Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

After watching Star Trek again, I am convinced that Chris Pine is the best candidate for playing Steve Rogers/Captain America.

yeah well people also want him to play Hall Jordan. Personally I think he's too small to play Steve Rogers.

Pine's already playing Thor. He can't play both. Sorry.

dang, pine is really popular in the superhero world lol.

Pine would be cool as CA, but i guess he'd do a good Thor aswell, Jensen Ackles would be my pick for CA though.

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
yeah well people also want him to play Hall Jordan. Personally I think he's too small to play Steve Rogers.


he is too small to play Steve Rogers/Cap, but prolly just right for Hal Jordan

Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
Pine's already playing Thor. He can't play both. Sorry.

No he's not. Chris Hemsworth is.

As for Chris Pine for Captain America, yeah I'd be cool with that. Really dug him in Star Trek.

Originally posted by SnakeEyes
No he's not. Chris Hemsworth is.

As for Chris Pine for Captain America, yeah I'd be cool with that. Really dug him in Star Trek.


Ohhhhh yeah!!! My bad. (egg on my face)

Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
Pine's already playing Thor. He can't play both. Sorry.

Actually Chris Hemsworth is playing Thor. Not Chris Pine, Chris Hemsworth played George Kirk, Captain Kirk's father.

My pick lives on!!!!! HA!

I'll probably get picked on for this, but since I can't think of anybody better, John Cena.

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
I'll probably get picked on for this, but since I can't think of anybody better, John Cena.


Don't laugh , there has been talk about Cena

lol well he would definately look the part.

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
lol well he would definately look the part.

well I thought about HHH for Thor - only because he looks the part.

NO WRESTLERS. I can't make that clear enough. People don't want fvckin terrible "actors" like John Cena or HHH playing these iconic characters. Who cares if they've got big muscles, big deal. Quality acting is so much more superior to a ripped physique it's not even debatable.

Originally posted by SnakeEyes
NO WRESTLERS. I can't make that clear enough. People don't want fvckin terrible "actors" like John Cena or HHH playing these iconic characters. Who cares if they've got big muscles, big deal. Quality acting is so much more superior to a ripped physique it's not even debatable.

I totally agree, however I was just stating that HHH looks the part. They've already pick the actor for Thor. I really doubt the Hollywood would give a lead role to major franchise like Captain America or Thor.

if John Cena was Captain America, I would be pissed.

Actually, Matthew McConaughey would be good.

Originally posted by jcvaldez
well I thought about HHH for Thor - only because he looks the part.


HHH did try out for Thor..


Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
Actually, Matthew McConaughey would be good.


His voice stinks.. He talks the same exact way in every film.. I don't want to hear Steve Rogers/Cap talk with a mouth full of mush

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker

His voice stinks.. He talks the same exact way in every film.. I don't want to hear Steve Rogers/Cap talk with a mouth full of mush

Hahahaha!!! Good point.

Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
Actually, Matthew McConaughey would be good.

No

I gotta say I'd never believed this but after seeing how well Pine pulled off Shatner's Kirk in Star Trek, I'd say he could totally be perfect as Cap!

Originally posted by Entity
I gotta say I'd never believed this but after seeing how well Pine pulled off Shatner's Kirk in Star Trek, I'd say he could totally be perfect as Cap!

That's what I'm saying!

I say...NO WAY...for Chris Pine to play Cap.....i just dont see it...i was not impressed with his performance and/or his talent...... they might as well put Jon Cena in the suit...i have seen his movies...and he is as good as Pine i.m.o...but i say none of them should play cap......though i dont have a better choice......a while back(when Troy was released) people clamoured for Brad Pitt to play him....i guess that might work

John Cena's as good of an actor as Chris Pine? Get your head out of your ass.

Originally posted by SnakeEyes
John Cena's as good of an actor as Chris Pine? Get your head out of your ass.

I agree! Chris Pine is great! John Cena sucks. Chris Pine did a wonderful job in Star Trek. He carried the movie on his shoulders.

Originally posted by SnakeEyes
John Cena's as good of an actor as Chris Pine? Get your head out of your ass.

Wow...such maturity..just grow up!..lets just disagree then.....Chris pine is as wooden an actor as i have ever seen....i.m.o.....i think it would be a disaster.....he was the worst of the bunch in the new star trek.

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/LetsCutTheBS/news/?a=7994
Looks like Steve Rogers is coming back in time for the movie.

What about Kevin Sorbo for Thor?

Originally posted by starlock
Wow...such maturity..just grow up!..lets just disagree then.....Chris pine is as wooden an actor as i have ever seen....i.m.o.....i think it would be a disaster.....he was the worst of the bunch in the new star trek.

