Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Ash, one of the best Pokemon Trainers

VS

Gary, who easily defeated Ash's Pikachu with his Electivire despite becoming a full-time Pokemon Breeder

VS

Ritchie, a Pokemon Trainer just as good as Ash



Who is the greatest Pokemon Master?

Depends, does Ash have to use his current line-up? Or can he pick from any that he has caught? Or do they all just get random pokemon to see who can battle best with different pokemon?

Though Ash is cooler so he automatically wins anyway.

Cooler than Gary? Nonsense.

Does Gary have a prophecy about him? Nope. Has Gary met and befriended any legendaries? Nope. Does Gary's grandpa like him better? Nope.

But yea I haven't seen Gary since Hoen started I do believe and only watched the Electivire vs Pikachu battle on youtube never seen the episode.....and he always sorta annoyed me.

Originally posted by Kento
Does Gary have a prophecy about him? Nope. Has Gary met and befriended any legendaries? Nope. Does Gary's grandpa like him better? Nope.

But yea I haven't seen Gary since Hoen started I do believe and only watched the Electivire vs Pikachu battle on youtube never seen the episode.....and he always sorta annoyed me.
The episode was after the Battle Frontier saga, which was after the Hoenn saga.

Ash went all the way back to Kanto in Pallet Town, and had a friendly fight against Gary, who became a Pokemon Researcher (NOT Breeder) and no longer a Trainer after being defeated by Ash in the Johto League.
Despite being a full-time researcher, he easily beats Ash's Pikachu... an insane feat for Gary since Ash should have the edge spending all his time battling trainers in Hoenn and Battle Frontier.
I believe he would have become better than Ash if he didn't quit training.

Did it specifically say he stropped training? He obviously got new pokemon. Didn't Gary leave all but Umbreon..or was it Arcanine..at the end of Johto/start of Hoen which is why Ash just took Pikachu?

Gary beats that ass.

Gary toys with ash. his eevee beat ash's pikachu.

Originally posted by Kento
Did it specifically say he stropped training? He obviously got new pokemon. Didn't Gary leave all but Umbreon..or was it Arcanine..at the end of Johto/start of Hoen which is why Ash just took Pikachu?
Not necessarily, but it is logical that he spends more time in research work now than training.
And being able to defeat Ash after all that Ash has gone through is quite surprising.

Does Ash get Charizard?

gary has blastoise.

Charizard has already beaten a Blastoise. Gary's not cool enough to beat Charizard.

I'm going to say A.J. and his HaxxShrew.

"I'm gonna be a PO-KAYMON Master!"

Originally posted by Kento
Charizard has already beaten a Blastoise. Gary's not cool enough to beat Charizard.

How is Gary not cool enough? He has his own fanclub.

Gary mother****ing oak

Originally posted by Kero_Co
I'm going to say A.J. and his HaxxShrew.

"I'm gonna be a PO-KAYMON Master!"
Oh yeah. Almost forgot about him..

I think he would probably beat any of the chumps in this thread.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
How is Gary not cool enough? He has his own fanclub. Having a fan club doesn't make him cool. Least not cool enough to beat Charizard.

Against the rules, closed.