Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

thor fights captain marvel from dc who wins

Originally posted by HallaOfValhala
thor fights captain marvel from dc who wins

If Thor is able to forcibly cause Marvel to revert to Billy, he WTFPWNs. Outside of that, Thor still stands a good chance against him.

thor 6/10

captain marvel got a much better showings and fight record of wins then thor

really?

yep thor lose most of his fights unless he throws mjolnir

Thor recently got owned by norman osborn and the rest of his crew not to mention speedblitzed by sentry and again i mean norman osborn owned him

not that it has to be mentioned but just one of the Ufoes was turning Hulk into a skeleton and thor was unharmed by the combined attack of him, Vector and Osborn and all this after he got hurt by Sentry

50-50

Captain Marvel is my man, but you gotta give it to Thor 7/10. Without mjolnir C.M. wins 6/10

Originally posted by Warlord
not that it has to be mentioned but just one of the Ufoes was turning Hulk into a skeleton and thor was unharmed by the combined attack of him, Vector and Osborn and all this after he got hurt by Sentry

no one ever said he doesnt have durability but what i am saying is that thor is one crappy fighter , osborn alone with a single punch took him down and was beating him and after that his crew came and beat the hell out of thor he is one crappy fighter

Originally posted by HallaOfValhala
no one ever said he doesnt have durability but what i am saying is that thor is one crappy fighter , osborn alone with a single punch took him down and was beating him and after that his crew came and beat the hell out of thor he is one crappy fighter

ok then make a Iron Patriot vs Thor thread to be more even...

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
50-50

Without Mjolnir, Captain Marvel wins.

With Mjolnir, Thor wins


You have to consider the fact that most of Thor's best feats are with him using Mjolnir, with the exception of RKT.

A lot of those attacks, Cap would be immune to and or be able to stand up to. Except for the God blast. Transmutation, magic, and blunt force, Cap has withstood time and time again. Especially magic.

Thor wins.Originally posted by HallaOfValhala
no one ever said he doesnt have durability but what i am saying is that thor is one crappy fighter , osborn alone with a single punch took him down and was beating him and after that his crew came and beat the hell out of thor he is one crappy fighter I really hope for your sake you aren't serious.

CM wins. CM has a nice advantage in Durability against magic.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
CM wins. CM has a nice advantage in Durability against magic. The hammer will still hurt him whether he's durable or not.

Captain marvel

Originally posted by quanchi112
The hammer will still hurt him whether he's durable or not.
Hurt? why not, but his durability is like Superman's, but just better with Magic. Much better

Originally posted by xJLxKing
Hurt? why not, but his durability is like Superman's, but just better with Magic. Much better He still isn't immune. He just doesn't have the weakness Superman has. That being said Thor is a lot more powerful and will put him in a coma if he loses his temper.

there is an IF
I ain't changing my opinion. Thor doesn't have speed blitz and his strength, and durability is comparable. I give it to CM because of his high resistance to Magic

Originally posted by xJLxKing
there is an IF
I ain't changing my opinion. Thor doesn't have speed blitz and his strength, and durability is comparable. I give it to CM because of his high resistance to Magic Do you really think Marvel can resist more than Galactus? Galactus felt pain when he Thor struck him. Marvel doesn't have anywhere near the combat feats or durability showings to suggest he can take the hammer to the domepiece.

With Mjolner: Thor 7/10 (though CM makes him work for it, hard)
Without Mjolner: Captain Marvel 7/10, due to speed and movement abilities, though Thor will likewise make him work like a ***** for it...

Lol thor got owned by iron patriot and trashed by his crew he is going down

Originally posted by HallaOfValhala
captain marvel got a much better showings and fight record of wins then thor

No He Does Not.
This would be a great fight, but if Billy truly can be reverted back to mortal form by Thor's lighting, it's basically over then & there.

Originally posted by HallaOfValhala
Lol thor got owned by iron patriot and trashed by his crew he is going down



Are you Peterlame?

Originally posted by JakeTheBank


Are you Peterlame?

are you a thor fanboy?

Nah.

It just seems funny that you're singling out one low showing of Thor against someone who he has previously dismissed with ease, let alone against someone who he has previously demolished that is overall >>> than said character (referring to Iron Patriot).

Originally posted by roughrider
No He Does Not.
This would be a great fight, but if Billy truly can be reverted back to mortal form by Thor's lighting, it's basically over then & there.

(Just using your quote to link with what I am referring to)

Now see, I don't go on the bandwagon that Thor's lightning could cause Billy to revert; that's just PIS, and unrelated in terms of power sources/ specific effects. It's just redonkulous, especially in a forum fight.

Just saying...

Originally posted by tideoftime
(Just using your quote to link with what I am referring to)

Now see, I don't go on the bandwagon that Thor's lightning could cause Billy to revert; that's just PIS, and unrelated in terms of power sources/ specific effects. It's just redonkulous, especially in a forum fight.

Just saying...

Lightning, especially magical lightning, has been shown to depower Marvels before though.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Nah.