Were you watching the same film? It's fine if you don't like Chris Pine, but he was anything but wooden. When I think wooden, I think Keanu Reeves/similar actors, but Pine was pretty damn charismatic throughout the whole film. Wooden is actually the worst word I can think of to describe his perormance. Like I said, it's cool if you don't like the guy's acting, but at least use an accurate word to describe it.

Chris Pine's a great choice for Captain America, but I say Mark Valley is still the ideal choice.

Originally posted by frommd
http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/LetsCutTheBS/news/?a=7994
Looks like Steve Rogers is coming back in time for the movie.

I KNEW IT!!!! HA!

Originally posted by SnakeEyes
Were you watching the same film? It's fine if you don't like Chris Pine, but he was anything but wooden. When I think wooden, I think Keanu Reeves/similar actors, but Pine was pretty damn charismatic throughout the whole film. Wooden is actually the worst word I can think of to describe his perormance. Like I said, it's cool if you don't like the guy's acting, but at least use an accurate word to describe it.

I completely agree, Chris Pine did a wonderful job carrying Star Trek. He made the movie interesting and I know he'll (if he's picked) do a great job.

I find it interesting that people are complaining about his size. I don't know he looks fit and in good shape. He may be a little short, but so was Robert Downey Jr. as Iron and Christian Bale as Batman, even worse Michael Keaton as Batman.

In the end it's all about the acting, and Chris Pine would be perfect!

not bad actually. he's got the hieght, the looks too. if he buffs up a little more he'd be great actually.

~Sado

Originally posted by Sado22
not bad actually. he's got the hieght, the looks too. if he buffs up a little more he'd be great actually.

~Sado

He's a B list actor and is 50 years old.

Matthew McConaughey is still my pick.

Originally posted by The Nuul
Matthew McConaughey is still my pick.

really? country accent and all? No I don't agree.

Originally posted by Warrior18
He's a B list actor and is 50 years old.
Originally posted by The Nuul
Matthew McConaughey is still my pick.

I am sure he can act without his hick accent.

Originally posted by SnakeEyes

Originally posted by The Nuul
I am sure he can act without his hick accent.


he hasn't been able to yet

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
I'll probably get picked on for this, but since I can't think of anybody better, John Cena.

who else has the military look other than Govenor Swartziwhateveritis?

or how about Mark Wahlberg?

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
who else has the military look other than Govenor Swartziwhateveritis?

what?! No! Chris Pine is the best choice

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
or how about Mark Wahlberg?

say hi to your mother for me...

The reason why I think about Mark Wahlberg is because I just saw him in Renasonce Man and at first I thought he was a younger John Cena. THEN I thought, he could be Captain America if he had the same look.

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
or how about Mark Wahlberg?

interesting choice.. he could work

Mark Wahlberg? Are we being serious here?

You're sure?

Have you seen any of the man's movies? Max Payne? He couldn't act if you told him that it'd give Earth a cure for cancer.

That we know of; John Barrowman. Easy.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Mark Wahlberg? Are we being serious here?

You're sure?

Have you seen any of the man's movies? Max Payne? He couldn't act if you told him that it'd give Earth a cure for cancer.

That we know of; John Barrowman. Easy.

-AC


I am very sure.. I m not basing anything off of past performances.. If the studio decides to hire him and give this film a good script, it could work..


what makes you think John Barrowman will work?? Isn't he like 50 years old?? Besides this isn't Doctor Who, Barrowman works well on the tv screen, the movie screen is totally different

Originally posted by jcvaldez
what?! No! Chris Pine is the best choice As of right now I'd have to agree. Probably needs a bigger build but get him in the gym with a trainer and he'd do fine IMO.

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
I am very sure.. I m not basing anything off of past performances.. If the studio decides to hire him and give this film a good script, it could work..


what makes you think John Barrowman will work?? Isn't he like 50 years old?? Besides this isn't Doctor Who, Barrowman works well on the tv screen, the movie screen is totally different

He's 10 times the actor Mark Wahlberg could dream of being. He has a chiselled look, very heroic.

At least John Barrowman works well on something, as opposed to Mark Wahlberg.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
He's 10 times the actor Mark Wahlberg could dream of being. He has a chiselled look, very heroic.

At least John Barrowman works well on something, as opposed to Mark Wahlberg.

-AC



yeah, but will he actually translate to such a role??? Anyway I doubt the studio will hire a 50 year old to portray a 20 year old...

Originally posted by Darth Martin
As of right now I'd have to agree. Probably needs a bigger build but get him in the gym with a trainer and he'd do fine IMO.


Pine would definitely work as well..

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
yeah, but will he actually translate to such a role??? Anyway I doubt the studio will hire a 50 year old to portray a 20 year old...

I doubt they'd hire someone who can't act for sh*t, too.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
I doubt they'd hire someone who can't act for sh*t, too. Who are you referring to? Walhberg?

