Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Which Joker wins?

http://beetstro.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/joker.jpg

Vs.

http://clothesmonaut.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/joker-crashes-mob-meeting.jpg

Vs.

http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/thumb/a/a1/Joker_DCAU.jpg/300px-Joker_DCAU.jpg

Cartoon Joker had more resources than probably both live action Jokers combined. He shouldnt even be in this. The man almost killed Superman for petes sake.

If we wanna have a battle between both live action Jokers, then Jacks Joker takes it.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Cartoon Joker had more resources than probably both live action Jokers combined. He shouldnt even be in this. The man almost killed Superman for petes sake.

If we wanna have a battle between both live action Jokers, then Jacks Joker takes it.


agreed..

You know I could always add this to balance it out:

http://www.freewebs.com/odetojoker/JokerCesar_Romero_.gif

there's joker from "the batman" also. he'd solo all of them in 30 seconds flat.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
there's joker from "the batman" also. he'd solo all of them in 30 seconds flat.

Bah!

Luke Skywalker's Joker would own him.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Bah!

Luke Skywalker's Joker would own him.

To quote some douchebag whose name I do not remember on this site: "There is only one Joker, and his name is Mark. May the Force be with you."

In a fight, Mark's Joker wins again, but between the two live-action ones, Ledger's would win. Nicholson's Joker was kind of a puss when it came to fighting IMO.

Hamil, he had the mosty resources and the best fighter.

he was also the best version outside of comics

Originally posted by NemeBro
In a fight, Mark's Joker wins again, but between the two live-action ones, Ledger's would win. Nicholson's Joker was kind of a puss when it came to fighting IMO.

Yea, but Joker isnt exactly know for his h2h prowess. Jacks Joker had better weaponry on hand.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Yea, but Joker isnt exactly know for his h2h prowess. Jacks Joker had better weaponry on hand. Ledger's Joker just needs a gun to kill Jack's.

And please do not bring up the big gun.

Ive always prefered the cartoon Jokers especially that cartoon one (Hamill). They are always cooler and more insane than when they try to make him on film.

So ill go with Hamill

Originally posted by NemeBro
Ledger's Joker just needs a gun to kill Jack's.

And please do not bring up the big gun.

Jacks Joker wasnt afraid of guns. Plus he had that "aura". And why cant bring up the canon? Hell, Jacks Joker would kill Ledgers with the pen. Ahhhh! Forgot about that one didnt ya?

Originally posted by jrodslam
Jacks Joker wasnt afraid of guns. Plus he had that "aura". And why cant bring up the canon? Hell, Jacks Joker would kill Ledgers with the pen. Ahhhh! Forgot about that one didnt ya? He doesn't have to be afraid of them, he'll still die.

The canon takes an ungodly amount of time to prepare.

The pen? Ledger kills Jack with the pencil.

Originally posted by NemeBro
He doesn't have to be afraid of them, he'll still die.

The canon takes an ungodly amount of time to prepare.

The pen? Ledger kills Jack with the pencil.

Jacks "aura" will make Ldger miss.

The canon only took longer in the movie was because Bats was so high and so far away. If Ledgers Jokers get show with that thing, help his body is gone. Then again, Jacks Joker could use in in regular mode.

Yes the pen. Thats also a ranged attack whereas the pencil is within very close range.

Acid flower too!

Cartoon Joker wins

If excluded..Jacks Joker stomps!

