Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

List your top five comic book characters, not limited to Marvel or DC.

After say, a month or two, I will tally up which characters get the most mentions.

Hopefully this simple idea will leave us with a better idea as to who the most popular one is, on average. Maybe the top five most popular by mention.

Disclaimer: No joint decisions. "I can't decide, my top two are Batman/Superman.". For the sake of accuracy, please separate them. If you cannot do this, then please leave the thread to those who can, as it will mess up the tallying.

Doesn't have to be in order, just the five you enjoy most (Or less than five if you haven't got many. List as many, up to five, as you like).

Try to keep it simple, no "I like so and so because...". Just list the names and try to keep it concrete. If people keep coming back and editing their lists, that too will balls up the tallying.

Thanks for your co-operation, to quote Robocop.

Mine:

Deadpool, Surfer, Hulk, Iron Man, Ghost Rider.

-AC

in no particular order..

solar
firestorm
swamp thing
all-star superman
mxy

Depends on the Writer and Artist.

Thor
GL Hal
Cap
Punisher
Sinestro

Batman
Scott Pilgrim
Invincible
John Constantine
King Mob

Superman
Hal
Thor
All Star Superman
MM

1. Adam Warlock
2. Silver Surfer
3. He-Man
4. Captain America
5. Superman

Batman
Captain America
Daredevil
Punisher
Deathstroke

Just gonna say, will leave this up for just over a month.

Get a mod to close it on Sept 15th or so. That should give enough people time to comment.

That, or I'll get it closed whenever it's lost steam.

Again, thanks to those who have posted within the criteria of the thread. If this turns out as big and fun as I hope it will, then it'll save me a lot of trouble if I don't have to filter through pages of spam to find peoples' lists.

Good job guys.

-AC

In no particular order.

Joker
Batman
Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk

Kitty Pryde
Wolverine
Batman
Superman
Juggernaut

Charon
Qztr
Great Evil Beast
Daredevil
Swamp Thing

Spider-man
Batman
Daredevil
Ult Captain America
Wolverine

Cyclops
Superman
Colossus
Flash Wally West
GL Hal Jordan

Deadpool
Batman
Lobo
Hulk
Punisher

Batman
Joker
Lucifer
Magneto
Superman

Spider-Man
The Tick
The Doctor (Wildstorm)
Death's Head II
Alan Scott

The Mighty
Irredeemable
Majestic
Invincible
Wolverine(Daken)

Silver Surfer
Hulk
Galactus
Thanos
Wolverine

In no order

Black Adam
Dr Strange
Thanos
Deadpool
Captain Britain

Batman
Spider-Man
Wolverine
The Joker
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Spider-Man
Wolverine
Batman
Harley Quinn
Superman

Originally posted by tjcoady
Scott Pilgrim very nice pick.

sadly, i doubt he'll get any more votes.

I was tempted to vote for Scott, but he just didn't make it

Martian Manhunter
Jason Todd
Jack Horner
Tim drake
Deadpool

Originally posted by Galan007
very nice pick.

sadly, i doubt he'll get any more votes.

It was a coin flip between him, Casanova, and Doc Strange.

None of who are going to rank very highly here

SBP
doomsday
KAL-EL
Colossus
slade

Thanos
Galactus
Black Adam
Silver Surfer
Doctor Doom

Thor
Wally West the Flash
Magneto
Deadpool
Black Adam

haven't been here in awhile

I think that later people are going to start remembering other companies after they voted. Like I did off the spot, now it's going to be a bit challenging, gotta put Leo from the TMNT in there. Supergirl has to go.

Flash
Spiderman
Leonardo
IronMan
Ryu (SF)

Taskmaster
V
Molecule Man
Firelord
Galactus

C-Master: Then I'll say one edit per person.

-AC

Superman
Star-Lord
Darkseid
Nameless
Iboga

Wolverine
Spider-man
Night Crawler
Tigra (Thunder Cats)
Dum Dum Dugan( Yea I said it)


Flash

Ghost Rider
Punisher
Wolverine
Batman
Hellboy

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Wolverine
Spider-man
Night Crawler
Tigra (Thunder Cats)
Dum Dum Dugan( Yea I said it)


Flash

That's six. I'll just count the five.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
That's six. I'll just count the five.

-AC
I know, but I simply had to make it known Flash just barely missed the list.



-BH

1. Multiple Man
2. Deadpool
3. Green Arrow
4. Mitchell Hundred
5. Nick Fury

Steve Rogers
Bucky Barnes
Moon Knight
Deadshot
Johnny Blaze

Wolverine
Raphael
Spiderman
Captain America
Nightcrawler

Captain America
Batman (Almost number 1)
Punisher
The Maxx
WWH

Sometimes im not sure if I like my first three more but for different reasons.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Wolverine
Spider-man
Night Crawler
Tigra (Thunder Cats)
Dum Dum Dugan( Yea I said it)


Flash
Interesting.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Dum Dum Dugan( Yea I said it)

Wow. I'm impressed by such an obscure choice. You must be loving Secret Warriors at the moment

Originally posted by willRules
Wow. I'm impressed by such an obscure choice. You must be loving Secret Warriors at the moment
Thanks.