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
I doubt they'd hire someone who can't act for sh*t, too.

-AC



you never know since studios will hire their best choice for who they feel will be suited for the role

Walhberg isn't a bad actor at all. I thought he was excellent in Boogie Nights and The Departed, but he's not Captain America.

Wahlberg was excellent in The Departed.

He was just supported well by many more great actors.

Generally, he's a shitty actor.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
He was just supported well by many more great actors.

Generally, he's a shitty actor.

-AC I don't know about that. To me he just doesn't seem to care most of the time and puts in half arsed efforts. It was only a small role, but to me his performance in The Departed stood out even with quality all around him.

I just think he'd have the best look. (Mark I mean.) Cap is a guy who is from the ww2 era suddenly placed in the 21st century. I think Mark could capture that as well.

The guy from Troy that played Hector should be CA. They just have to dye his hair.

Walhberg whould make a shit CAP. Departed was his best role other than that he cant act.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
The guy from Troy that played Hector should be CA. They just have to dye his hair.


eric bana...fascinating

Doesnt have the look.

It needs to be a guy who can pull off the whole " I'm from the WWII era " thing. Acts really old fashioned, but can whoop butt all the same.

Eric Bana is a good actor but too old. How about Channing Tatum?

Channing Tatum? who's he? I will stick to Mark Wahlberg for now until I see somebody better.

How about Ben Mckenzie? add more muscle and weight to him.

http://www.mtv.com/movies/photos/i/incredible_hulk_premiere_080609/08_ben_mckenzie.jpg

Originally posted by The Nuul
How about Ben Mckenzie? add more muscle and weight to him.

http://www.mtv.com/movies/photos/i/incredible_hulk_premiere_080609/08_ben_mckenzie.jpg

Hell no!

Originally posted by The Nuul
How about Ben Mckenzie? add more muscle and weight to him.
huh....that's a thought. might be an option if, like u said, he added some serious muscle and weight.

http://www.mtv.com/movies/photos/i/incredible_hulk_premiere_080609/08_ben_mckenzie.jpg

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
eric bana...fascinating

and yet...totally ridiculous??

Originally posted by Juk3n
and yet...totally ridiculous??

yes it is..


another choice could be sam witwer or sam worthington

Originally posted by PRAYERRUN
Channing Tatum? who's he? He was in Fighting and will appear in G.I. Joe film. And hell no to Wahlberg.

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
another choice could be sam worthington He was good in TS. But by god he'd have to get in the gym.

Louis Leterrier Talks Captain America, Avengers
Source:Los Angeles Times
August 10, 2009


The Los Angeles Times recently spoke to The Incredible Hulk director Louis Leterrier and got quotes about what he's seen of The First Avenger: Captain America and his dream for The Avengers. Here are several clips from the article:

LL: ...I have seen some of the design work they’re doing for Captain America and it looks amazing. It’s a period piece and it’s like “Raiders of the Lost Ark” and with more gadgets...

GB: Well that makes sense, I know Feige and his team turned to Joe Johnston because of his art direction work on “Raiders” and the fact that he directed “The Rocketeer.”

LL: Yes, exactly, so it’s “Raiders” meets "Rocketeer” and “Saving Private Ryan.” It’s going to be so cool.

LL: ...You know, you asked about my dream, I’ll tell you my real dream: To work with Joe Johnston and Kenneth Branagh and Jon Favreau and make like a triptych. We do four movies. We release them one a month for the summer. Or even every two weeks or three weeks. And the whole summer would be Avengers summer. So we do it the way they make television shows. One story arc but told in installments by different directors. So all of the directors that touch part of the Avengers world would do a part; we could make the movies shorter, maybe less than an hour and a half, and we use the same sets and save Marvel money. I would love to sit around a table with all of them a kick around the story. That’s my dream.


http://www.superherohype.com/news/captainamericanews.php?id=8601

Originally posted by Darth Martin
He was in Fighting and will appear in G.I. Joe film. And hell no to Wahlberg.

He was good in TS. But by god he'd have to get in the gym.

true, most likely whoever they get will have too

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Eric Bana is a good actor but too old. How about Channing Tatum?

The guy couldn't act in G.I. Joe. I don't think a role this big is for him.

-AC

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Eric Bana is a good actor but too old. How about Channing Tatum?


Channing Tatum , if he gained weight and worked out, he could make a good Captain America

Nah, I change my mind. He would look the part, yes, but I agree with AC. His acting sucked balls in G.I. Joe.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Nah, I change my mind. He would look the part, yes, but I agree with AC. His acting sucked balls in G.I. Joe.


well that really doesn't matter.. The only thing matters is what the film studio thinks

Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
Actually, Matthew McConaughey would be good.

That could work to be honest.

Originally posted by DarthLazious
That could work to be honest.

Not his voice

Naw. not him lol.