Jack's Joker would get stomped by Ledger's. Better acting, better fighter, better planner and oh yeah. HE DIDN'T DIE AT THE END OF THE MOVIE. jokedur

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Jack's Joker would get stomped by Ledger's. Better acting, better fighter, better planner and oh yeah. HE DIDN'T DIE AT THE END OF THE MOVIE. jokedur You just like Ledger more because he played a gay cowboy, so you feel a connection.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Jack's Joker would get stomped by Ledger's. Better acting, better fighter, better planner and oh yeah. HE DIDN'T DIE AT THE END OF THE MOVIE. jokedur jack's joker can't be hit by projectiles though. rockets and gatling rounds locked on can't touch him, even the explosions were useless.

and his durability was good enough to keep his body from exploding after falling something like...100 stories straight down onto concrete.
he was just ko'd.

the Dark Knight Joker wins this. He can fight, and really confuse the heck out of you.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
You know I could always add this to balance it out:

http://www.freewebs.com/odetojoker/JokerCesar_Romero_.gif

That Joker is a joke. All he ever did was fight Adam West in a gray suit.

Originally posted by XanatosForever
That Joker is a joke. All he ever did was fight Adam West in a gray suit. yeah agreed.

Originally posted by XanatosForever
That Joker is a joke. All he ever did was fight Adam West in a gray suit. Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
yeah agreed.

And? Adam West is the real Batman.

Yeah and all I remember is Adam West punching everybody else in the head a million times over. That Joker took a really pounding.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
jack's joker can't be hit by projectiles though. rockets and gatling rounds locked on can't touch him, even the explosions were useless.

and his durability was good enough to keep his body from exploding after falling something like...100 stories straight down onto concrete.
he was just ko'd.

Haha! QFT.

Also, Ledgers Joker was a bluffer. Jacks Joker was way more psychotic and was always going for the kill.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Jack's Joker would get stomped by Ledger's. Better acting, better fighter, better planner and oh yeah. HE DIDN'T DIE AT THE END OF THE MOVIE. jokedur yes he did. naughty

Originally posted by psycho gundam
yes he did. naughty

You're terrible...but correct in a sense.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Jacks "aura" will make Ldger miss.

The canon only took longer in the movie was because Bats was so high and so far away. If Ledgers Jokers get show with that thing, help his body is gone. Then again, Jacks Joker could use in in regular mode.

Yes the pen. Thats also a ranged attack whereas the pencil is within very close range.

Acid flower too! Aura...Refresh my memory, was this "aura" actually part of his powerset, or dumb luck? Because if it is the latter, no PIS rule sir.

2. And Ledger's Joker who was shown to actively use firearms can pull out said firearm and shoot Jack.

3. It was a mild joke. All Ledger needs is a gun.

4. Okay this gimmick shit is getting old...Ledger shoots Jack, the end. Having wacky gimmicks=/=being an effective fighter.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Haha! QFT.

Also, Ledgers Joker was a bluffer. Jacks Joker was way more psychotic and was always going for the kill. Ledger's Joker was far more psychotic and deranged. He killed countless people at a whim and with not even a slight disturbance in his(rather disinterested at times) facial expression. He only spares Batman because he is "fun."

Originally posted by psycho gundam
jack's joker can't be hit by projectiles though. rockets and gatling rounds locked on can't touch him, even the explosions were useless.

and his durability was good enough to keep his body from exploding after falling something like...100 stories straight down onto concrete.
he was just ko'd. 1. Once again, actual power, or dumb luck?

2. Yet hurt his hand when he punched Batman, and was likewise knocked around by him like a doll and bled like a pig from one punch.

Ledger was actually going to kill everyone in the hospital, after he killed that guard with no remorse. And he was shown to be a very talented fighter, and he would shoot Jack in the face, then ask, WHY SO SERIOUS???!!!!

Plus, how can this thread even exist? It's two movie characters and a cartoon.

Hamil beats both at the same time

Originally posted by jalek moye
Hamil beats both at the same time Indeed.

If I remember right wasn't he shown to hold his own against Batman in a pure H2H fight in that Batman Beyond movie?

yea, he also has gotten the better of batman in a few episodes, and i think he actually beat him once.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Aura...Refresh my memory, was this "aura" actually part of his powerset, or dumb luck? Because if it is the latter, no PIS rule sir.

