted by Borbarad
Yeah. Let's compare two acolythes who's only displays of "power" lie within Sith Alchemy to a fully fledged Sith Lord who apparently killed a nice amount of Jedi on his own.

Yeah just Sith Alchemy. I mean its only behind some of the most powerful demonstrations of the Force we've ever seen.

You would need to prove that they had their defenses up, or their Force-sensitivity is irrelevant.

Originally posted by Borbarad
Especially when said Sith Lord in the cutscenes takes a nice force beating from Nihilus and gets up second after this, as if nothing has happened at all... You mean when Nihilus effortlessly pwned him and Sion limped away with his tail between his legs?

Not a good point to bring up.

Nihilus was not trying to kill him anyway.

And cut content is non canon.

Sidious wins.

Originally posted by Faunus
You would need to prove that they had their defenses up, or their Force-sensitivity is irrelevant. Any force user would get overwhelmed if they are attacked by a very formidable force user and not having their defences up.

Thats how both marek and vader tooled each other.