Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Strange forces are at work worlds have begun to change. Two Gothams have begun to merge. In one Batman disapears, but he does not leave Gotham with out a protecter as Robin remains. The Batman from the other Gotham remains and has discovered that the Batman from the other Gotham may be a killer and goes to stop him and his cohorts. Robin here's some nutjob pretending to be Batman is out to get him and decides to stop said nutjob first.

So

Round 1
Is a turf war. Both Bale Batman and O'Donnel Robin get their assets and alies. In other words each gets the contents of his Batcave. Help from his Alfred etc. We will even front Bale Batman his Wayne manor and limited police support as Robin will be getting the same. For the sake of this debate Robin will be the inherited head of the Wayne estate of his reality including bussiness holdings.

Round 2
Is a random roof top encounter with each packing his normal gadgets.

Round 3
Is melee combat. Imagine their villians have teamed up captured them and are forcing them to fight in an arena. Neither will kill under the circumstances. Robin is armed with a staff and Batman has a sword. This is a plain clothes afair. Both are dressed in work out clothes.

Round 4
Similiar to above accept. No weapons.

1: Robin. Anthalogy Batcave had more......stuff....And Robin's fight in the alley versus the thugs was uberesque.

2. Not sure.

3. Batman.

4. Robin.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
1: Robin. Anthalogy Batcave had more......stuff....And Robin's fight in the alley versus the thugs was uberesque.

2. Not sure.

3. Batman.

4. Robin.

So let me get this straight you think Anthology Batman would lose to Baleman? As evidenced by your reactions/comments in the Baleman vs Storm Shadow thread, but you think Anthology Robin could take out Baleman?

Originally posted by Nightstick
So let me get this straight you think Anthology Batman would lose to Baleman? As evidenced by your reactions/comments in the Baleman vs Storm Shadow thread, but you think Anthology Robin could take out Baleman?

In scenario one and four? Yes.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
In scenario one and four? Yes.

So are you of the belief that O'Donnel Robin could take Anthology Batman in a straight h2h2 fight.

Originally posted by Nightstick
So are you of the belief that O'Donnel Robin could take Anthology Batman in a straight h2h2 fight. Well, I am of the belief that Robin is faster than both Batmen. He took on the painted face goons in the alley with no armor and pwned them. Both Batmen are stronger and obviously will bust Robin up hella bad if they get ahold of him.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Both Batmen are stronger and obviously will bust Robin up hella bad if they get ahold of him.

Clooney Batman will only bust up his anus.

That's a given, Rob.