2. And Ledger's Joker who was shown to actively use firearms can pull out said firearm and shoot Jack.

3. It was a mild joke. All Ledger needs is a gun.

4. Okay this gimmick shit is getting old...Ledger shoots Jack, the end. Having wacky gimmicks=/=being an effective fighter.

1. Call it whatever you want. Bats was locked on, and Jack didnt move one bit.

2. Yea and Ledgers Joker had trouble hitting a moving target. Jacks Joker appeared to have better aim at least.

3. See above.

4. Gimmick shit? The flower had a rang of at least 5 feet. Jacks Joker also had the hand buzzer. It would be a wrap for Ledgers Joker. Effective fighter? Didnt Ledgers Joker only get Bats on the floor after he was distracted?

Originally posted by NemeBro
Ledger's Joker was far more psychotic and deranged. He killed countless people at a whim and with not even a slight disturbance in his(rather disinterested at times) facial expression. He only spares Batman because he is "fun."

What? Far more psychotic and deranged? Jacks Joker killed tons of people in the movie. The man made a chemical and poisoned an entire batch of products that hundreds of people used and were already exposed to without even knowing it. Then, he had the balls to go on tv and tell ppl. Threw a parade to give away money, yet killed many of those same people at the same time. Please les not compare body counts because Jacks Joker wins by a nice margin in that department.

Originally posted by KingD19
Ledger was actually going to kill everyone in the hospital, after he killed that guard with no remorse. And he was shown to be a very talented fighter, and he would shoot Jack in the face, then ask, WHY SO SERIOUS???!!!!

Plus, how can this thread even exist? It's two movie characters and a cartoon.

NO, Ledger was NOT going to kill everyone in the hospital. It was all part of him plan. He WANTED them to get evacuated just so he can get close to Harvey. Wait wait. He was shown to be a talented fighter? Are you serious? A talented? Jacks would shoot Ledgers Joker just because his smile was phony.

Originally posted by NemeBro
1. Once again, actual power, or dumb luck?

2. Yet hurt his hand when he punched Batman, and was likewise knocked around by him like a doll and bled like a pig from one punch.

Note: Keatons Batman was both stronger and had a more durable suit than Bales. Id put money that Ledgers Joker would hurt his hand as well.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Note: Keatons Batman was both stronger and had a more durable suit than Bales. Id put money that Ledgers Joker would hurt his hand as well.
Keaton has a more durable suit than bales?.......did you see bales it looked sick

Originally posted by Kaos sebaceous
Keaton has a more durable suit than bales?.......did you see bales it looked sick

Having a better look is one thing, sir.

Very strange vs. match.

Anyways, between the 2 movie versions, Jack wins.
He had a more killing instinct, and far greater durability.
Killed hundreds of people with those poisonous cosmetics, and survived falling from a building.

And yes, Mark Hamill omfgwtfpwns them both.

Joker as Ledge beat any other Movie version of Joker. The cartoon version kill them all though.

Originally posted by Kaos sebaceous
Keaton has a more durable suit than bales?.......did you see bales it looked sick

So the cosmetics of the suit determines durability?

Originally posted by jrodslam
NO, Ledger was NOT going to kill everyone in the hospital. It was all part of him plan. He WANTED them to get evacuated just so he can get close to Harvey. Wait wait. He was shown to be a talented fighter? Are you serious? A talented? Jacks would shoot Ledgers Joker just because his smile was phony.

IIRC Joker's only h2h feats would be beating a cop off screen, hitting Batman with a lead pipe while he was distracted and owning some random goon with a pencil.

Jack's Joker wins.
The hand buzzer,the acid flower,the pen. What does Ledger Joker have? The 'Why so serious' quote?

Originally posted by jrodslam
1. Call it whatever you want. Bats was locked on, and Jack didnt move one bit.

