Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Superman from Superman Returns played by Brandon Routh vs Silver Surfer from Fantastic Four: Rise of The Silver Surfer played by Doug Jones.

movie superman wins. all he has to do is break the board in half and thats it. cause movie surfer gets his powers from the board.

comic surfer owns comic superman

Superman

Originally posted by chomperx9
movie superman wins. all he has to do is break the board in half and thats it. cause movie surfer gets his powers from the board.

comic surfer owns comic superman

qft

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
qft qft ?

movie Surfer sucked a lot and.... well, Superman from Superman Returns fought the effects of Kryptonite really impressively.

I'd say 6/10 to Superman. Surfer is powerful enough to beat him given the kind of shit he was doing to the Earth (with supreme ease) and given the speed advantage (film Superman was quite slow in comparison) but, Surfer was stupid and could be removed from his board...

Surfer could only be removed from his board by a pulse of a specific frequency designed by Reed Richards. Superman won't be separating the Surfer from his board.

Surfer takes this IMO. He can go intangible, so Superman can't even hit him. He could probably kill Superman the way Dr Doom killed Susan when he had the Power Cosmic.

Originally posted by Placidity
Surfer could only be removed from his board by a pulse of a specific frequency designed by Reed Richards. Superman won't be separating the Surfer from his board.

Surfer takes this IMO. He can go intangible, so Superman can't even hit him. He could probably kill Superman the way Dr Doom killed Susan when he had the Power Cosmic.

Originally posted by janus77
movie Surfer sucked a lot and.... well, Superman from Superman Returns fought the effects of Kryptonite really impressively.

I'd say 6/10 to Superman. Surfer is powerful enough to beat him given the kind of shit he was doing to the Earth (with supreme ease) and given the speed advantage (film Superman was quite slow in comparison) but, Surfer was stupid and could be removed from his board...


agreed movies supe>then movie SS


but in comics ...well thats another story.

Superman

Supes i think.. both movies sucked so it`s not like I`ve watched them more than once.

Superman

Arguably the Routh Supes is also Reeves supes and he could go through time.
SS can turn intangible though.

SS took it to Galactus and saved Earth!

SS..he is just more powerful..