Hell yes, it my favorite run at the moment. I think the writing great, it has some awosome villains and of course it has my man Dum Dum Dugan with some great moments, like when he on the helicopter with the rocket launcher

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Thanks.



Hell yes, it my favorite run at the moment. I think the writing great, it has some awosome villains and of course it has my man Dum Dum Dugan with some great moments, like when he on the helicopter with the rocket launcher

Yeah it's been good. Still think the first issue was my favourite though. It was the first comic I've read that felt like the bonus material at the back actually served to enhance my enjoyment of the overall storyline.

Originally posted by willRules
Yeah it's been good. Still think the first issue was my favourite though. It was the first comic I've read that felt like the bonus material at the back actually served to enhance my enjoyment of the overall storyline.

Yea I liked that issue. my favorite was the attack on Hammer.


I like that it has new characters, so that new readers/as well as old can see the development of new characters. I also like the idea of bring back kick ass villain ike Gorgon and using old well known characters like Nick Fury, but also using old less known characters like Dum Dum Dugan and other memebers of the Howling Commando's.

martain manhunter
Marvels(since i can't say CM & BA, i like the group of charecters and think tehys houdl get much more spotlight)
superboy conner
ult spiderman
hulk

This isn't a Secret Warriors thread.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
This isn't a Secret Warriors thread.

-AC

That is true, my apologies on derailing the thread.


-BH

No worries.

-AC

Apologies

Here's the Secret Warrior's thread for anyone who is interested......

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=502545

1-Galactus
2-Deadpool
3-Wolverine
4-Joker
5-Batman

Xman
GL Kyle/Ion
Quasar/Wendell
Superman
Nightwing/Dick Grayson

Ms. Marvel
Super Girl (Kara)
Rogue
Flaming Torch
Deathstroke

Hmmm, nice thread, really can't decide between Batman or Superman.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Yea I liked that issue. my favorite was the attack on Hammer.


I like that it has new characters, so that new readers/as well as old can see the development of new characters. I also like the idea of bring back kick ass villain ike Gorgon and using old well known characters like Nick Fury, but also using old less known characters like Dum Dum Dugan and other memebers of the Howling Commando's.

Indeed good issue. Which new character was your favorite?

Boy Blue
Yorick Brown
Plastic Man
Agent 355
Mitchell Hundred

Odin
Hulk
Invisible Woman
Gambit
Hitman

Jack Knight
The Shade
Dr. Doom
Thor
Dr. Manhattan

Chase Stein
Loki
Thor
Kid Omega
Maximus

Originally posted by Doctor-Alvis
Jack Knight
The Shade
Dr. Doom
Thor
Dr. Manhattan

How can you like Doc Manhattan? He's not as strong as Thor or Surfer!!! zomghatehatehate.

Seriously though, good picks.

Adam Warlock
Silver Surfer
Dr. Strange
Ghost Rider
Thor

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Chase Stein
Loki
Thor
Kid Omega
Maximus

I actually need to chip Lucifer, Guy Gardner and Starlord in. They all tie.

Originally posted by Doctor-Alvis
Jack Knight
The Shade
Ooh... good picks. mmm

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I actually need to chip Lucifer, Guy Gardner and Starlord in. They all tie.

Why was this: "No joint decisions. 'I can't decide, my top two are Batman/Superman.'. For the sake of accuracy, please separate them. If you cannot do this, then please leave the thread to those who can, as it will mess up the tallying." not clear enough?

There's one edit each, so either remove one from your list and replace with one of the above, or I'll count it as it is.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Why was this: "No joint decisions. 'I can't decide, my top two are Batman/Superman.'. For the sake of accuracy, please separate them. If you cannot do this, then please leave the thread to those who can, as it will mess up the tallying." not clear enough?

There's one edit each, so either remove one from your list and replace with one of the above, or I'll count it as it is.

-AC

I'll roll the dice, 8 it is.

Ok, so I'll just count your first list.

-AC

Rorschach (I can't spell it, the guy with the mask)
Gambit
Wolverine
V (for Vendetta)
Kitty Pryde

Closely missing out was the Comedian, but I know I already got 5

Daredevil
Iron Man
Punisher
Wolverine

Hmm this is difficult Im probably gonna disagree with myself in a few days but here goes

In no particular order

Juggernaut
Green Lantern
Black Adam
Thor
Darkseid

Magneto
Xavier
Jean Grey
Proteus
Vulcan

Superman
Static
Blade
Rorschach
Surge

Green Arrow
Captain Atom
Superman
Nightcrawler
Joker