2. Yea and Ledgers Joker had trouble hitting a moving target. Jacks Joker appeared to have better aim at least.

3. See above.

4. Gimmick shit? The flower had a rang of at least 5 feet. Jacks Joker also had the hand buzzer. It would be a wrap for Ledgers Joker. Effective fighter? Didnt Ledgers Joker only get Bats on the floor after he was distracted? 1. Dumb luck. Not applicable in a vs. match.

2. Ledger's Joker only had trouble hitting an armored car in a high-speed chase...

3. See above.

4. FIVE FEET? HOLY SHIT!!! A gun has a range of...Well it really does not matter, more than five feet. As for the hand buzzer...That involves getting close to Ledger, which is not good for Jack. Yeah. And Jack's only H2H feat is hurting his hand while punching Batman.

Originally posted by jrodslam
What? Far more psychotic and deranged? Jacks Joker killed tons of people in the movie. The man made a chemical and poisoned an entire batch of products that hundreds of people used and were already exposed to without even knowing it. Then, he had the balls to go on tv and tell ppl. Threw a parade to give away money, yet killed many of those same people at the same time. Please les not compare body counts because Jacks Joker wins by a nice margin in that department. Ledger for the lulz kidnapped and tortured a fat Batman wannabe before hanging him from a rope dead to frighten Gotham and send a message to Batman. He was forcing two ships, one of inmates, one of normal citizens including small children, to make a decision to kill everyone in the other ship, and if they did not make a choice within I think thirty minutes, he destroyed both ships. Jack could never claim to have fvcked with so many people's minds in that way, nor has he done something so deranged. He made hostages appear to be armed guards, who were basically going to be meat-bags, and his real henchmen were disguised as hostages. That is being deranged. Jack has NOTHING on this in terms of being deranged and morally deprived.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Note: Keatons Batman was both stronger and had a more durable suit than Bales. Id put money that Ledgers Joker would hurt his hand as well. Stronger? Bale's Batman through Ras Al Ghul with one arm, Liam Neeson weighs about 200 pounds. Keaton takes beatings from normal thugs. Bale beats down trained martial artist ninjaz. More durable suit? How?

anti-aircraft buster pistol ftw

http://img10.imageshack.us/img10/1385/jokerjdl.jpg

Originally posted by NemeBro
1. Dumb luck. Not applicable in a vs. match.

2. Ledger's Joker only had trouble hitting an armored car in a high-speed chase...

3. See above.

4. FIVE FEET? HOLY SHIT!!! A gun has a range of...Well it really does not matter, more than five feet. As for the hand buzzer...That involves getting close to Ledger, which is not good for Jack. Yeah. And Jack's only H2H feat is hurting his hand while punching Batman.

1. I dont know what to call it, but i wouldnt call it luck. That shit was.....aura ish, lol.

2. The case wasnt that highspeed, but i can let that one go.

3. See, thing is, Jacks Joker had a gun to. Thus saying Ledgers Joker just shoots Jacks Joker can go the other way as well. Im just bringing up other weapons Jacks Joker had on hand. As far as Jacks Joker hurting his hand, ive already addressed that. Im sure Ledgers Joker would hurt his hand just the same.

don't knock the hand buzzer on roids, that thing completely desiccated that crime boss guy in 10 seconds flat. and the guy was useless in terms of defense once it was activated, ledger would be done if he made skin contact with it.

he also had; the acid spraying flower that had decent range; the portable flame throwing zippo; teh collapsible bustah gun; and a fake hand and teeth (shut up, it was useful)

Originally posted by NemeBro
Ledger for the lulz kidnapped and tortured a fat Batman wannabe before hanging him from a rope dead to frighten Gotham and send a message to Batman. He was forcing two ships, one of inmates, one of normal citizens including small children, to make a decision to kill everyone in the other ship, and if they did not make a choice within I think thirty minutes, he destroyed both ships. Jack could never claim to have fvcked with so many people's minds in that way, nor has he done something so deranged. He made hostages appear to be armed guards, who were basically going to be meat-bags, and his real henchmen were disguised as hostages. That is being deranged. Jack has NOTHING on this in terms of being deranged and morally deprived.