It just seems funny that you're singling out one low showing of Thor against someone who he has previously dismissed with ease, let alone against someone who he has previously demolished that is overall >>> than said character (referring to Iron Patriot).

whats so funny about an on panel proof? its not a low showing iron patriot is a class 100 character, rulk too thor out, hercules too thor out,a giant doombot took thor out recently all thor does is getting his ass handed to him so thats not a low showing

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Lightning, especially magical lightning, has been shown to depower Marvels before though.
NO! Only certain magic lighting. Thor doesn't have magical lighting. He just controls magic

Originally posted by HallaOfValhala
whats so funny about an on panel proof? its not a low showing iron patriot is a class 100 character, rulk too thor out, hercules too thor out,a giant doombot took thor out recently all thor does is getting his ass handed to him so thats not a low showing

And yet, you clearly refuse to look into context.

Rulk, first and foremost, is one of the most PIS riddled characters in comicdom. Most people will agree with this. Also, Thor returned the favor and then some, making Rulk admit that Thor was about to kill him.

Hercules and Thor routinely stalemate each other, and any given comic can have one put decisively over the other.

Giant Doombot = Destroyer Armor which is to be expected. I mean, its only a weapon designed by Odin to fight Celestials.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
NO! Only certain magic lighting. Thor doesn't have magical lighting. He just controls magic

...Thor commands all aspects of lightning and the storm. Mundane lightning like you see everyday, amplified lightning, temporal and cosmic storms, and lightning of mystical nature. Besides, I never said it was a surefire thing if you look at my previous post. All I'm saying is that it's certainly not out of the question.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
And yet, you clearly refuse to look into context.

Rulk, first and foremost, is one of the most PIS riddled characters in comicdom. Most people will agree with this. Also, Thor returned the favor and then some, making Rulk admit that Thor was about to kill him.

Hercules and Thor routinely stalemate each other, and any given comic can have one put decisively over the other.

Giant Doombot = Destroyer Armor which is to be expected. I mean, its only a weapon designed by Odin to fight Celestials.

its just amazing how everytime thor gets his ass handed to him its either a PIS or a low showing... perhaps you show me some of his good showings? and not the ones about 20-30 years ago of hiw winning with majolnir Lol

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Lightning, especially magical lightning, has been shown to depower Marvels before though.

A point of PIS/story-specific incidences, and I generally agree with xJLxKing's statement (though I have to say I would classify Thor's conjuring lightning out of nowhere, for example, as "magical lightning", though not Shazam's lighting effect, in this context).

cap might be able to depower thor sence he has zeus lightning. (zeus has done it before)

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
cap might be able to depower thor sence he has zeus lightning. (zeus has done it before)

If CM is smart, he won't try saying the Wizard's name in a fight with a guy who can control lightning and thunder.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
If CM is smart, he won't try saying the Wizard's name in a fight with a guy who can control lightning and thunder.
What? You do understand that the lighting that CM calls upon is actually a spell indisguice?


He might be able to control weather, but he ain't controlling CM's Spell.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
What? You do understand that the lighting that CM calls upon is actually a spell indisguice?


He might be able to control weather, but he ain't controlling CM's Spell.

Why wouldn't he? Other beings have manipulated the lightning before, both in positive and negative ways. The lightning is the fuel which triggers his transformation and has been shown not to be all powerful. Lightning is lightning regardless of the source. I can agree that it wouldn't be likely for Thor to conviently channel a bolt of lightning to CM transforming him into Billy (though I wouldn't put it completely past Thor to be capable of this), but to argue that Thor cannot divert the lightning from its path or even absorb it into Mjolnir itself seems short sighted.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Why wouldn't he? Other beings have manipulated the lightning before, both in positive and negative ways. The lightning is the fuel which triggers his transformation and has been shown not to be all powerful. Lightning is lightning regardless of the source. I can agree that it wouldn't be likely for Thor to conviently channel a bolt of lightning to CM transforming him into Billy (though I wouldn't put it completely past Thor to be capable of this), but to argue that Thor cannot divert the lightning from its path or even absorb it into Mjolnir itself seems short sighted.

Now, *that* I can agree with. If for whatever reason Billy/CM was saying "Shazam", and the boom came, it is not at all inconceivable that Thor (via Mjolner), could manipulate, deflect, absorb, what-have-you, the lightning/magic of the effect; I don't, however, see that as being an issue in a typical forum-fight -- it would be more of a plot point in a cross-over story, having more to do with the story at hand than any combat applications involved, as such.

Originally posted by tideoftime
Now, *that* I can agree with. If for whatever reason Billy/CM was saying "Shazam", and the boom came, it is not at all inconceivable that Thor (via Mjolner), could manipulate, deflect, absorb, what-have-you, the lightning/magic of the effect; I don't, however, see that as being an issue in a typical forum-fight -- it would be more of a plot point in a cross-over story, having more to do with the story at hand than any combat applications involved, as such.

True. There would be no reason for CM to shout "Shazam" in the first place against Thor, so it would be a huge mistake if he did. And while CM is highly durable against magic, yes, so is Thor. And both combatants have more to work with than just magic. But while Captain Marvel is limited to just blunt force, Thor's versatility and skill factor puts him over the Big Red Cheese.