Speaking of for the lulz. Jacks Joker saw that Bats was getting a bunch of attention in the press. He decided to put chemicals in an entire batch of city used products just to kill people slowly. Out of attraction, he killed an entire museum/restaurant to to get close to a woman. Ledgers Joker wanted to put fear into people and try to prove that ppl are like him in ways, and he HOPED theyd kill each other. He depended on it, whereas Jacks Joker would have just killed them.

Jacks Joker couldnt mess with peoples minds? Not to long after killing a man in cold blood with the press there, in public, in daytime, the man interrupted the mayors/harveys speech and made the people go against Bats. He made them get on his side. Told them he was giving away a million dollars in a celebration. Made the people trust him, just in turn to try and kill them all and get at Bats at the same time. The thing Ledgers Joker did with the guards was a nice tactic, however not many ppl knew about that. Imagine sitting down and watching the new with your family and the news broadcaster starts laughing after her partners mentions ppl dying? Then she continues to laugh hysterically until she has a permanent smile and dies? Just for everyone to see. That my friend is more deranged than anything Ledgers Joker did. To know that my hair, face and body products have been tainted and ive already started to use it? Lol.

Nicholson's Joker had the balls to unmask himself on tv and call out Batman. Ledger didn't.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Stronger? Bale's Batman through Ras Al Ghul with one arm, Liam Neeson weighs about 200 pounds. Keaton takes beatings from normal thugs. Bale beats down trained martial artist ninjaz. More durable suit? How?

Yup, stronger. In the beginning on the movie, Keatons Batman took the guy and held him at the edge of the building ledge. The man had to have weighed over 200lbs. Also, at the end, when he and Vale were holding on the the side of the building and Vale got tricked by Jokers fake hand, Bats with one hand, caught her and lifter her up so she can get her grip again. All while holding on with one hand himself. Keaton takes beatings from normal thungs? Some of Jokers thugs actually had skill(guy with swords in alley, black dude in church tower). More durable suit for the fact that he took point black gun shots. For the fact that he had armored areas when he could deflect both bullets and swords. He wasnt effected by body blows at all. He crashed in his plane. had it explode, just to walk out of it with only a minor face bruise.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Nicholson's Joker had the balls to unmask himself on tv and call out Batman. Ledger didn't. '

Actually, Jacks Joker put makeup on when he went on tv. His skin was actually chalk white, but to deceive the people, he covered it up with makeup and told them that he took it off.

Originally posted by jrodslam
'

Actually, Jacks Joker put makeup on when he went on tv. His skin was actually chalk white, but to deceive the people, he covered it up with makeup and told them that he took it off.

Wait that's even more bad ass then.

Now this is deranged.

ZKFeuBfDTso

I do agree that killing with laughter and killing them slowly while they don't even know they're dying is more deranged than killing through fear or giving people the choice to kill others. Ledger seemed to want to turn Gotham on themselves. Jack seemed to want to have fun and kill off Gotham for his own enjoyment.

jack's joker did it for the lulz

If hamils joker is out than Jack for me. That pen technique is no joker, "Bob its your uncle bingo, time to pay the check "

Bump for the lulz

Jack Nicholson will always be the best joker. EVER.

for awhile everyone was posting heath ledger the best joker ever. now its back to nicholson all of a sudden

I prefer Ledger's by a mile, to be honest. The only real good portrayal of him outside of comics imo.

animated joker stomps....


if its a fight between live acton jack wins it....

TBH, Jack was closer to the comic version of the Joker..

The things he did in the movie is something the comics version would do

They were just 2 different visions of the same character, neither was wrong exactly. I preferred Ledger's more psychotic looking joker to Jack's neatly trimmed and maticulous joker. Both are insane, I just enjoyed the anarchist one more than the rising crime lord.

FHvhFZOOXrs